Bin Laden Prayer Request Is Blatant Grab for Attention


prayerIf there's one thing that can be said about the death of Osama bin Laden, it's that it has given us Americans a crash course in what to do when an evil terrorist mastermind has fallen.

First things first: pop the champagne. Scale a traffic sign chanting, "Hey Hey Hey, Goodbye." Remind yourself that no celebration is too raucous in the face of justice. Second, cash in on the event with t-shirts and coffee mugs making fun of the deceased. And, finally, submit a prayer request at your church asking all parishioners to pray for the enemy leader's soul.

It sounds like a joke, but it's not: A parishioner actually made a prayer request for Osama bin Laden at the Holy Name of Jesus Catholic Church in Palm Springs because as he explained, "[Bin Laden] needs forgiveness and compassion from God."

According to the church pastor, Holy Name has never turned down a prayer request and won't do so in this circumstance. But that doesn't mean the other church-goers are happy about it. In fact, the request is proving quite divisive among the parishioners. Here's Louis Pizzano Sr., explaining why he prefers to pray for American soldiers rather than Bin Laden:

I just don't think it's right, I really don't ... I think what's happened to the American people, what he's done, what he was planning to do and because we killed him, it doesn't stop there.

You've got to wonder why someone would make a request that would upset, divide, and alienate other parishioners at a time when so many are already hurting. There's no logical explanation other than perhaps he wanted the attention that such a contentious appeal would instigate. Instead of banding together with his fellow church-goers to reflect on the events that have transpired, he's put himself at the center of this controversy. He's divided his church during one of those time when people need it the most.

Many religions are about forgiveness and love -- love for everyone, even enemies. But people need to come to that forgiveness and love in their own time, not have it be forced upon them in a public church gathering. Bin Laden is a face that, even dead, incites rage, fear, and, most acutely, pain. Why is it so hard to allow people to grieve and move on from his death without forcing them to decide whether he's deserving of prayers?

Do you think the Bin Laden prayer request was too soon?


Image via hpebley3/Flickr

in the news, islam, religion, terrorism


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Kimberly Virga

No. And as a Christian, I completely understand this. I find it sad that so many other "Christians" don't understnad the concept of forgiveness. Why can't we pray for enemy and friend alike? Of course we pray for our soldiers; of course we pray for our fallen brothers and sisters. Of course we'll never forget 9/11. There are OTHER PEOPLE (major newsflash to Americans, I know) that suffer as well. Not just the good. And God will judge and forgive them, too, even though their crimes were heinous. It's what I believe.

David Leonard

christians need to put their prayers where their mouths are. forgiveness is not selective, and it is not your place to judge. if you want to do as jesus did, then you will pray for this SOB, and you will like it! as for me, i'm not a christian, nor do i care to act like one should. frankly, bottom line--you're all hypocrites.

nonmember avatar peter

"love your enemies, PRAY for those who persecute you" (matthew 5:44)
What part of that commandment of Christ don't people understand?

nonmember avatar Greg Belfrage

Forgive me, as I couldn't help but laugh as I read Kim Conte's reaction. Kim says the parishioner who made the request is a "divider". Kim, if you'll recall, Christ was a divider in His day, too. He challenged people to such a point that they crucified Him for it. If you have issues because I pray for bin Laden... that says a lot more about YOU than it says about me.

nonmember avatar Meg

"You have heard that it was said, 'Love your neighbor and hate your enemy.' But I tell you: Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you." Matthew 5:43-44

nonmember avatar Madam Aurantia

Ooh, you mean that compassion ISN'T just restricted to those we like? Blasphemy!

Seriously, for most Christians it's easier to point a judgement at someone and feel superior to them than it is to actually follow those commandments such as compassion, forgiveness, and love.

I've known many Christians, but can count those who actually GOT IT on my fingers. This is why Paganism is the fastest growing religion in the country.

Wheep... Wheepingchree

I agree with the first two comments. Practice what you preach


1-7 of 7 comments