Emily Maynard May Have Slept With Arie in the Fantasy Suite Before Getting Engaged to Jef

Say What!? 29

emily maynardAs Bachelorette Emily Maynard rode off into the sunset with Jef Holm, did you happen to catch Arie Luyendyk chasing after their car yelling, "You just slept with me!" No? Well, that may be because the show's producers allegedly cut that bit out.

Us Weekly is reporting that Arie and Emily slept together before she made her final decision -- and he was outraged that she picked Jef anyway. But-but-but, didn't Emily say she wouldn't do the fantasy suite with anyone because she's "a mother and a role model"? Didn't we see Arie driving away? How could they have slept together?

So many questions. But if Emily did do the deed with Arie, I can totally see why.

I wouldn't be at all surprised if the rumor is true. You bet Emily would have been able to find a way to kick Arie's tires before deciding which car to claim. She was probably just dying to sleep with him. Because -- hello, the chemistry! And they didn't even have to do it in the "fantasy suite." There are many, many beds in America. Hell, you don't even need a bed.

But Emily has a squeaky-clean image she's trying to create and Jef Holm fits with that image so much better. Nice Mormon boy from Utah, running a business that delivers water to thirsty people in Africa? He's perfect! And "reining in their passions" just makes the two more virtuous and irresistible. It's like Emily took a page out of the Twlight books: Chastity is the new sexy. She had to pick him.

She also had to sleep with Arie. It was her last chance for a fling with a super-sexy stud before committing to her future husband. Call it a bachelorette party for two. What's that saying -- Why buy the cow if the milk is free? If Arie though sleeping with Emily would win her hand he obviously wasn't paying attention to the game Emily was playing.

Do you believe the rumor that Emily slept with Arie before choosing Jef?


Image via ABC

bachelor/bachelorette, celebs, commitment, hooking up


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

nonmember avatar kesp

This really bothers me, because I've never seen it be an issue in the media after a season of the Bachelor, and their multiple visits to the fantasy suite. Please.

berge... bergencounty

What's that saying -- Why buy the cow if the milk is free?

Did you mean  ...........  Why buy the pig if the sausage is free?sidesplittinglaughter

MrsCh... MrsChurch

I don't believe it for a second. But I totally wanted to sleep with Arie after seeing their chemistry!

fleur... fleurdelys3110

I do believe that this is possible. People are not always in real life what they make themselves out to be on tv. Yes, that includes someone as "sweet" and "innocent" as Emily Maynard!

Fondue Fondue

"Why buy the pig if the sausage is free?"

Love it!!!!

nonmember avatar Michelle

OMG...LOVE the sausage saying!
And you bet your ASS she slept with Arie! If I were in her shoes I would have done the same damn thing. Good for her!

CLM3345 CLM3345

"Why buy the pig if the sausage is free?"  LMAO!

Sex is so important in a healthy relationship. I've never watched a single episode of this show. I wouldn't blame her at all if she slept with both of them. She apparently had different emotional chemistry with both men, so maybe her deciding factor was sexual compatability.

Wendy Williams

This is rediculous! The news media needs to leave people alone. The show is over so let them be. This is exactly why the couples from bachelor and bachelorette end up splitting up. The news media needs to butt out and let them have their lives back.

nonmember avatar Sheri

I don't think she did. She never even went into the fantasy sweet with Arie because she said she would be too tempted because they had so much chemistry.

Barbara Slusher Morris

No she did NOT ... I believe that is what hurt her about BRAD ... he did sleep with the girls and I don't think she knew that until the show aired. May have been the reason for her change of heart. I don't blame her. I think she stuck to her beliefs, didn't sleep with anyone until Jef. I think that Jef would have been upset too if he knew that Arie slept with Emily upon their engagement. Another twist from the media that's trying to split them up. Leave them alone.

1-10 of 29 comments 123 Last