Standardized Testing Isn’t Going Away So How Can We Make It Better?

OMG 37

testOh man, a wave of standardized tests just hit our school kids the past few weeks. For some parents and kids, it's a nightmare. You may have read Lindsay Ferrier's post on her daughter's test stress and the Google Hangout conversation on school testing we had last week. It seems like every year, more and more parents are saying, "Let us off this crazy ride!" Well, Secretary of Education Arne Duncan admitted last week that he gets it. He said the criticism about testing "is merited."

Duncan says he and his department are "spending a huge amount of time listening to ideas" about how to transition to the Common Core Standards. But ditching assessments is not one of those ideas -- he says testing will still happen. He's open to support "much better assessment," though. So what are they? Here are a few better school assessment ideas different education experts are pushing.

Lower the stakes of testing. Many parents and educators think we need to stop tying rewards and punishments to testing and stop using tests as the only or the main tool for evaluating schools and teachers. Advocacy group Time Out From Testing, for example, is calling for a variety of methods to assess students' progress. And in the meantime, they are calling for a comprehensive review of the New York State tests to see the impact they've had on students, schools, and the community.

Test less to improve accountability. Executive Director of the National Center for Fair and Open Testing Monty Neil argues that we should be testing students less. He says it would be more effective to have comprehensive school quality reviews, to test in just a few grades, and do local assessments.

Shift classroom focus from test prep to actual learning. The American Teachers Federation feels assessment is necessary, but testing has come to "dominate" education. They call for a return to well-rounded education (instead of excessive test prep) and giving teachers the tools and resources the need to teach effectively.

We need classroom assessments too to show how, not just what to teach. The Center for Comprehensive School Reform and Improvement points out that standardized tests show teachers which objectives students aren't learning. But what teachers really need is to find out what kind of instruction will help them learn those objectives. Classroom assessments would look at the activities students are doing in classrooms and how effective they are.

Do you feel like there's too much pressure on standardized tests?


Image via albertogp123/Flickr

moms matter


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

count... countrygirlkat

I absolutely feel there is too much pressure with standardized tests.  Too much pressure on the kids, too much pressure on the teachers and too much pressure on the schools.

truth... truthrowan

why don't we go back to "This is our national standard, the states and local school districts get to decide how to meet these standards." And if the kids haven't received passing grades and passed normal end of the semester mastery exams, they don't advance? Why do we need a week of aggrivating testing?


Bloom... Bloomie79

After a few years of paying for private school we moved to a great school district so the kids could attend a "great" public school. Cue every single learning tool made to prep them for standardized tests, missing essential texts and tools until November because the budget doesn't become avavlible until October. I could stomach a weeks worth of standardized tests if the other 35 weeks were actually dedicated to learning. 

godde... goddess99

Idk, we haven't really had to worry about that yet. So far here my dd has only taken tests to see how well the teachers teach. But because of tenure it doesn't really matter. The lousy teachers will still have a job.

My nice answer.

aneela aneela

I'm not sure what's really happening in the PS system

Bob192 Bob192

Yes!  My daughter is in 3rd grade and was totally stressed out!  I agree that they should focus more on kids learning than being able to pass the test!

slw123 slw123

I can't stand all this standardized testing.

coppe... copperswifey

I do because I always got nervous taking tests so I blew them most of the time. It's hard to tell from just tests how someone is doing :/

LOswa... LOswald0314

Yes, it's gotten ridiculous.

Miche... MichelleK41

I feel having them more than once during the school year is a bit much.

1-10 of 37 comments 1234 Last