Father Takes Disappointment of Having a Baby Girl Too Far

Heartbreaking 155

gloomy day lakeI think we all know that gender disappointment is a very real thing. Though most people can move on from it and put it behind them. I remember when I found out that my twins were one boy and one girl. I remember the look on my husband's face when he knew we were having a boy -- relief mixed with happiness. Of course we wanted healthy babies, but he wanted a boy, and that's okay. It's funny how now he and our daughter are nearly inseparable -- she is so Daddy's little girl.

Some people, however, cannot handle their gender disappointment. When one mother had given birth to her third girl, the father had the worst reaction anyone could ever imagine. He killed the mother of his three children.

This happened in Afghanistan where violence against women is reportedly out of control. The mother, whose name was Storai, was sadly killed at the hands of her husband who wanted that third child to be a boy. He strangled her three months after the birth. He is still at large and is said to be protected by militia, but his mother was arrested in connection with the murder. Such a sad and tragic story. I hope someone is taking good care of those three children.

Being a mother in other countries certainly presents different challenges than we face in the United States. Mama: Motherhood Around the Globe showed many instances and I was particularly struck by the mom from Kabul. But gender disappointment is a universal thing. Though it is also taken to extremes in China because of their one-child policy. In these instances, the family usually wants a boy. But if we overproduce boys, won't it throw off what I'll call "nature's balance"? Will the world end up with too many men and not enough women to give birth to future generations?

Or maybe we'll just end up with the male equivalent to Sister Wives. They would be called Brother Husbands, I guess. I highly doubt that could ever really happen on a large scale though.

We also have to remember that more and more women are opting to keep their maiden name, too. Some even give their children their maiden name as well. So maybe a non-traditional thought is needed here, for everyone. Though in countries very steeped in tradition, this may not be a welcome thing.

Call me biased, but women are wonderful. We are the ones who give birth. We are needed.

I hope anyone with gender disappointment is just disappointed and moves on. It's okay to have wanted a boy and had a girl -- or the other way around. But this type of violence against women (any violence really) is nonsensical. The man's sperm had a vital part in making the baby -- it's his sperm that determines the gender. Not that I want to point blame because it is so random with millions of sperm being released when you make a baby. A baby being born is a miracle in my eyes -- boy or girl.

Do you think the way many women are keeping their maiden names will help some with gender disappointment?


Image via Hamed Saber/Flickr

boy or girl, fathers


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Kritika Kritika

Did King Henry VIII come back from the dead?

Melis... Melissa042807

It IS a problem in China. Already they're seeing an increase in instances where young women are kidnapped, packed away to a remote village, and forced to marry older men who haven't found wives because there weren't enough women. Because of the "one child" policy. They shoulda seen that coming. 

Maias... MaiasMommy619

I dont see a correlation between a maiden name and gender disappointment..but either way its 10000% the mens sperm that determines  the sex of the baby..Mothers only donate the X chromosome whereas the men can donate either X or Y.

ashjo85 ashjo85

Yeah, I don't get your question. HERE, gender disappointment stems from the life you imagined diverging from the life you're now expecting. You wanted a boy who'd be the quarterback of the football team, and now you have three girls and your life is dance recitals and scaring boyfriends (I'm way generalizing here). I never met a guy in my life who wanted a boy just so he could pass on his name.

jalaz77 jalaz77

That is what I was thinking MaiasMommy619...if he wanted to kill someone he should have offed himself since the gender was HIS FAULT. Which shows how damn ignorant he is. Go figure his mother was involved somehow because she is partly to blame how this man behaved, she raised him. Such a messed up culture over there, it could be a beautiful place.

ivego... ivegotrhythm

How the HELL did you make the leap between a horrible act of violence and a woman keeping her maiden name?!?!,,__

Other... OtherMonkey

How on earth is keeping your maiden name and passing it to your children going to help here??  If someone wants a child of a particular sex, the name on the certificate won't mean anything - side note, these kinds of men probably don't end up marrying the type of woman who will end up keeping her name to begin with.  All that aside, these families/cultures are going to end up facing a harsh reality once their males outnumber their females because of them killing off baby girls.  How are they going to get their male offspring when there's no one left to procreate with?

Za245 Za245

I really dont see the correlation between gender disappointment and mothers keeping their maiden names.

Torra... TorranceMom

This man's mother was an accomplice in the crime as well.

kjjakjja kjjakjja

What does keeping the maiden name have to do with gender disappointment? Even a single mother might be disappointed by the baby's sex. Your point is not clear. Are you saying women who keep their maiden names are less likely to have a gender preference?

1-10 of 155 comments 12345 Last