Being a Squeaky Wheel Paid Off for Woman Who Challenged Cable Bill


Dollar Signs At HomeWhen your two-bedroom bungalow gets a water bill big enough for an aquarium, of course your antennae are going to go up. But keeping your eye on every household bill on a monthly basis can be more of a challenge. Still, it’s worth it, as one woman discovered.

The error on Linda Sacash’s cable bill wasn’t huge, but it added up to a big difference in her bottom line. And even though the company told her she couldn’t do anything about it, she kicked up a fuss and got what was coming to her. Here’s what happened ...

When Sacash signed up with Time Warner Cable, she got a special three-year promotional deal that gave her bundled service for $89.95 a month. But after just two years, the bill jumped to $179. She called to ask what was up, and they told her they had decided to end the promotion one whole year early.

Sacash got a consumer-assistance TV news show to intervene on her behalf -- and won the extra time she was owed -- but even if she hadn’t, she would have been right to insist she get another year of the deal. Would she have gotten it, though?

I’ll admit, it’s harder and harder to get companies to stick to their promises these days. As they worry more and more about their profits (because God forbid their CEOs don’t get their bazillion-dollar bonuses), they tighten their hold on each penny that comes in, and look for nasty ways to slip a few extra bucks past us. But they’re not getting past me.

My stepson Max loves it when I get on the phone with a company that has made a billing mistake. He sits outside the office door and reports to everyone else exactly how mad I’m getting (for the record, these discussions rarely get heated, because politeness gets me a lot further), how many supervisors I’ve spoken to, and how much credit we’re getting on our next bill.

I’ve had a health-insurance company change their policy so that my bill was one penny more per month, and when my check was one penny short, they tried to cancel me (while I was pregnant, no less). That time, I called the Department of Labor and they advocated for me 'til I was reinstated. On a smaller scale, I’ve gotten partial credit on my cable bill because of a weekend-long outage, a credit to my ZipCar account because of a weird situation at the parking site, and a $25 credit to a store whose site crashed during a big sale (yeah, it was Missoni). And that’s just in the past few months.

I’ve also found out that I was in the wrong, in which case I always politely thank the customer-service rep for straightening me out -- because their time is worth a lot, and it’s not their fault I made a mistake (or their company is being a jerk).

Of course, I’m a master negotiator -- I come from a long line of hagglers on both sides of my family. After listening to me finessing the purchase of our car, my husband told me, “I’m going to make sure I never have to get divorced from you.”

As I said, though, companies are getting harder and harder to deal with. It used to be a sure bet that I would get a replacement pan if I sent in one from my guaranteed-for-life set, but the last time I tried, I got my same old pan back (and was out shipping). When Amazon didn't extend their free Prime service as I asked them to, I canceled my most recent order and bought my daughter Penelope's bike at a local shop -- which I shoulda done in the first place.

But if you don’t ask, they can’t say no. There are people who say their time isn’t worth it, but I’m not one of them. If your bill seems wrong, speak up. Ask why it’s different this month. Ask if there’s anything you can do to bring it down. Mention how long you’ve been a customer. Tell them what a good experience you’ve had with the company, and how you’d hate to leave it. Be nice. Be persistent. It works. Keep your money!

Have you fought a company over an issue like this and won? What worked for you?

Image via kate*/Flickr

christmasdecorating, home finances


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

nonmember avatar jmaymay

I once called our satellite provider to cancel HBO. They said they would, but then they didn't for some reason (their system was down, I dunno). It took me another month or two to call them again to remind them to cancel it, and I haggled my way into getting a $15 credit for 3 months because of their error (even though I waited so long before calling them again). It's amazing what you can get when you're nice AND relentless about something. I never ever get mean or angry. Sugar goes a lot further than vinegar!

Momma... MommaMolly04

Direct TV continues to increase our monthly bill. I call them every time.  Yet every time I am reminded of the huge amount of money it will cost me to break my contract......

Peajewel Peajewel

I do fight for things like this.  I fought with AT&T for soooooo long over their "nationwide long distance" plan I was signed up for.  This was just before you could get phone through cable and have no long distance.  I got the nationwide long distance because my husband and I moved to an area that was long distance from everyone we knew even though we were just one town over.  When I got my first bill I had all kinds of long distance charges and their explanation was that their nationwide did not include local long distance.  I truly fought them for a long time on it and finally just told them they could put their phone where the sun did not shine because I did not remain calm.  tee hee -- In this day and age though there is no reason for a land line and we have not had one for about three years now. 

ceciliam ceciliam

I never have. I've never had to.

momka... momkaribg

I never have forgot my bill.

Leele... Leelee1008

yes, I know that its tough answering the phones and listening to people complaine about stuff. but sometimes to get your point across you have to get stern

allie... alliesmom112

Yes my dish bill is $63 every month then 1 month it shot up to 97 I called and asked why the big difference and the csr tried to say that even though when we signed up we were promised a rate for 2 years but that they had decided to raise their rates so I was going to have to pay it. I talked to a super viser who adjusted my bill and it has been right ever since.

daerc... daerca574

I contstantly complain about my bills going up.  It does pay to spend a few minutes haggling to get those bills down!!

jessi... jessicasmom1

I do not get these , but let it happen now that I said that and you better bet I am talking to a supervisor

Cori Whitney

Direct TV is the worst about that! We had a set deal and all of a sudden there was billing for movie channels (the HBO, STARZ package) that I never even ventured to or requested. I called, was polite, led to arguing, then it was taken care of. This process happened 3 times! I finally contacted BBB and it was resolved. They STILL add on bs charges and I STILL have to call and correct them. I can't WAIT until June when the contract is up.

1-10 of 27 comments 123 Last