Nanny Suspected After Mom Comes Home to Find Her Children Stabbed to Death

Heartbreaking 39

police tapeIn a story so horrific it's truly unfathomable, tonight a mother found her two small children stabbed to death in her upscale apartment in New York's Upper West Side. While some rumors are saying the nanny has been arrested, police have not officially confirmed.

According to the New York Daily News, Marina Krim, who works as a pediatrician, returned home around 5:30 p.m. with her 3-year-old daughter after swim practice and found the apartment dark. After confirming with the doorman that her nanny and children hadn't left the building she returned, and when she went in the bathroom and turned on the light there she saw the gruesome scene.

There were her other two babies -- a 2-year-old boy and 6-year-old girl -- bloodied and lifeless in the bathtub. Their nanny lay on the floor near the knife, with what authorities say appeared to be a self-inflicted cut on her own throat. The children were pronounced dead at the hospital; the 50-year-old nanny, Yoselyn Ortega, was immediately taken to the hospital and is in critical but stable condition.

The details as to what happened exactly are sparse at this time, and it's unknown how long she worked with the children. It's also unknown where the children's father -- Kevin Krim, who is CNBC’s general manager of digital content -- was at the time of the stabbings. And, of course, the biggest question of all remains -- why?

I'm sure more details will be revealed in coming hours and days, but none of them will change the horrific nature of the case, which is sure to send shock waves through the country as it brings to the surface the fears every parent has when leaving their children with anyone but family. It's truly everyone's worst nightmare, which is now this poor family's reality.

Everyone is making assumptions right now about what happened, and with the fact laid out like they are, it's hard not to. WE can do all the background checks in the world, and we know that most caregivers are amazing and loving, but it's the random, horrific incidents like this that stay in our heads as we walk out the door and leave our children. We wonder how much we can really trust them, how well we really know them, and we hope for the best ... just the same way I bet this mother did.

Do stories like this make you question your childcare providers?


Image via Provisions/Flickr







To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

LadyRabbit White

why is a huge deal. you just dont expect that type of stuff from nannys

tuffy... tuffymama

I'm so thankful I get to stay home with my LO. This poor mother. I can't even fathom what horror she feels.

kelti... kelticmom

This makes me so sick. But let's not hop on the"nannies are evil and the mom should be watching her kids" train. I am sure if you look at it, most cases of child abuse, abduction, molestation and even murder are usually perpetrated by a family member or close friend. Evil people are everywhere. This woman was obviously a deranged psychopath. That doesn't mean that using childcare is upping your odds of having your child murdered. That poor mother. She is a pediatrician and saves children's lives, yet her own were ripped away. So sad.

ImaSo... ImaSoulMom

I think kids are safest with their mother. All i know is that no other person loves my kids more than I do. Sometimes there is no other choice. This woman thought her kids were safe and probably checked references and everything a good mom would do. she had one of her babies with her and thank god she did not lose all of her children. This is heartbreaking.

Angie Hayes

Not even are they safe with family members. My mother-in-law sent my son to the ER because she peeled his foreskin all the way back... She no longer has contact with us.

cmjaz cmjaz

Poor, poor parents. Heartbreaking. Such evil in the world....

BPayne09 BPayne09

And that is one of the reasons I'm glad I get to stay home with our son! And also makes me very thankful for the grandparents who watch him when I do work!

bills... billsfan1104

This makes me angry and sad. Those poor poor kids and mother.

OKgirl OKgirl

Those poor babies. My heart breaks for them and their family.

mommy... mommyof5cutties

I have 5 beautiful little ones... the oldest is 7... and in all 7 years I am proud to have never needed to hire a babysitter or daycare.. I just can't trust anyone... call me over protective or whatever... but better to be safe then sorry.

1-10 of 39 comments 1234 Last