25 Weirdest & Most Hilarious Online Dating Screen Names


love onlineWhen people find out I married a guy I met on the Internet, I am prepared for the inevitable question: how could you be sure you knew the real him? In the age of Catfish, it's a fair question. But then, if you've done any Internet dating, you know there's one quick way to strike at least a few of the crazies right off your list.

Take a look at their screen name. Does it make you laugh? In a good way or in a "OMG what kind of nutbag loser would actually put that out there?" There you go. The Internet dating world is full of nutbag losers, and their hilariously awful screen names are like big flashing warning signs.

Not sure what I'm talking about? The Stir talked to some Internet daters and rounded up some of the absolute worst dating profile names they've seen on the Internet. Believe it or not, they're all real ... sadly!

Farmers Only. This site gives you just a little screen name space to grab attention, so you have to make the most of it. And these people did. Boy did they ever:

GitMeDun -- Hmm, wonder what he wants?

GetatMeBaby -- Ditto (note this is the female version)

PullingTeats -- Please be referring to a cow's teats, please be referring to a cow's teats, please be referring ...

YourHero -- Oh man, it couldn't get cheesier if it were a block of cheddar!

MaleDNAFarmer -- Is that like saying you like to sow your seed?

BakedFrogLegs -- Um, what?


Imhisforever -- Well, that doesn't leave much room for love, now does it?

SnotCat2 -- Yes, nothing sound sexier than your cat's snot.


SexySpazz -- Don't these two words mean the exact opposite of each other?

pickofdestiny4u -- We get it, you have a realllllly high opinion of yourself.

InsuranceSeller -- Dude, did you really just lead with that? No one's picking up your calls now!

fatbikerballs -- Turns out there IS something creepier than that pair of metal testicles hanging off the back of a pick-up truck.

YesYesOhGodYes -- Be warned: he's a screamer.

Creepy_stranger -- Isn't he the one we're supposed to AVOID?

Hurtone4u -- Nothing screams creepy control freak like this guy's screen name.

Needsisterwife -- Isn't there a site made specifically for these people?

BostonFootLover -- So does his fetish exist outside of Beantown?

hottestguyonOKC -- Clearly someone in need of some self-esteem.

Pootieboi -- What? Huh? Maybe we don't want to know.

muffinthumper -- The image. The image.

FyUoCuK -- Yes, we see what you did there. Doesn't make you clever ... or attractive.

Wasteofair -- Why not just name yourself "miserable a-hole" and be done with it?

Plenty of Fish -- This site doesn't just have screen names! You have headlines to play with. Behold what people have come up with in the extra space:

Not an Internet Killer -- Now THAT is reassuring, isn't it?

I Have All My Teeth/Hair -- Well, thank goodness for that.

Can you top all this crazy?


Image by Jeanne Sager

online dating


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

nonmember avatar Blush

STDMuffin...he chose it because StudMuffin was taken, not making the connection with STD. Nice guy, we dated for a while.

ethan... ethans_momma06

Sure can.

I have an email account that says something along the lines of youcancallmedaddy.

First of all, I'm a straight female woman. Secondly- imagine having to say that to the Target customer service guy, as you try to straighten out your on-line order.

Honestly, I think some of these are people with a sense of humor.

MaryC... MaryCimino

I used to have one on Christian Mingle called NoOneEver just so it would show up on their feed NoOneEver contacted you. Yeah I'm mean and I know it

Kissy... Kissybratzmom

A screen name from POF. 'PeteShagNasty' We briefly dated...before that horrid screen name. 1. His name was not Pete. 2. I can assure you that there was nothing nasty about his shag. It was the most boring sex of my life.

Stephie Lynne

the one on christian mingle, iamhisforever, whoever that was was refering to god..... the pick of destiny on, thats a movie title with jack black in it

nonmember avatar Daniel

Hilarious profile names indeed...one can find many such names on eHarmony, www.freakin-out.com, match.com, etc.

nonmember avatar SadieSabrina

A guy from Plenty of Fish contacted me, and his screen name was Sea_Squirt...1 date and he was clearly a loser!

nonmember avatar Nicole

I had a guy message me and his username was SilverTRD

nonmember avatar CumenCrumbs

I've had random/funny screen names on random things...


Hopscotch Johnny

Cum Crumbs

A Bull Supenis

Psycho Penis Pump

Cumen Crumbs (Cum Crumbs was reported)

Baby Eaten Fairy

and a few others. Most were just random, and not that funny. Damn ADHD, cursed it be...

1-9 of 9 comments