Follow The Stir

Politics at Play

Is Florida's Voter Registration Law Fair? (VIDEO)

by The Stir Bloggers on August 3, 2012 at 11:34 AM

students affected by florida's voter registration lawDawn Quarles is a high school government teacher in Pensacola, Florida, who made national headlines when she was fined for registering her students to vote. The fine was a result of violating Florida's new voter registration law, which requires voter registration forms to be turned in within 48 hours. 

As part of our Moms Matter "Swing State" Road Trip, we heard Dawn's and her students' story firsthand and took an in depth look at Florida House Bill 1355 -- a law that very well could influence the outcome of the Presidential election this fall. 

Take a watch:

What are your thoughts on voter registration laws like the one in Florida? Are they going to be effective against voter fraud or are they a political tool to target voter groups?


Filed Under: 2012 election, barack obama, cafemom studios, mitt romney, moms matter road trip

Comments

19
  • Guest
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Guest

    August 3, 2012 at 12:41 PM
    There is a VERY good reason for this law. If you recall from the ACORN fiasco in '08, one of the tactics they used to file fraudulent voter registrations was to collect large stacks of voter registration forms, mix in large numbers of bogus forms, pump up the numbers with large numbers of duplicate forms, and then "dump" them in mass on the registrars office at the very last minute. The registration office was swamped, and since they have to err on the side of making sure everyone who wants to vote is registered, they had no choice but to "rubber stamp" them in mass, without properly verifying them.

    Why are "third parties" even involved at all?

    What possible legitimate, non-nefarious reason could there possibly be to allow "third parties" to even handle, much less posses and fail to turn completed voter registration forms promptly?

    A few years ago, I picked up a voter registration form for a friend and gave it to her. I obtained it at the post office, and it was attached to a "postage paid" envelope. Same thing if you get one at the DMV. There was absolutely no reason for a "third party" to handle the paperwork at all.

    I find it interesting that it is assumed that all voter registrations that are obtained using techniques that involve "funny business" are presumed to be democrat voters...
  • mleil...
    --

    mleilanim

    August 3, 2012 at 1:37 PM
    If you so wish to possess the "maturity" -wink wink- to vote, than one should also possess the minimal amount of maturity to fill out the form themselves. Sounds like this teacher is an enabler & not promoting these children to seek out "adult like" -wink wink- endeavors on their own. I definitely support this law.
  • Guest
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Guest

    August 3, 2012 at 2:19 PM
    When I was 17, it wasn't that easy. When I had register to vote for the first time in an upcoming election (that occurred right after I turned 18), well in advance of the election (they don't schedule elections suddenly by surprise) I had to look up the address of the voter registration office in the phone book (remember those?) call them and find out their hours, physically travel to that office, sit down and fill out a form all by myself, raise my right hand and swear an oath under penalty of perjury in front of the registrar that all my information was true and accurate, and show my ID to prove it. They then processed the paperwork, verifying all of the info with official records, and only then mailed me my voter registration card.
  • Guest
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Guest

    August 3, 2012 at 2:24 PM
    continued...

    That is why I opposed "Motor Voter".

    First, it kept it legitimate.

    Second, if you can't be bothered to go through a process that is in reality less trouble than renewing your drivers license, you are probably not all that inclined to research and study the issues. Someone who can barely be bothered to sign one extra form while waiting in line at the DMV is also likely to be the one who is an unmotivated idiot who will just cast a ballot for whoever their favorite Jersey Shore star said was "cool"...

    Once again, interesting that that too was a left/right issue...
  • Autum...
    --

    Autumnleaves87

    August 3, 2012 at 2:26 PM
    Hahah hold on. Guest. There is no voter fraud. That's the bottom line. THEY EVEN SAY THAT IN THE VIDEO. You can try and make up some stupid bs and claim that there was some "funny business" with acorn or a third party but the only funny business is the Florida legislator making it harder for young Latino and African Americans to vote.


    "We can't beat Obama on our own so let's make it harder for his supporters to.vote!!" What a great idea. NOT.

    And calling this teacher an enabler is a joke too. When I just turned 18 in high school I had no idea where to go to register to vote, but luckily my senior issues teacher brought forms for us and educated his students about where to register, when and where to vote, ect ect. This "enabling" you're talking about is actually a great opportunity to educate first time voters.

