Andi Dorfman Accused of Cheating on Josh Murray ... With His Brother

Andi Dorfman Josh Murray

Even though Bachelor Nation relationships don't always have the best staying power, it was still shocking when Andi Dorfman and Josh Murray ended their engagement in January, just days after they'd appeared at the Bachelor premiere together as a happy couple. And although Andi appeared on a Bachelor special to dish about their breakup with Chris Harrison a few weeks later, is it possible there's a big piece of the puzzle she's not filling us in on? According to RadarOnline, Andi reportedly cheated on Josh with his brother, Aaron.


And that is reportedly what led to the end of their relationship -- not that they simply realized they weren't right for each other ... and that would explain why both Josh's and Aaron's engagements ended so close together.

Allegedly, Aaron's ex-fiancée's grandmother talked to Radar and said that "[Aaron] knows what he did," although she wouldn't confirm or deny the whole cheating thing.

More from The Stir: Andi Dorfman & Josh Murray's Twitter Fight Says It All

I can't help but feel like we should take this rumor with a grain of salt. From everything Andi's showed us, she seems like she'd be a faithful partner. It'd be super surprising if she cheated on Josh -- especially with his own bro. That's low! 

If this story is true, the truth will come out eventually. But far more likely? It's just another rumor. Sorry, but I'm #TeamAndi on this one. Her relationship with Josh seemed like it was so real to her, and I doubt she'd jeopardize that by sleeping with his brother.


Image via Allan Bregg/Splash News

Read More >