Woman Sued for $750,000 Over Scathing Yelp Review of Home Repairs

Twisted 5

laptop"OMG, this place suuuuucks."I think most of us have read a nasty Yelp review and decided then and there never to frequent that restaurant, or use that nail salon, or hire those contractors. Did you ever think, though, that the person who left that review could be sued for defamation by the company they've publicly besmirched? Me neither. But, apparently, it happens. Just ask Virginia resident Jane Perez -- she left an honest, yet scathing, one-star review of a contracting company -- and now faces a $750,000 lawsuit.


Perez says that they basically did a crappy job, damaged her home instead of fixed it up, and laments that jewelry of hers went missing. The contractor, on the other hand, claims he lost $300,000 in business due to her online rant, and that there's no one out there to protect small businesses "when people slam their name." He says he did a fine job, and that Perez never paid him.

It's a tangled web, for sure, but what we're left with here is the reminder that there is a difference between freedom of speech and slander.

Of course, if it's found that Perez is telling the truth, the case is moot, but I'll think about this next time I'm reviewing something, be it on Foursquare, Yelp, or Facebook. I thought, as perhaps most people did, that there's nothing dangerous about sharing your honest perceptions of a service you received.

Turns out, though, there's the danger of being served. Perez will likely have to spend thousands on her legal defense, even if she's totally innocent. And, god, think of the stress of it all. Ugh. Just awful.

Experts say they're seeing more and more of these kinds of cases, but the numbers are still relatively low. That said, just, you know, maybe pause before publishing your review and make sure it's free of exaggeration or hyperbole. Otherwise, ah oh. You could be in trooouble.

UPDATE: The judge ordered Perez to take down her Yelp review after portions of her complaint could not be proven.

Were you aware you could be sued for your negative Yelp reviews?


Photo via notionscapitol.com/Flickr

newsworthy, web


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Reepi... Reepicheep.CSL

That is such bull. You provide a service then you have to be aware that people are going to review you.

We have a right to know what kind of person we are going into business with.

GwenMB GwenMB

I've never heard of Yelp.

But given how sue happy some people are, it wouldn't surprise me to hear about any lawsuit.  I do think that if you sue & lose, you should have to pay the legal bills of the person you sued.

Flori... Floridamom96

She was sued for defamation because she publicly accused his company of theft even though a police investigation had found no evidence his company stole anything. They're called facts people and as someone who's writings are published you should try using them.

bills... billsfan1104

Florida, that's what I figured. She deserves it and I hope they win.

nonmember avatar kaerae

It's libel, not slander, libel is written, slander is spoken.

1-5 of 5 comments