Woman’s Scary Fake Dating Profile Gets an Unexpected Reaction From Men

Men are a sucker for a pretty lady. Like, a real sucker. Like, you can totally have the absolute worst personality in the world, but if you're pretty -- well, men won't care. In case you think I'm making this up, check out the dating profile of one AaronCarterFan. The name should be enough to make most men click by, but combine that with the 25-year-old woman's racist, gold-digging, misspelled, idiotic, manipulative profile, and you'd hope she would have had zero messages in her inbox. Instead, she had 150. Within 24 hours.

Cracked blogger Alli Reed hoped to create a fake dating profile so despicable that no man would respond to it. But she did that in a weird way -- she used lots of pictures of her gorgeous, busty, model gal pal.

Alli apparently didn't know what I figured out ages ago -- if a guy is attracted to you, you could tell him you're a serial killer and he'll be all, "Aww, well, you're not gonna kill me, are ya, cutie?" In my early 20s, working part-time in a nightclub while attending college, I thought I came up with a brilliant plan to get the guys who would hit on me all night to leave me alone. I would tell them horrible things about myself -- the worst things I could think of -- in hopes that they'd go away. Once, I told a man who was particularly tenacious that I had five children, all by different fathers, that I had AIDS and herpes, and that I was dead broke, and a few other things thrown in that I've forgotten. His response? "I love kids!"

Not joking. (What did work? The time I wore fake bad teeth -- all I had to do was smile and they scampered.)

But when Alli posted a dating profile that not only described herself as an "Aaron Carter fan" but also that she loved "convincing people im pregnat lol"; that the first thing men notice about her is "Prolly ... the drink Im throwing in there face"; and suggested men only email her if "ur rich" -- she expected no one would show up for the ride to crazy town.

Boy was she wrong. Almost 200 responded in one day. Shocked, Alli began trying to turn the guys off by email. She told one she wanted to "pull out his teeth" -- but he responded by asking for her phone number.

Not really a surprise considering AaronCarterFan also expressed an interest in casual sex. There are many men who would trade some teeth for sex. It truly makes you weep for humanity.

More From The Stir: 8 Reasons Women Don't Date 'Nice' Guys

Profiles that would have gotten less responses? Possibly been ignored altogether? My guesses:

- A 28-year-old woman who wants to be married and pregnant within six months -- and no sex until marriage.

- A 50-year-old woman looking to date a 50-year-old man.

- A 41-year-old woman who writes, "Marriage-minded only! NO casual encounters! No sex! I HATE sex! Yes, you must pay for the first date!" (Though if this woman is pretty, she still might get some responses.)

- A 32-year-old lawyer with short hair who went to Harvard and is pictured wearing a turtleneck and beige slacks.

- A woman who writes, "I am VERY OPINIONATED!" (And she's not hot.)

Why do you think men responded to this profile? Does it surprise you?

Image via Ken Seet/Corbis

in the news, dating


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

NoWei NoWei

None of this is surprising. Men are pigs.

Kattey Kattey

It's really disturbing the lengths some people will go to to hook up with a pretty face, and a testament to just how messed up our society is in regards to prizing beauty.

LostS... LostSoul88

When I was on a dating site I had one guy message me for a while then he went into say how he hasn;t had sex for a long time because he  has ED. I knew it was all a lie so i responded. "That's okay I am not into sex at all and don't mind not having it."  Never heard from him again LMAO

deeha... deeharmonic

Saw this on another page, laughed my butt off because its so true. The internet dating sites are just full of sexual predators who really, don't give a crap about starting a family or even a serious relationship. Its soo disgusting, I knew this behaviour was out there but to have it proven to us so bluntly is embarassing to the male race. 

prplecat prplecat

If you think about it, it makes sense...I'll bet that the respondents were all bottom-of-the-barrel, just looking for NSA types.

s_ran... s_ranker116

I love Cracked, I mean LOVE it! I read the article too and I'm pretty horrifyed by the responses she got.

nonmember avatar mawnckman

I rise in defense of the men on OKC. All attractive women on the site will get messages from the clueless. This is not news. However, she had "casual sex" listed under "what I'm looking for". While in real life that can mean a number of things, on OKC it indicates that the person is specifically looking for one night stands. Only about 5% of the female profiles have that option checked, and that 5% gets a LOT of attention from icky guys who aren't that concerned about the profile. Also, this profile comes across as a joke. Joke profiles get a lot of responses from people just looking for a fun message interaction. All this "experiment" really proved is that some women have no idea what constitutes a bad profile. Had she been average looking and talked a lot about her personal Lord and Savior, it would have been a more plausible profile and she wouldn't have gotten squat. (PS - A 32-year-old lawyer with short hair who went to Harvard and is pictured wearing a turtleneck and beige slacks? If she was listed as "looking for guys", she'd be INUNDATED with messages, including one from me! Really now …)

Sandy Mendez

men are pigs dating sites that screw housewives during the day and married dating sites make me sick

Mark Roy

I reported two scammers on DatingWithGenitalHerpes.com. Both of these two women are very pretty and untrue.

1-10 of 10 comments