Follow The Stir

Soldier Dog's Treatment Is an Insult to the Military

by Megan Van Schaick on February 11, 2011 at 8:30 PM

german shepherdBasco, an 80-pound German Shepherd, was recently discharged from the military after two tours of duty in Iraq. Basco’s no ordinary dog. He spent his time in Iraq sniffing out bombs, putting his life on the line each and every day to protect our troops and the people of Iraq. He’s a true war hero, one who was lucky enough to make it home alive.

You would think he'd receive a hero's welcome, right? Fanfare, adoration and respect galore. He's receiving something for his service, but it's probably not what you expect.

Basco's reward for his service to his country? Scientific experimentation.

You see, Basco suffers from osteoarthritis in his hips. We all know what happens to big dogs with hip problems. (In case you don’t, they are often forced to be put down because their hips just plain give out on them, rendering them immobile.)

Because Basco is older (he’s 7), he’s not a good candidate for traditional hip surgeries. His age and condition mean he’s simply less likely to recover well from surgery – just like an elderly person. So instead, doctors want to experiment on him with a stem cell therapy. Supposedly, the animals own stem cells are used to help regenerate tissue broken down by the ravages of arthritis.

Sounds like a good thing, right?

It should be. I’m all for treating this dog. I know I’d do just about anything necessary to save the lives of my dogs. But I also know that I would never knowingly subject them to what is essentially more stem cell research, to an experimental procedure with no real results to back it up.

This dog, a military hero, isn’t just being treated, he’s being experimented on. We are supposed to believe that highly controversial stem cell research is suddenly okay? Or is it just okay because he’s already served out his days in the military. They don’t need him anymore, so he gets thrown to the research wolves.

Basco deserves to be living in the lap of luxury, treated as a true hero to the country. He did what most human soldiers would never dream of, all without complaint. To render him a mere vessel of scientific experimentation is a horrific insult to the life he dedicated to our country.


What do you think of Basco's treatment?

 

Image via Mrs Logic/Flickr

Filed Under: pets

Comments

129
  • Elisa...
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Elisabeth

    February 11, 2011 at 8:40 PM
    I think that if I had a horribly painful medical issue and an experimental treatment could cure it I would totally try it. Stem Cell research isn't that controversial anymore because they don't have to use fetus material anymore...This shouldn't be a big deal. I would give an experimental treatment to my cat if it was "try this or she won't have a life at all" This is probably the best thing that could happen for this dog. Think about it... :)
  • Chris...
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Christine

    February 11, 2011 at 8:41 PM
    I have mixed feelings about how Basco is being treated. The dog lover and American in me thinks he needs a ticker tape parade and a human servant to wait on him hand and foot the rest of his life. The daughter of a medical technologist in me knows that there can be so many positive things from stem cells, and in order to find these positive things research must be done. Scientific research can be done without the animals having any pain and where my mom works the animals are so loved. SO, like I said, I am torn. Bless this American Hero no matter what happens!
  • Pishyah
    --

    Pishyah

    February 11, 2011 at 9:19 PM
    So, what you're saying is that we should either put him down or do the painful surgery that will probably not work for him and he might not survive instead of trying something new first? Yeah, that'll show him.
  • Jen
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Jen

    February 11, 2011 at 9:20 PM
    I hope for your sake you, you family or you pets never come down with a rare or incurable condition. Sometimes you have to use new or experimental treatments. It's not like they are using dead babies, they're using the dogs own stem cells. Actually, I do pray you anti stem cell / anti any and all research and experiment people do come down with something rare or incurable. Because only then will you all realize that we all deserve to be given the best chance. You said yourself, the only other option would be to put him down. Yeah, because I'm sure he'd rather be dead than experimented on.
  • Jlynn...
    --

    JlynnDoyle

    February 11, 2011 at 9:36 PM

    I really don't think they are doing anything wrong here.  It's not like they are trying to make the dog grow 2 heads.  they are trying to fix his hips.  What are they supposed to do, nothing at all & just let him suffer in pain & not be able to walk or there is the option of doing surgery that he may not be able to recover from.  Neither of those seem like great options either.  the article seems to leave out all the facts.  Is there potential damaging side effects from trying this? Is there at least hope that this may actually work for this dog who deserves to live out his full life in as much comfort as possible?  this article is very much one sided.


  • Chris...
    --

    Christina807

    February 11, 2011 at 9:43 PM
    He still has a family. He isn't living in some research facility, so what exactly is the problem here?
  • Darla
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Darla

    February 11, 2011 at 11:27 PM
    They are giving him a hero's treatment by trying the most cutting edge therapy they have available. They are giving it everything they have to save this dog and prolong his life. If it works, he will have the best chance he could have had. How do you know there is no data for this "experimental procedure with no real results to back it up."? Have you read PubMed? Do you have a PhD in stem cell research? Where is your citation? I work in animal research, not stem cells, but vaccine development. They will treat that dog with utmost dignity and respect. Far better than most people treat their pets. He will have access to the best veterinary care available. How is it wrong to give him every chance at a better life?
  • Sam
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Sam

    February 12, 2011 at 2:28 AM
    I know Basco and his mom, Debbie Richter. (BTW, the military did not disclose Basco's condition upon his adoption.) Debbie takes in shepherds with difficulties and she would try to move mountains to relieve his pain. He is being treated at Oregon State University,which has a fine vet school, and she is paying the cost of the surgery herself. This is not the same procedure used in humans. Why second guess these efforts when you have no apparent qualifications to assess them?
  • Jazzfox
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Jazzfox

    February 12, 2011 at 3:26 AM
    I love all the rational responses to this post. I wish Basco the best and am glad that he's in the capable hands of the vet school in my state. The military should pay for his medical treatment since the wear-and-tear on his hips was probably aggravated, if not caused, by his military service. Treat him like any other soldier.
  • Manny...
    -- Facebook comment from

    Manny Osou

    February 12, 2011 at 4:10 AM
    I have a degenerative knee and have 5 marginally successful surgeries. Most of them are fairly archaic, including microfracture which basically is drilling of the bone in hopes of stimulating cartilage growth. I would love to be able to get stem cell tissue implants, even at an experimental level, which of course are not yet available for people. There really isn't a downside to this, because the alternatives are either a painful knee condition, or total knee replacement. Knee replacement is great for relieving the pain, but will never work structurally as a real knee does. Orthopedic knee surgery hasn't changed a whole lot in 30 years, and stem cell tissue and other cartilage regeneration techniques are still out there on the horizon, in some part due to misguided opinions like this.
1-10 of 129 comments

To leave a comment, log in as a CafeMom member:

Log In

OR, use our non-member comment form: