Follow The Stir

Twisted

People Calling Female Olympians 'Fat' Need to Get Off Their Couch

by Jill Baughman on August 6, 2012 at 2:10 PM

Holley Mangold
Holley Mangold
What would your first thought be if you heard about a 22-year-old woman who weighs 346 pounds? But then what would you think if I told you that this woman is an Olympic athlete?

Holley Mangold, an American weightlifter, is one of many Olympic athletes who are frustrated with the public's scrutiny of their weight. According to Yahoo, other athletes such as British heptathlon champion Jessica Ennis and Australian swimmer Liesel Jones have been called fat, by everyone from us everyday folks to the press.

Such a shame, especially since this is a historic Olympics for the Americans, in which there are more women participants than men. No one would think of calling a 300-pound male weightlifter fat, agreed? It's terrible that people can only seem to point out that they think these women are overweight ... there's just no way in my mind you can be unhealthy yet still be able to compete in the Olympics. And their health is what should be most important!

Want more examples? It seems the Australian media said Liesel Jones "did not look as fit as at Beijing in 2008." British swimmer Rebecca Adlington said she was going to avoid Twitter because of so many insults about her appearance. And the entire Brazilian women's soccer team were called "a bit heavy" by the Cameroon coach. What the hell?

As Mangold tweeted, "I'm not saying everyone is an athlete but I am saying an athlete can come in any size."

Preach, girl.

The article goes even more in depth -- saying that a negative body image makes women not want to exercise since they believe it's more important to be thin than fit. I mean, I can't even imagine what it must feel like to be in peak physical form to compete on a world stage and still be nitpicked over your weight and appearance. To put your heart and soul into your sport, get in front of an international audience and judges to perform ... only to have people call you fat and ugly on Twitter? Come on, society. Stop sucking.

We really need to back the heck off of Twitter and let these women enjoy representing their countries. Let's talk about how well they're doing instead of what they look like. What kind of message is this sending to young girls? It's terrible that people can be so mean-spirited to poke fun of an athlete's weight over discussing her talent and hard work.

Are you outraged by the unnecessary scrutiny placed on female Olympic athletes over their appearance? I am!

 

Image via Getty

Comments

32
  • missusmc
    --

    missusmc

    August 6, 2012 at 2:17 PM

    I'm really annoyed at the weight bashing for almost every female athlete, but I kind of agree with the criticism of the weight lifter.  Sure, she's mega talented and able to lift far more than I ever could, but at 346 pounds, can anyone be truly healthy?  Can she do cardio without her heart exploding?  I think some criticism of celebrating unbalanced athleticism (cardio without weight training and vice versa) is warranted. 


  • psugal
    --

    psugal

    August 6, 2012 at 2:24 PM

    Even if she is overweight public critism is not warrented.  She knows what she looks like and she knows what she is able to do - her physical appearance does not need to be brought up.  She clearly works with a coach who should be monitorring her health.  Let's celebrate her accomplishments instead of making her feel bad about herself.


  • Shelly
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Shelly

    August 6, 2012 at 2:25 PM
    346 pounds IS FAT. Extremely, fat. She is not an athlete. She is picking up heavy things and dropping them. I'm willing to bet she doesn't run, walk fast, or do anything other then pick up weights. I watched her and was horrified, that the woman could hardly walk! (This was before she lifted the weights, not after.) She is so heavy, she was struggling. I don't give a flip about her appearance, that woman is NOT healthy.
  • ambear
    -- Nonmember comment from

    ambear

    August 6, 2012 at 2:26 PM
    Holly was on an episode of MTV's documentary series True Life and had an amazingggg story. She was even her high school's quarterback
  • Rhond...
    --

    RhondaVeggie

    August 6, 2012 at 2:33 PM
    It's name calling when people call skinny little movie stars fat because their ribs don't protrude or they need a size two when buying jeans. It's not name calling when someone actually is fat, it's just stating a fact. Saying she is fat doesn't imply you don't respect her abilities or you think she shouldn't be in the Olympics. It just implies that she wears clothes with multiple Xs on the size tag. I'm fat and strong too, not as extreme as her but I do need to lose weight and I can lift significantly more than any other woman at my gym and most of the guys too. I'm not going to get upset if someone calls me fat because it's true. If they called me weak then yeah, they'd get a telling off. I have actually been known to pick people up if they try to argue that I'm exaggerating my lifting abilities, your average six foot tall guy is always pretty mortified to find that the little girl can pick him up like a baby. From interviews I have read with Holly Mangold it sounds like we have much the same attitude and we'd probably get along quite well.

  • LynBoz
    --

    LynBoz

    August 6, 2012 at 2:34 PM
    She is very overweight.
  • PonyC...
    --

    PonyChaser

    August 6, 2012 at 2:36 PM

    I think there is a lot more involved in being "healthy" than most people know. There are plenty of thin people out there who look healthy, who could not walk to the end of the block without getting winded, while someone who looks fat could run a 5K (or more) without batting an eye. And yet, that "fat" person will be bashed for being "unhealthy" and for courting heart disease, diabetes, etc., with nothing being directed at the thin person.

    What matters is how you feed your body. How you treat it. Obviously, these weight lifters exercise. A LOT. They eat a lot, too, to feed those bodies.

    Ever see what Michael Phelps eats? Carbs, sugar, more carbs, sugar, some protein (last Olympics, they profiled him. 25K calories in a day, and massive amounts of pancakes and french toast swimming in syrup for breakfast). And yet, nobody questions him because, well, he's Michael Phelps. He's thin, he's cut, look at those ABS!!! I'm not saying that he *should* be questioned, but if this weight lifter was eating the exact same diet, she'd be totally trashed because she's heavy.
    Such a pathetic double standard we have, based on nothing more than appearance.

  • the4m...
    --

    the4mutts

    August 6, 2012 at 2:38 PM
    A person CAN be overweight, and healthy. But not obese & healthy. She's obese. I'm sure she has a lot of muscle, but she also has a LOT of fat. I'm sure she knows it too.
    Therefore, I see no reason to point it out on twitter, or to actually criticize her for it.
    I do have a slight worry for her though. She's gone through all this work... what if she dies doing it? She SHOULD lose some weight, just so she lives long enough to continue her sport and enjoy her success to the fullest.
  • Kathr...
    -- Facebook comment from

    Kathryn Marie Precious

    August 6, 2012 at 2:42 PM
    Do they expect her to be 120lbs and lift the weights she does, I think not. I want to see a average person that had something to say about her or any of the other athletes weight, try and do what they do.
  • kaerae
    -- Nonmember comment from

    kaerae

    August 6, 2012 at 2:58 PM
    There are 2 separate issues here. The fact is, they are fat. They are also extremely talented athletes. That doesn't mean you are a "hater" if you acknowledge that they are fat by definition. They are both, and denying that they are fat does a disservice to people who are fat, not a favor. There are people who are both fat and fit, but they are the exception, and it's not the case with most fat Americans.
1-10 of 32 comments

To leave a comment, log in as a CafeMom member:

Log In

OR, use our non-member comment form: