Ben Higgins Is Reportedly Dating Robby Hayes's 'Other Woman'

Ben Higgins

Robby Hayes completely blew it with Amanda Stanton, as we learned earlier this week on the finale of Bachelor in Paradise. He reportedly cheated on her at a concert in Colorado, and now we're learning that he couldn't even work it out with that girl either, because she is now allegedly dating yet another Bachelor hunk.


So Robby spent the majority of BIP wooing Amanda, even though she was initially reluctant to his advances. They finally became a thing, even though she didn't want to go to the fantasy suite with him. They apparently kept dating however, at least until July, when Robby was caught canoodling another woman, identified as Lindsey Duke.

Robby and Lindsey knew each other from when they both lived in Florida, and had hooked up a time or two. They reconnected at the Zac Brown Band concert in Colorado over the summer, and someone sent Amanda a picture of them making out. Classy, Robby.

More from CafeMom: Dean Unglert Gets Real About His 'Bachelor in Paradise' Love Life

Anyway, according to Reality Steve (who, let's face it, knows everything about everyone on reality TV), Lindsey is now dating former Bachelor star Ben Higgins. Lauren Bushnell's ex was in Denver recently for a guest bartending stint at Sloan's Lake Tap and Burger, to raise money for the victims of Hurricane Harvey.

Lindsey was at the same event, and the two reportedly even left together. Steve said that he couldn't show the pictures of them together for various reasons, but that he had seen them. And they were apparently spotted by fans at breakfast together the next morning.

More from CafeMom: Chris Soules & Andi Dorfman Spotted Having Lunch Together

This lady may definitely have a type, as she has also reportedly dated Jef Holm, who was the winner of Emily Maynard's season of The Bachelorette.

Whatever is happening with Lindsey and Ben, we're glad that she's moved on from Robby. Given the confidentiality clause the stars have to sign, she probably didn't even know he was dating anyone when they kissed at the concert. We're just going to go ahead and give her the benefit of the doubt here.

Read More >