I had my first child in 2005, my second in 2008. Prior to two years ago, I worked full-time outside the home. These days I work from home -- mostly part-time, depending on my freelance client load -- while taking care of my kids.
I tell you that only so I can say that given my own background and experience with balancing work and parenthood, I'm not terribly surprised by the recent study that shows moms who work full-time are healthier than moms who stay at home.
Not because moms who work are better off. But because moms who are free to make their own choices are.
Here's what the study shows: moms who work steadily full-time after the birth of their first child are healthier at age 40 than moms who stay at home, work part-time, or moms who find themselves repeatedly out of work.
Researchers from the University of Akron in Ohio studied 2,540 women who had children between 1978 and 1995. After adjusting for other factors that could influence the findings (like prior health, employment before pregnancy, race/ethnicity, single motherhood, cognitive ability, and age at first birth), they found the choices women make early in their professional lives can influence their health later on:
Women who go back to full time work shortly after having children reported better health, both physical and mental. They have more mobility, less tendency to depression, and have more energy, at age 40.
We can probably make a few assumptions from this study -- for instance, the working women likely had more access to childcare, more education, and relatively stable home lives. It stands to reason they'd be healthier later in the life. But I think we can also assume that they were healthier because they were following their own paths.
Now, I'm not saying that every single mother who works is doing so because it's their choice. Some women choose to work, some women choose to stay home, some women would rather stay home but have to work in order to take care of their families.
In other words, BREAKING NEWS FROM THE NO-SHIT GAZETTE: we're not all the same.
Personally, I've found that it's all hard. It's hard to work outside the home and miss your family, it's hard to work from home and not feel like you're ignoring your family. It's draining being home with kids all day, it's painful not to see them until dinnertime. It sucks not earning a salary at all, it sucks earning a salary and paying a bunch of it to daycare.
There are pros and cons to everything, and every single person's situation is different. I feel incredibly blessed that I've found the balance that works for me, and I have no doubt that I will be healthier at 40 than I would have been had I stayed at my unrewarding office job.
The shrieking of the 'mommy wars' might occasionally drown out common sense, but the truth is, all moms aren't meant to make the exact same choices. If nothing else, this study surely proves that not every woman is better off staying home with her kids. So maybe it's time to drop the attacks, the guilt, and wake up to the reality that what's best for mom is best for her family -- period.
Did you get to make the choice you wanted after having kids? Are you happier for it?
Image via Tom Carmony/Flickr


Ashley Is a Widow Who Stays Strong...
This Hot Dad Wants to Vacuum Your Rug
This Hot Dad Wants to Do Your Ironing
KStew Refuses to Shower
















Comments 51
I work for a local school district as an aide. It doesn't pay much, but I am able to get health insurance for my family. My husband is self employed so insurance is a big deal to us. I am able to be home 10 minutes after my kids get off the bus and I am home with them all summer. If the kids are out of school then I am off of work for the most part. There are a few training days that I have to find babysitters for, but it is a vast improvement from paying hundreds of dollars for daycare.
I went back to work full time when my daughter was 8 weeks old. That meant she had to go to daycare. My husband and I fought it as much as we could, but we were fortunate and found an amazing school for her. She's thriving socially, has a great deal of self-confidence, is learning so much more than I could ever teach her, has lots of friends and is loved by many, many people. Of course, I don't get much time with her during the week, but what time we do have together we don't waste. And when we're out and about and run into a teacher, it's wonderful that she knows other adults whom she can trust.
I applaud any mom who can stay at home with their children. When I'm alone with my daughter on Sundays, when her dad has to work, I'm exhausted and starving and always looking for something new and exciting for her to do. Stay-at-home moms rock for being able to do that every day. But I am happy that my daughter is in a safe, nuturing environment when I'm away from her.
I left a stressful and demanding career 11 years ago to be a SAHM, and can honestly say I'm much healthier, emotionally and physically. But this is definitely a case of to each his/her own. I have time now to take care of myself, eat healthier rather than skipping meals or just grabbing whatever, exercising regularly, etc. I'm not working 60+ stressful hours/week and running on emotional fumes much of the time. I'm truly happy being with my kids all the time, and don't regret or resent being a SAHM :).
I have little regard for statistics. The littlest variable throws them either way. I think that moms who do what they want are healthier. I have mom friends that are full on homebodies (crunchy, homeschooling, and absolutely wonderful) and ones who are career women (Driven, Business savvy, and not one hair out of place) and the ones who work/stay at home because they want to are the healthiest. Point is Happy = Healthy. When my munchkin was born my mother encouraged me to go back to work and my mother-in-law encouraged me to stay home. For me, home was where I wanted to be. I'm an engineer so I can always teach tech if I want, but I am happy with my choice.
Oh... and side note. My mother was full on career woman. I did horribly in daycare. However, now that I am older, I am glad she did what she wanted to. She was SAHM when I was eleven and nearly drove me nuts because she was miserable. It was at that point I started researching bording schools. While happy mom does not equal happy kids... Miserable mom definitely equals unhappy kids.
I usef to work full time , and my mother in law will take care of the twins , am expecting a lil boy now and I been staying at home for a couple months now and honestly DO NOT miss going to work , am also a firm believer that if you are mentally healthy youll be physically healthy as well .
Positive emotions are the bomb