An Engagement Ring From a Big Retail Chain Store Is Just Tacky & Tasteless

Rant 141

Recently, a woman confessed in CafeMom that she found out her fiance had bought her engagement ring at a big chain store. She admitted she was upset about it and asked if others would be. Wellllllllz ... the first answer pretty much summed up the universal holier than thou response: "No. I am not materialistic." At first, I had the same thought. Hey, it's not about the ring, Miss Hoity-Toity! It's about the person, the relationship ... yada yada.

But then I sat with the question. I pictured myself opening up a box and inside finding a lovely ring. And then I pictured looking that ring up online and discovering it came from some big chain retail store. Or actually seeing that name on the box. And I had to admit I'd be -- something. Maybe not mad. But definitely not happy. Yet I'm not a materialistic person. No romantic partner has ever paid for a single day of my upkeep. I wear thrift store clothes until they have holes in them. So what gives?

A ring from some big box store reeks of, "I just happened to drive by a Big Store XYZ and was like, 'Oh yeah, better stop in and get a ring.'" It smacks of putting no thought into it. Like, Hey, lemme pick up some Pringles, pudding packs, spiral notebooks, and an engagement ring!

And no, I'm not materialistic. In fact, I was quite happy with the engagement ring my fiance gave me -- and that was FREE. He spent ZERO money on it. That's because he got it from his mother, who was given the ring by her husband on the occasion of my fiance's birth. In fact, I was glad he hadn't spent money on it because at the time neither one of us had much. And it came with special meaning.

I also don't agree with what big box stores stand for -- billions in profits that are not passed along in health care or livable employee wages, and prices so low that it forces small local shops out of business and closes plants that open up overseas where they can pay people much, much less. I don't give those places business if I can help it, so I certainly don't want to look at their brand name on my left hand for the next however-many years. (Here we could get into the ethics of buying diamonds in general, but that's another post.)

If you don't have much money, there are other places you can go for an affordable ring. EBay. Craigslist. Vintage stores. (Personally, I love the idea of getting a great classy ring for a decent price just because someone else happened to wear it.) I guess if there isn't ANY other place to buy a diamond beyond a big box store in your hometown, and your guy didn't want one sent through the mail, then so be it. But it still smacks of lazy to me.

Would I break up with a guy over a generic big retail store ring? Of course not. Would I pout about it endlessly? I hope not. But something deep, deep inside of me would shudder. And not in a good way.

Would you be upset if your ring was from a big chain store?


Image via wwarby/Flickr

marriage, romance tip, love


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

kelti... kelticmom

What. A. Freaking. Ungrateful. Snob. Ugh. I can't even.....

Laurlev Laurlev


silve... silverdawn99

i would be happy with whatever my s/o gave me. (my dh bought my ring for little money and i love it!)

fleur... fleurdelys3110

I consider myself to be quite materialistic. I only wear the best brands of clothing, shoes, makeup, etc. However, I would not not be upset if my ring came from a place like Zales as long as it is a quality stone with good cut, clarity, and color. Most engagement rings from upscale retailers such as Tiffany, Cartier, Harry Winston, etc. are RIDICULOUSLY overpriced. As long as the ring is of good quality (and big enough), I couldn't care less where it came from. 

Pinst... Pinstripes4

People buy what they can afford. That's pretty much how it goes.

names... namestaken

You are what they call a self righteous hypocrite.

Dawn Marckwardt-Harville

My first husband got my engagement ring at Wal-Mart, and I LOVED it. My current engaement ring is one of those gaudy fake silver $9.88 rings they sell at walmart, and it still means more to me than an expensive ring from Zales or Jareds would ever mean.  People read too much into shit. Why do some women think that the more expensive the ring, the more they love you. It is BS.

Bloom... Bloomie79

I think we're talking about Walmart not zales here... And really if your not happy with your ring, speak up, shop together, and be reasonable. Maybe he thought that's all he could afford, maybe he was intimidated by mall jewelry stores, maybe he just didn't know. If he loves you he will understand, and if you love him you won't be so upset about a ring.

Aeris... AerisKate

I think it is more ridiculous to go in to debt over a ring.  I was just so happy to get engaged to my husband that he could have proposed with a plastic ring from a gumball machine and I would have been happy.  Of course, I don't like to wear jewelry and haven't worn any rings since my first child was born 4 years ago.   Anyway...if you can afford an expensive ring and that's what you like, go for it.  But don't knock people who can't afford those and don't want to go in to debt just to have one.  I don't think it says lazy at all. Someone could put just as much (or as little) thought in to a ring from Walmart as one from Zales or Tiffanies. 

1-10 of 141 comments 12345 Last