
Image courtesy of PhotobucketDictionary.com defines the word "feminism" as "the doctrine advocating social, political, and all other rights of women equal to those of men." Merriam-Webster's entry is similar: "The theory of political, economic, and social equality of the sexes." Check a few others and you'll see the definition is pretty uniform. Nothing is mentioned about a requirement that a feminist be someone who supports abortion rights.
Recently, Sarah Palin has added to her pit-bull-with-lipstick persona by embracing the mental image of a mama grizzly bear, trying to energize her sister conservatives into becoming activists, claiming the title of "feminist" for themselves.
And there are plenty who are crying foul.
Not surprisingly, traditional feminists -- those who fought the long (and still unfinished) fight for equal rights, an end to gender discrimination, and the right to make our own reproductive decisions -- claim that Palin can't be a feminist because she opposes abortion rights. Palin's new embrace (or her attempt to usurp, depending on your perspective) of that feminist label has again raised the question many have asked for a long time: What does it really mean to be a feminist?
For me, it means that I have the right to make decisions for myself, especially when it comes to my body -- just as men have had the right to do since, say, the dawn of time. The feminist movement was born from the idea that men, be they husbands or lawmakers, shouldn't have the right to determine the details of women's lives, especially how and when to have families. What Palin is calling "conservative feminism" is more narrowly drawn, calling on girls and women to embrace the idea that they can have children and be active outside the home as long as they rely only on their own bootstraps for their own success.
Sorry, Sarah, but while bootstraps are all well and good (and I've used mine plenty, thank you very much), there also needs to be a true support network among all women before any form of feminism wins the day.
Interestingly, it's not just the Palin crowd that's been trying to redefine feminism. During the 2008 presidential election, many young women claimed they could be feminists without being obligated to vote for a woman candidate, forsaking Hillary Clinton in favor of a man (who, by the way, still has a long way to go to prove his own feminist bona fides). But I digress.
Here's the thing -- while Palin likes to tout that she didn't choose abortion for herself when she found out her then-unborn son Trig had Down syndrome, she considered it. She considered it because it was her choice -- a choice she doesn't want other women to have. She's proudly proclaimed that her daughter Bristol chose to keep her baby when faced with her unwed teen pregnancy. But she had a choice. And that's one of the unspoken underlying principles of feminism, isn't it -- having the right to choose, to have control over those decisions about our own bodies. The right to make all our own choices, just as men have always had.
Just as Palin and her daughter had.
So, if one is going to claim the feminist mantle, I have to conclude that you have to be willing to say that all women have the right to self-determination. It's about choices and we don't all have to make the same ones.
I don't have to be a mama grizzly to stand up for what I believe is right or to defend how I view the world as a feminist. But touch the things I believe are my daughter's birthright and I might have to channel my inner wolverine.
Joanne Bamberger also likes to hang around the blogosphere writing about politics at her place, PunditMom. She finally finished her manuscript about how women -- progressive, conservative, and in-between -- are revolutionizing the world of politics through social media!


This Hot Dad Wants to Do Your Ironing
KStew Refuses to Shower
This Hot Dad Wants to Cook You Dinner
This Hot Dad Cooks AND Does the Dishes
















Comments 35
@fine1956 - While you've ticked off a list of reasons to admire Sarah Palin, I expect those who criticize her have their own list of reasons to do so, none of which have anything to do with how we define feminism for ourselves or as a movement.
I'm not chiming in to defend Palin. I'm certainly not a fan. But...
The founders of feminism (Susan B. Anthony, Elizabeth Cady Stanton) were not for abortion. In fact, many believe that abortion adds to the oppression of woman (www.feministsforlife.org). Abortion is so rarely a "choice" for women but something that is pressured or forced upon them. Not to mention all the women who are aborted around the world for simply being female.
She may not be a feminist (and I don't really care if she is or is not) but it is not because she is pro-life.
Actually, I am glad that student loans are being handled by the Feds. Know why? The schools-for-profit like University of Phoenix, DeVry, (there are a huge slew of these for-profits) were ripping students off by charging enormous per-credit fees (upwards of $450), not for professor salaries of course, but officers of these businesses were pocketing the bulk of the fees, and promising students jobs after school was completed, then not delivering on those promises. Since students couldn't get jobs, they ended up in incredible debt--owing hundreds of thousands of dollars! These for-profits are unregulated and the administrators of these businesses are the ones getting rich. It became a scandal--and that's why the Feds had to step in and regulate loans-so the crooks couldn't continue to take advantage of generations of students to come. It's not about needing or wanting to control things--it's about controlling the corruption of people who don't give a damn about anything but how rich they can get, and making sure citizens don't get taken advantage of.
@mamaktb Actually, all the recent spin about Susan B. Anthony, etc., not favoring abortion is not entirely accurate.
http://womensenews.org/story/abortion/061006/susan-b-anthonys-abortion-position-spurs-scuffle
dear mimi - Phoenix's credits are NOT worth the paper they are written on at any reputable university. They are now forced to disclose that. What does that have to do with my son now being forced to go to the federal govt to get a loan to a credible university. Please put some energy into closing Phoenix down, they should be. But some beauracrat in Washington has no business telling my son anything about whether he should get money to anywhere, it has EVERYTHING to do with control. A huge majority of the admissions,registrars, and financial offices are opposed to this, they expect it to operate as smoothly as every other federal govt agency, and it should not be forced upon the entire coutry, Unconsitutional is the best word to describe this major takeover of private industry.
Dear Julie - as you just described, feminism is about agreeing with someone??? or only about abortion???. I consider that simplistic and misguided. Agree with her or dont, just tired of the discussion of who deserves??? the feminist title. Complete waste of time, and requires some arrogance to think anyone has the right to make that judgment.
And guess what -- I'm not the only one our here calling Palin out on her "feminist" credentials --
http://www.creators.com/liberal/connie-schultz/if-sarah-palin-is-a-feminist-then-i-m-president-of-the-tea-party.html
And this one ...
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/sam-bennett/sarah-palins-brand-of-fem_b_588729.html
Yeah, Connie Schultz is so middle-of-the-road! Ha!
As a pro-life, highly-educated, professional woman who also happens to be the single mom of two daughters, I believe in the kind of women's abilities/rights that Palin believes in, including:
The ability and right to be taken seriously in every field and profession, right up to president of the USA.
The ability to recognize the importance of respecting our bodies and the right to say no to any or all of the following: sex stereotyping, peer pressure to take sex lightly, engaging in protected or unprotected sex, devaluing a child of our body or any other child, and/or educating our daughters to disrespect these values.
You folks are completely blind to the former (Palin's track record as a successful woman who stands for women's professional success), while lacking the depth to understand the latter.
It amazes me that self-proclaimed feminists actually believe the right to kill their own baby is more important than the ability to have a meaningful and successful career. The only thing I can figure is that you yourselves have no clue about what it is to achieve professional credibility, so you wouldn't know how to value it. Which is ironic, considering that is supposed to be one of the main thrusts of the women's movement, which you like to call feminism.
So I'm fine with not being a member of your club.
@punditmom Regardless of what the truth is about SBA (although, I believe FFL)...being pro-life does not exempt you from being a feminist.
Regardless of her anti choice views, Sarah Palin is a woman who has as Mayor of Waisila charged women for rape kits and advocates abstinance only education...she is not pro woman, she is only pro Sarah