Couple Arrested for Kidnapping 2 Amish Girls

A few days ago we were horrified, and then relieved, to find out that two young Amish sisters had been kidnapped from their home in northern New York, but that they were able to get away from their captors and return to their parents. There were quite a few holes in the case -- we knew they had been taken while working at their family's roadside vegetable stand, but we couldn't fathom why the kidnappers suddenly dropped Fannie Miller, 12, and Delila Miller, 6, off in Richville -- a town located 36 miles away from their home.

Well, today we have a few more answers -- and, most importantly, two suspects. A father of three and his girlfriend have been arrested and charged in connection with the kidnappings. And, according to police, what they had planned to do with the little girls couldn't be any more disturbing.

Stephen Howells II, 39, and his 25-year-old girlfriend Nicole Vaisey were arrested last night at their home 20 miles away from where the Miller girls were found this week. They've been charged with two counts of first-degree kidnapping, as well as intending to sexually abuse or physically harm the girls. They could face 25 years to life in prison if convicted.

Not a whole lot is known about these two, whom neighbors say are a couple. But they've also reported that three children live in the home, and Howells' Facebook page show him with three children, alongside captions like, "Father's day kickball." It isn't clear whether Vaisey is the mother of the children.

The sisters disappeared this week after they reportedly went up to the suspects' car to greet them while working at the vegetable stand. No one is sure why, but they were then reportedly driven to a home in Richville and told to stay in the car while they got out for unknown reasons. The girls bravely escaped and knocked on a neighbor's door. He says he recognized them from news reports, fed them, and drove them back to their home in Oswegatchie.

The girls were reportedly able to provide police with enough information to lead them to Howells II and Vaisey. The couple agreed to go to the sheriff's office to be questioned and were arrested after their interviews. We still have no idea what, if anything, was done to the girls between the time they were abducted and rescued, but St. Lawrence Distict Attorney Mary Rain says the couple's arrest "saved young children from future abuse at the hands of these two."

Just chilling.

More from The Stir: 2 Abducted Amish Sisters Found Alive in New York

Hoping we find out these girls were not harmed during their time away from home. And, if these two are convicted, they deserve to be put away for a long, long time.

Are you surprised that a young couple was arrested in connection with this kidnapping?


Image via Facebook





To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Kelly Walters

Sick. I wonder what made them chicken out? Thank God they did and in a way this may be a blessing for the children of this man. You know he has probably been abusing them.

nonmember avatar Me

No,not surprised at all,sadly there are many monsters that walk Earth,including female monsters.

egrze... egrzesik91

Yeah this is near my house..... creepy

nonmember avatar Nik

They didn't chicken out. They took them to a house & went inside & told the girls to stay in the car & while they were gone the girls escaped & knocked on a neighbors door. The neighbor recognized them from the news, fed them, & drove them home.

nonmember avatar Sarah

You do know they were from Heuvelton? Every time I read these articles I always discover that you have something wrong in them. This time this one hit close to home because I currently live 45 mins away. When I lived closer I used to go to their farm. Please learn to read over things before you create your own article about something.

Michelle Dauser Mcgee

Sooo glad that there is finally a kidnapping story with a happy ending. These girls are very lucky to be alive. And as far as whether or not anything happened to them while they were gone is their business only. We do not need to know that. I only hope that nothing did happen. But if it did, I hope they will be allowed to get the help they are going to need to be able to deal with it. These people need to be put away for a long time if it's proven that they did in fact do this. Monsters come in all shapes, sizes and genders and have no place around children. Not even their own.

Cari Poissant

Im soo happy the girls are home safe but what about the 3 kids that these deranged people have living at home with them???


sunfl... sunflower1968

No surprise

There's two more off the streets, n so many more out there people please watch your children. Your carelessness makes your children suffer.

Tell them not to talk or go with anybody if the parents don't say OK!

Then family hurts kids too so who do you trust.

So happy the girls was left alone n the saw a chance to run some kids would had been to scared to move. Happy ending :)

Pray nothing happened while they were away.

1-6 of 6 comments