    We don't just POP out of the womb knowing how to feed ourselves and how to register to vote. Duh.

    These laws are out there for one thing: Repubs know Obamas base and they are trying to keep them from voting.

    I say democrats take voting booths and put them at the top of Mt Shasta. That would hopefully keep old rich white dudes from voting.
  • PonyC...
    --

    PonyChaser

    August 3, 2012 at 2:39 PM

    Ok, first comment is WAY off topic: Lindsay, what the heck? DRIVING while you're making this video??? Your eyes were on the camera more than they were on the road! Park next time, please. I like your writing. I don't want you to do it from the hospital!!


  • Jespren
    --

    Jespren

    August 3, 2012 at 2:41 PM
    So, Autumnleaves87, basically what you are saying is republicans are dedicated and intelligent enough to register to vote and subsequently vote given voters laws but Obama followers are not. That's very interesting that the *exact same law* could somehow be too much of a hardship and defeat hordes of anxious, willing democrat voters while at the same time having no effect on republican turn out. That, ah, says a lot about your faith in democrat voters.

    These laws apply equally to everyone, they are just as much in force for the white conservative disabled grandma who relies on public transportation and has no drivers license as for the 18 year old Latino liberal who has to watch his younger siblings every day after school. Legal U.S. citizens of legal age have a right to vote, that does not mean they have a 'right' to have a ballot hand delivered in a gold envelope by a courier who will happily wait to hand deliver it back to the ballot drop off (same for voters registration).
  • PonyC...
    --

    PonyChaser

    August 3, 2012 at 2:45 PM

    On topic. Interesting how 18-year old students are capable of researching, applying for, and getting into a college all on their own. They are also capable of obtaining scholarships and loans to pay for that college education.

    They are capable of researching the material for tests that they need to pass in order to graduate from school so they can attend those colleges. They are capable of looking up a plethora of information on the web, from their favorite drink mix to what time their favorit sport is being broadcast during Olympic coverage, to whether an iPad or another tablet would suit them best. They can research and figure out what car to buy, what apartment to rent, and what dorm to live in. They can order pizzas online, and figure out how to get a job. They can get their drivers' licenses and register for Selective Service. All without the help of a teacher.

    But when it comes to registering to vote, suddenly they are helpless babies who can't figure out how/where to get the forms? They can't figure out how to complete them on their own and mail them in? Or drive them to the building and take an oath?

    Sorry, folks. Rules are put in place for a reason. Even if there wasn't one single documented case of voter fraud in FL, it has been plenty documented around the rest of the country, and I don't blame FL one bit for being proactive.

    It's not racist. It's common freaking sense. So is requiring an ID when you show up to vote.


  • Guest
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Guest

    August 3, 2012 at 3:03 PM
    @Autumnleaves87, you abundantly prove my point about my DMV sentiments. Just because "THEY EVEN SAY THAT IN THE VIDEO"DOES NOT MAKE IT TRUE. Little effort is expended to even try to detect voter fraud, in practice it is very difficult to detect and prosecute. So, given that they HAVE caught hundreds, (false claims to the contrary not withstanding) one can reasonably assume there are more.

    And unlike you, I made up nothing, about either the ACORN fraud nor about fraudulent voting numbers. Google it. Either that, or see if they give you any information about it on the back of your DMV paperwork...

    "We can't beat Romney on our own so let's make it easier to cheat!!" What a great idea. NOT.
    (sorry to inject truth and reality into your rant)

    Unbelievable. My side is simply saying "Keep it fair", your side wants to eliminate even slightest safeguards to prevent fraud; and somehow in your... er... "mind" my side is the one that is trying to "cheat"?

    Wanna know what I really think? We should change it from "one warm body, one vote" to "one IQ point, one vote". Though granted, that would be the end of your party...
  • wamom223
    --

    wamom223

    August 3, 2012 at 3:08 PM

    Ponychaser said everything I wanted to say.  Thanks.


1-10 of 19 comments

To leave a comment, log in as a CafeMom member:

Log In

OR, use our non-member comment form: