10 Real Stories of Marriage Proposals Gone Wrong

engagement ringIt may be the first day of spring, but it's also National Proposal Day! Yes, it's true! And what better way to celebrate than by taking a microscope to some stunning findings from David's Bridal's 8th annual "What's on Brides' Minds" survey of newly engaged and married women? Hmm, actually, I guess being proposed to would be the best way -- even for those of us who are already hitched. Because if this survey is any indication, 1 in 2 of us would love a re-do proposal!

Well, 53 percent, in fact, said they'd change something about their proposal if they could: 22 percent would change the location; 14 percent something about their engagement ring; 14 percent wish different people had been present for the Q-popping; 10 percent wanted a different engagement date; and 3 percent would change something else. Ouch!

So, to test these stunning stats ourselves, we asked real women to share about the proposals they wish had gone down (even a bit!) differently. Here, 10 proposals gone wrong ...

  1. "So it was my high school graduation party, and he'd had a few too many. He got down on BOTH knees in my parents' house and asked me to marry him. I didn't know if he was being serious ... or would remember it later! Fortunately he did and said he meant it, but well, needless to say, I'd much rather have had a sober proposal I could have been 'sure' of!"
  2. "We had spent all day apple picking in beautiful rolling hills. Dropped our friends off at home, and then he proposed while we were sitting in the car outside of their house! I was such a brat. I made him drive to a park and ask again!"
  3. "He did it in Vegas on our one-year anniversary. I was getting dressed for dinner and he was acting all weird. I knew something was going down. And then, when I asked him how I looked, he said, 'Great, but your outfit is missing something.' Then he got down on one knee, yada, yada, yada. Showed me the ring, which he had bought like the day before without putting any research in. I was so bummed that it wasn't this huge surprise."
  4. "My ex proposed in a Safeway parking lot. I frequently wonder why I married the man."
  5. "I wish I was dressed up instead of in sweats and hungover! And I wish my neighbors, who we hated, weren’t the ones who decorated our apartment with flowers while we were out. It was so weird when they came over afterwards!"
  6. "After dating for only three or four months, I told my then-boyfriend (now ex-husband) that I loved him, and instead of just saying 'I love you' back, he skipped that step and asked me how I’d feel about a summer wedding the following year. (Whatever, I was 24, so I was thrilled.) We designed our own rings and had them made in a shop in the East Village, which was really cool. But I never got that iconic proposal moment. After we picked up the rings, he did this jokey mock proposal in his bedroom. He got down on one knee and was all, 'Haha, will you marry me?' SIGH."
  7. "He proposed at my parents' house when I was home from college, before we went out to dinner at his favorite restaurant with my ex-boyfriend (who he was friends with and I remained friendly with, but still!). I should have asked for a do-over ..."
  8. "My husband proposed at this very nice mountain house, and I kind of knew it was coming, because I’m just so intuitive about stuff like that, but didn’t want to ruin the surprise. We went for a hike, and I could tell he was trying to find just the right opportunity to ask me, but chickened out a couple times. When we were in having tea in the big, public sitting room -- which was packed because they had a fire and it was a cold day -- he got down on his knee and pulled out the ring. I grabbed the box closed, took the ring, and ran from the room. I was so embarrassed. He knew how I hated doing things like that in public, and I panicked with all those people looking for us. When we got outside I said yes and hugged him, but not before I scolded him for doing that to me when he KNOWS I hate to be the center of attention. Funny thing is, I wouldn’t change how it happened because it was just so 'me' and so 'us.' We never go by the book!"
  9. "We drove to Key West for the weekend, and my husband’s plan was to propose on the pier as the sun was setting the next day, because he knows how much I love watching the sun set. But he just couldn't wait (no patience at all -- LOL!). We arrived in Key West at like 11 p.m., and he said, 'Let’s go for a walk,' but that was totally out of character for him, given we’d just driven four hours, and he was exhausted. So I kind of knew something was up. We walked along the beach for half a minute and he got down on one knee ... and although it was beautiful (I really shouldn’t be complaining!), it kind of would have been nice to have him propose as the sun was setting on the pier."
  10. "My DH is never good at keeping secrets, and that includes presents. He usually buys my gift for birthdays and Christmas the day before. ... Well, he went with my little brother and bought my engagement ring and had it all ready for an upcoming trip. We ended up getting into an argument the day after he bought the ring (something stupid about car insurance), and he decided that the best way to end the argument was to propose to me there on the spot. Of course I loved the ring, and I said yes, but I still wish he wouldn't have used that time to propose. Now every time I think about how we got engaged, I just remember that he wanted to make monthly payments on our car insurance, and I wanted to make annual payments. Very romantic." 

Be honest: How do you feel about your proposal? Would you want a do-over?

Image via Andrew Abogado/Flickr

weddings, love, marriage, proposals


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

linzemae linzemae

The Vegas one was super cute!

SaphireH SaphireH

i got my do over last night and i loved it. my hubby and i got married nov of 08, we had very little money so i never got a ring, we used one that my mom got me for xmas years before and he proposed after sex so it wasnt very special at all and we got married at the court house with 2 friends. We have been talking about how one day we would get remarried and be able to finally share the day with our friends and families when we could afford it, well last night i got a surprise trip to my favorite place The Melting pot and when we got to the table my best friend was there and i was confused thinking we were setting him up on a date and i just wasnt told because i would have blabbed to him and when i sat down at the booth i looked to my husband to ask what was going on he was down on one knee with a ring in his hand asking me to marry him and my best friend took a couple of pictures for us. it was all perfect i loved it, my hubby then admited to me later he had spent the past month trying to plan it out and everything kept messing up so he decided to just improvise it all and it worked out. i was so surprised at everything especially my ring because it is a replica from my all time favorite move The Crow and i always wanted to have the ring Eric Draven gives to his fiancee Shelly Webster

zombi... zombiemommy916

My husband proposed on the bathroom floor...next to the toilet...I was in the mirror, getting ready for a fancy birthday dinner and I looked down and there he was, asking "so what are you doing for the rest of your life?"...we'd already been together 14 years so I kind of expected something more romantic but he's so private...bathroom private, apparently

nonmember avatar Taylor

My fiancé proposed to me just before our one year anniversary, but we have been close since we were 10 years old. We were laying on the bed watching tv one night and I was picking at him, pouting because I keep getting called the unwed housewife by EVERYONE. He looked me in the eye and said, well I was gonna wait until friday (our anniversary) but I think I'd rather do this now, I was so confused, he snuggled up real close and grabbed both sides of my face and said "so will you be Mrs. Donnelly?" Of course I said yes. I honestly wouldn't change that moment for anything. We love to watch movies and just cuddle. It was perfect. Even though he later told me he thought I really was upset and really didn't think he wanted to be with me... He's really good at over analyzing things sometimes.

happymia happymia

We had just turned 18, our son was a month old, and we were in bed(at my mom's house). I said to him that we should just get married, he said ok. Then he said, so are we engaged? I said sure. Worst proposal ever, but we'll be married 15 years next week.

white... whitetrashqueen

My ex boyfriend proposed to me right after I had a panic attack. We had an argument (dont even remember what it was about) we were in a cheap, run down hotel. He just got out of jail few days before. I went to take a shower to calm down and when I got out thats when he threw the ring at me and walked out. I was 19 at the time and of course being young and dumb thought I would never find any better. 2 weeks later my parents were in a really bad car accident so I made the choice to move back home to take care of them and for chosing my parents over him I never saw him again. Although for almost a year he kept texting me, finally had to change my #.  Now at 25 finally have my perfect boyfriend and couldnt ask for more :)

nonmember avatar Me

my man proposed to me on April fools day..

Jasmine Swenk

When my hubby and I first started dating he asked me out by trying to be all cool and sayig "so what do you think about that boyfriend/ girlfriend BS?" I thought it was adorable and we started dating. well we split up for 7 years and he was now in the Army. when we got back together he had to go to Korea for a year. The night I went to his families house to pick him up from the airport he proposed to me.  The moment we got back from the Airport he sat me down in a chair got down on one knee and opened the box saying "so how about that husband/ wife BS?" I loved it! The fact that he remembered after all those years! It was perfect! Of course I had already known we were engaged I had been planning our wedding for 6 months. and I had kind of seen my ring via text. But I guess his Skype proposal wasn't good enough for him. 

B1Bomber B1Bomber

I guess I just cant fathom being disappointed in agreeing to spend the rest of your life with the man you love, no matter whether he asked while rappeling from the Empire State building during a flash mob or on the phone on the way to work.

1-10 of 19 comments 12 Last