Photo by lovesamelia
Dear MrsManners,
Is shyness bad manners?
An older woman told me my child was not well behaved because she gets shy around new people. I don't see any problems with it -- I actually like that she won't go to any person who speaks to her. --nattabugsmommy
MrsManners says:
No! Shyness does NOT mean your daughter has bad manners. I can hardly believe someone had the audacity to say this to you! However, teaching your child more in depth manners may in fact help her feel less shy around others.
Try not to think about whether she will go to some random person, but rather, how she feels in those situations. The question to ask is if she is uncomfortable around other people. If she is, then you should try and help her, at some point in her life it could become a hindrance to her.
There is something that I teach called situational confidence and it is quite important, especially for some children. After all, if she is confident in any situation, then she'll know not to talk to a stranger, but she will not be afraid either. Instead, she will know how to handle anything that comes her way.
Here's the catch, all of this sounds really great, but how old is she? These are not skills that a toddler will normally possess, nor are they prepared to learn quite yet. It is completely normal for a toddler to just go through a general fear of strangers, period. This may be exactly what your dear daughter is experiencing.
As parents, all we can do is lay the foundation for good manners and situational confidence. The best way to do that is by showing her through your actions. Are you comfortable around new people? Do you extend your hand when greeting someone new? Do you make eye contact when speaking? Do you smile? For some parents, this can be more difficult than it sounds. There may be those of you out there who are not comfortable in social settings because perhaps you weren't given the opportunity to learn how to be. Take THIS opportunity to learn, it will not just help you, but your toddler too.
Here is something that I do with my little ones in class. I have my Manners Monkey, which is a stuffed animal with very distinctive "hands" and very floppy arms. It is scary for a child to even think about approaching an adult and shaking hands or making eye contact. So start with a stuffed animal first.
- Teach them how to shake hands, I like to do a count of three up and downs, have them look the stuffed animal in the eyes and smile while they are doing this. It feels like more of a game to them, but it gets them acclimated to the concepts.
- If your child is really into it, then go ahead and add the introduction part in. Hello, my name is Alex, (shake, shake, shake) it's nice to meet you. However, your child may not be ready to use this skill with a new person for quite some time.
- Your next step would be to practice with your child, then friends that she may be comfortable with.
- Finally she will be ready to meet people in public. This is when you explain that she is NEVER to approach another person to make an introduction but rather, she should only speak to a stranger if you or her father have talked to them first and indicate it is okay. I have worked with three year olds who could do all of this, but still weren't quite ready to do it with someone new. By age four, no problem!
I hope that you know you have done nothing wrong as a mother, your child is young and the woman who spoke to you was just flat out of line!
Got a question for MrsManners? Ask it here!
Mastectomy Photos Banned in Another Facebook Fail
Arrest in Etan Patz Missing Child Case (VIDEO)
A Chilling Past Life Experience Recounted
3 Red White & Blue Cocktails
Controversy: Gwen Stefani Bleaches Her Son's Hair
A '50 Shades of Grey' Shortcut for Busy Moms
Latest on Baby in Washing Machine Case (VIDEO)
Are People Who Eat Organic Judgy & Mean?
A Dad's Perspective on Playdates
Bagged Salad Recall Sparks New Fears
Help Dying 4-Year-Old Fulfill His Bucket List (VIDEO)
Melissa McCarthy & Sandra Bullock's Buddy Cop Movie
Do Working Moms Have It Easy?
Your Morning Coffee Could Save Your Life
Join the Fight Against Toxic Kids' Products
Ashley Is a Widow Who Stays Strong...
Stephanie is a Surrogate Mom
I Named My Kid SpongeBob!
Emma Lives with Severe Food Allergies

Comments (9)
My son at less than 18 months old learned how to shake hands and say nice to meet you. My husband was an Army recruiter at the time so anytime we saw his coworkers or other area recruiters they would shake my husband's hand and also mine. He learned just by watching. Now at 2 1/2 if anyone says hi and that he is cute, he looks at them with a serious look and says No, I'm Ethan S****. He also knows how to say please and thank you when he asks for something, and will tell you you're welcome if you say thank you to him. I believe you are never to young to be polite. My son also shys away from strangers now but as a very young toddler he would walk up to a stranger in the store and try to take them for a walk. Now he knows you don't go away from mommy unless she says it is okay.
Good article. I had a friend once tell me (when I was preggo with #1) that she couldn't stand babies/kids who were clingy and had to be near their parents all the time. I thoguht, WTH do you care?
Shyness is NOT impolite! Geez, some people.
ANyone that would say a small child wasn't polite because they don't talk to strangers is out of their minds. What's WORSE would be to force your child to interact with people when they didn't want to.
Shyness is a character trait.Not impolite. Everybody doesn't have to have a big mouth to be polite.You should have told the lady well children and dogs sense good people and when they sense they are bad they don't want to TALK and interact with them.Maybe that's why she's shy around you.Maybe she'd get the POINT of how ignorant her comment to you was.
SHYNESS IS NOT IMPLITE. if there's some one you want your child 2 meet and the child doesn't want 2 respond that doesn't mean there impolite there just shy Ca's they don't know them. a mother shouldn't make her child say hi if they don't want to. that's messed up[
Trying to make a shy child change would make them feel they aren't adequate as they are. My middle daughter was painfully shy when she was little - she couldn't even look at people who were trying to speak with her but she got over it on her own. It didn't bother me one bit.
i was shy as a child....it always embarssaed my mom and gandparents... i think kids will come around to strangers when they feel comfortable..
I have super bright RED hair... it draws attention WHERE EVER i go... when i was a little girl i HATED for people to single me out and tell me or my mom or grandparents how beautifull my hair was. when ever anyone would say anything i'd just glare at them....everyone would always have to prompt me to say thank you bc hated being singeld out.
My son is shy around strangers - and frankly, I'm glad. I wouldn't want my son being too friendly, you never know who might want to snatch up a little boy...
He does take some time to warm up to new people, but when he does, he really likes them. My husband has a friend who my son took forever to like, but now that he's come over quite a bit, my son just loves him.
I don't force my children to interact beyond greeting and answering questions if asked. They are required to use their manners which means NOT ignoring people who compliment them or speak to them. My children are not unattended in public so "running off with a stranger" is not an issue. We have discussed stranger danger. It's never too early to begin to learn social skills.