Bristol Palin vs. 'Teen Mom' Stars -- Who Prevents More Teen Pregnancies?
Bristol PalinSo you have a teen-aged daughter with a serious boyfriend and you absolutely don't want her to get pregnant. You've talked yourself blue in the face about waiting to have sex and sexual responsibility and maybe even gotten her on birth control, but you'll take any other deterrent you can find.
So, for the sake of conversation, do you expose her to: a) Bristol Palin, who got knocked up despite mom Sarah Palin's abstinence message but went on to start a lucrative career as a celebrity teen mom and teen pregnancy prevention and abstinence advocate, or b) the average, screwed-up stars of MTV's Teen Mom reality show who agree to show us the true grit of teen motherhood in every episode?
Bristol Palin and the stars of Teen Mom are all cashing in to varying degrees on youthful mommyhood, but are any of them actually helping to prevent future unwanted pregnancies? If so, who's doing a better job?
It was revealed this week that Bristol Palin was paid a salary of $262,500 in 2009 by a teen pregnancy prevention nonprofit called the Candie’s Foundation. She did work to earn this money, but I am curious to know if she prevented a single pregnancy during that campaign. I mean, with the immense support she gets from her famous family and the enormous list of financial opportunities (can you say DWTS?), how does she serve as an example of what not to be? For one, no average teen is going to be able to relate to Bristol Palin or feel that she is anything like them. Secondly, if she makes it look easy (even though it's surely not), how is she actively deterring other teenagers from following in her footsteps?
Then there are the Teen Mom stars, who are rumored to have made $60,000-$65,000 a season. This is a very hefty salary for these young girls for sure, especially since they're all teenagers and at most from lower middle class families. However, the "goods" these girls are selling, unlike Bristol's, happen to be real peeks inside their struggle-filled lives, which can be pretty darn scary and horrifying. And isn't the truth and the ugliness what our teens really need to see, instead of a life like Bristol's, which fares far better than most hardworking American adults who have planned their lives and their pregnancies?
I get it -- celebrities get you noticed. However, we're talking about unwanted pregnancy here, not selling nail polish. I'm not sure an out-of-touch celebrity like Bristol Palin is making any difference for any young girl about to engage in unsafe sex.
Who do you think is the better advocate for teen pregnancy prevention? Feel free to say none of the above at this point, but tell us why.
Image via The Candie's Foundation
Piping Hot Posts
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
butterflymkm
Leanne Carnegie
I don't think it's a competition. The more teenage sex/pregnancy prevention out there, the better, right? Why should we attempt to judge who's "more effective". Different approaches work for different people.
And I don't think Bristol Palin is "out of touch". Yea, she's leading a very different life now than she did pre-2008 (when she got pregnant)... but that doesn't mean she can't talk to young girls about what not to do. Not everyone will have the opportunities, or fantastic family, like she has.
billsfan1104
xavierlogan09
i think the teen moms do. bristol palin has something a lot of them don't. money. she gets paid to be on the dwts although she isn't famous. she just got buzz because of her mother. i think it scares some teens when they watch teen mom. because they see how drastically life changes when you have a child. they see that you no longer get to be a teen but a mother for the rest of your life.
Amber Harris
Heather Robertson
Tabitha
sunnybunny5us
Wow, back when I was a teenager it was considered sophisticated to be "on the pill" . Maybe someone should be pushing that kind of thinking, instead of "how hard it is to take care of a baby" (because unless you are as stupid as every one of the teen moms on MTV is - it's not.The actual difficulty raising kids usually kicks in about 8-16 yrs later). But teen pregnancy is down, so maybe the awareness is helping.
Ef
Jenniy
Teen Mom.....