Should Treehouses Be Banned From Backyards?

73

treehouseWe've all had the experience of being at a pal's house and thinking, "Well... that doesn't seem safe." We steer our kids away from the trampoline/glass coffee table/sheer cliff, and proceed on home.

But what if we took another tack? What if we called the county and demanded someone change their home to suit our comfort levels?

This is exactly the kind of thing going on right now -- with backyard tree-houses. They’re a classic bit of American life, the kind of thing childhood dreams are made of – and often, for the lucky among us, where kids really do go to run their imaginations, or just read comics in the lazy summer heat.
 
But one family’s annoying experience shows how today’s world seems to be sacrificing too much in a quest for a bubble-wrapped childhood. The question is: Don't I get to make the safety rules in my own home?

Look, I’m not into the whole “kids today are too coddled” argument. I am fine with coddling my children, in fact, and think those of us who are more hyper about our kids’ safety are probably reacting sensibly to things that happened to us and our friends.
 
But this story just makes me mad: a landscape-architect dad in Washington State engineered a spectacular treehouse for his 10-year-old twin boys, and an anonymous complaint from a neighbor may lead to their having to tear it down.
 
The tree house is a marvel of engineering. It’s built to be part of the tree, with no damage to the natural world around it. Take a gander at the video if you don’t believe me.
 
Really, people? In an age when video games and 1,000 channels of cable TV make it nearly impossible to say “kids, go play outside,” you’re going to punish kids for climbing trees? Not only that – you’re going to do so on their own property, where it’s their parents’ job to supervise them?

This is their property, their home, and from what the article says, you can't even see the tree-house easily if you're not standing right under it. So someone's sticking their nose way, way into their business.

The Free-Range Kids website lists at least two other cases where treehouses have been torn down. As she puts it, “I get that it’s a liability. All treehouses are. I just wonder when and how society will ever get back to accepting SOME risk, now that even the tiniest risk (and this is a little bigger than tiny) is seen as abominable.”

The Treehouse Guide, a website devoted to helping people plan and build their own treehouses, has a page dedicated to treehouse safety. Included on that page is a guide to keeping the law off your back when building a leafy getaway – that’s how common it is for people to get in trouble for their treehouses.

“My impression of a treehouse is that it is a fun exercise - something that takes hard work to build but which will give you a huge sense of achievement and a lasting, useful addition to your garden,” says Patrick Fulton, the site’s founder.

What's more important: private property, or public safety? Certainly, more safety is better, and the Center for Injury Research is on the case. But is it really a better use of a town’s resources to track down one well-cared-for structure on a family’s private property … or should those tax dollars be going to, say, a shelter for kids that are actually homeless, or hungry, or mistreated?

Because when it comes to treehouses -- they really are the stuff that dreams are made on.
 
Do you think this tree house should come down? Do you make the safety rules on your property? Tell us in the comments!
 
Image via emdot/Flickr

creative reuse, going green, home safety, kid spaces, inspirations, newsworthy, outdoors, safety, summer safety, yards

73 Comments

To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

butte... butterflyfreak

If you're not comfortable letting YOUR kids play in the treehouse, then DON'T LET THEM. But I don't think anyone has the right to tell somebody else what they can or can't do on their own property. This makes me so sad....

angev... angevil53

people need to realize there's literally a risk in walking outside, or even staying inside! there's risk to getting out of bed in the morning! there's nothing wrong with a kid playing in a treehouse, god forbid they walk up some stairs! they might fall down them! just like trampolines, johnny jumpers, and swingsets anything can hurt you even if you are paying attention. AND kids get hurt and heal most of the time, it's a part of growing up!

Freela Freela

There's risk in absolutely everything, and it's up to parents (and kids) to determine what is an acceptable risk.  If the parents are comfortable with the treehouse, than that should be their decision if it's on private property.  Honestly, the risk of getting injured playing outside in a treehouse are probably a thousand times lower than the risk of early onset diabetes from sitting on the couch eating potato chips watching tv because it's 'too risky' to play in the yard, or the park, or to ride your bike down the street, or to otherwise get up and do something!

nonmember avatar Shelly

It's not about public safety. It's PRIVATE property. The public doesn't have access to it. If you don't like it, don't send your kids there. Pools are MUCH more dangerous. So are lakes. Lets start filling pools with concrete and drying up lakes. While we're out it, take away bikes, skateboards, roller skates. All of those cause more injuries and death then a treehouse. My biggest fear...if it starts, where does it stop?

nonmember avatar FartOnMyHeart

I wish I had a huge tree on property that I owned so that my husband could build our boy a treehouse. That family deserves a treehouse for their children. Treehouses are the stuff being a home-owner is all about! Having the freedom to build structures in the backyard must be awesome! How dare someone try to take that freedom away!

AngiDas AngiDas

This is what our country has become. A nanny state. We need to take it back!

Anast... Anastazia975

This is exactly why I say that giving the government the right to make laws over our bodies as if we were incompetent to decide for ourselves, in turn gives them the right to do this. You cannot give the government control over any part of your life. We should be able to decide what is right for us from who we marry(or don't) how many kids, and whether or not we have tree houses.

Anast... Anastazia975

This is exactly why I say that giving the government the right to make laws over our bodies as if we were incompetent to decide for ourselves, in turn gives them the right to do this. You cannot give the government control over any part of your life. We should be able to decide what is right for us from who we marry(or don't) how many kids, and whether or not we have tree houses.

ashjo85 ashjo85

Stay out of my backyard!

ceciliam ceciliam

Are the neighbors complaining about the safety of the treehouse or the fact that it is an eyesore?

1-10 of 73 comments 12345 Last
F