Follow The Stir

Say What!?

New Rules About Nudity & Profanity on TV Mean Moms Need a New 'Babysitter'

by Adriana Velez on June 21, 2012 at 3:04 PM

kid televisionHey parents, remember when actress Charlotte Ross' buns got their seven seconds of fame on NYPD Blue? And when Cher and Nicole Ritchie blurted out curse words at live awards shows? Well it's official: They got away with it. The Supreme Court ruled that it was unconstitutional for the FCC to fine broadcasters for those fleeting moments of nudity and profanity.

But that was then and this is now. The Supreme Court did NOT rule on whether it's okay to fine broadcasters for nudity and profanity in the future. They said the FCC could make new rules about that, you know, whenever. Which brings me to this question: What are parents supposed to do in the meantime?

Just to be clear, the Supreme Court's ruling had nothing to do with parenting or morality. This comes down to a technicality -- something to do with the FCC not giving networks enough notice before fining them ... bla bla bla.

More from The Stir: Television for Toddlers: Even When It's Good It's Still Kind of Bad

Anyway, now it's an open question. The FCC can make new rules about brief profanity and nudity during prime time. But some folks say that's just more government intrusion. Like, why can't parents just not let their kids watch the bad stuff, or something. It's your responsibility!

ORLLY? Let's imagine a world where broadcasters are allowed to do whatever the hell they want.

Your kids go to bed at 8:00. You turn on your grown-up TV show. Your 3-year-old can't sleep and sneaks into the living room just as someone streaks across your screen in their birthday suit.

Or: You let your 8-year-old Gleek stay up to watch the Emmys. Darren Criss lets loose an F-bomb.

Or: A real-life example, that time before cable TV was regulated and my young siblings and I stumbled upon full-frontal strip tease at 2:00 in the afternoon. Yes, that happened. No, our parents never found out. Yes, we were kind of freaked out to learn grown-ups take off their clothes for each other just for fun.

So now you have to have one of those conversations with your kid. And you find yourself saying, "I know I said that word, too, last Friday, and I shouldn't have." Or you say, "Well, the human body is beautiful, but in our family, we kind of like to keep our private parts to ourselves because, um ... (???)"

Ugh. You know what? I know times are changing. And I don't want to go back to the days of Leave It to Beaver. But I am also not so desperate for one of those "I'm the Only Person Responsible for Raising This Child" medals of honor that I can't appreciate a little bit of help from the FCC. I mean, rules need to be clear and a little more liberal. But I'd still like there to be at least some baseline of acceptability on prime time television.

This video can not be viewed on The Stir Mobile.

Should the FCC have rules on profanity and nudity for prime time television? What should those rules be?

 

Image via woodleywonderworks/Flickr

Filed Under: fun & games, in the news

Comments

37
  • kuwel...
    --

    kuwelsdestiny

    June 21, 2012 at 3:20 PM
    I actually DO miss the Leave It To Beaver days. I banned cable from my house because even during children's television shows, the COMMERCIALS are horrible. All TV sells anymore is casual sex and bad behavior. Its not just nudity, its just... well, everything.
  • Kate
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Kate

    June 21, 2012 at 3:20 PM
    To suggest that the Supreme Court should base any of their decisions on what is considered "good parenting" is absolutely ridiculous. They base their decisions on what is constitutional, and there is nothing in the constitution about what is appropriate parenting.
  • Lulu425
    --

    Lulu425

    June 21, 2012 at 3:22 PM

    There should be rules but the FCC can't patrol everything.

    In your example, your kid comes downstairs at 8PM as you're watching your prime-time television show. What happens when your tween can't sleep and goes downstairs unsupervised and "stumbles upon" one of the late-night shows on one of the premium channels like HBO? You can't police everything. What about the internet? Browsers on cell phones? You're fighting a lost cause.


  • Lulu425
    --

    Lulu425

    June 21, 2012 at 3:24 PM

    Also, if you let your 8 year old watch Glee, the content of that show is questionable enough without you having to worry about an accidental swear word.


  • Odin
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Odin

    June 21, 2012 at 3:30 PM
    Right, kuwelsdestiny. In a free society we should be able to make those decisions for our selfs. In a high tech society, the technology exists for all electronic media to be rated and for each subscriber to set the rating level they are willing to pay for. The stupid commercials and government public service announcements and news need to be rated too. I hate it when the radio reports on a rape during prime time when the kids are around. One of these days I'll have to explain. If you want your kids to know, fine, set your ratings as you like. I would set my ratings for no reverence to sex, no profanity and no politics.
  • aunti...
    -- Nonmember comment from

    auntie judy

    June 21, 2012 at 3:38 PM
    If they don't hear it on TV, they will hear it somewhere else. You can't expect your kids to live in a bubble. whatever happened to "parenting"? Let them hear it, then DISCUSS with them why certain words are not appropriate.
  • Elise48
    --

    Elise48

    June 21, 2012 at 3:47 PM

    Honestly, not one of those scenarios bothers me. In our house we don't believe in "bad words" and naked people = no big deal. Most children would rather be naked so I can't understand why seing others who want to be naked (for any reason) would bother them. Having "those conversations" with your children is one of the biggest parts of parenting. Fun? No. Necessary? Yes. You just have to deal with it.


  • Mandago
    --

    Mandago

    June 21, 2012 at 4:09 PM
    Elise48, you hit the nail on the head. My kid can say "bad" words as long as they're contextually appropriate, and can be naked as long as he's not fondling himself in common areas of the house. It doesn't bother me when he sees people acting like people on tv, and if there's something I don't agree with him seeing, I turn the channel! Sometimes we see something that I feel warrants a conversation, and that's okay, because I like talking to my kid. It seems to me that if you don't want to expose your child to profanity, nudity, violence, etc., then maybe you should limit your prime-time viewing to kids channels or DVDs.
  • dirti...
    --

    dirtiekittie

    June 21, 2012 at 4:10 PM

    i consider it a non-issue. why? because i don't care WHAT time of day it is, i usually know what my kids are watching. honestly, this is why we have our netflix streaming - the kids can watch their goofy cartoons and movies without me worrying about every little thing they're seeing. it doesn't matter what they show on tv, as long as you are around to supervise.

    and seriously - the tv is not a babysitter. stop treating it like one.


  • CPN322
    --

    CPN322

    June 21, 2012 at 4:17 PM

    Nudity, I understand, profanity, I don't. 


1-10 of 37 comments

To leave a comment, log in as a CafeMom member:

Log In

OR, use our non-member comment form: