Swine Flu Vaccine: One Doctor's Opinion

Healthy Living 11

swine flu guide

h1n1 vaccineAll this week we've been talking to CafeMoms about whether or not their family will receive the H1N1 vaccine to prevent the swine flu.

AmyTuteurMD, an obstetrician gynecologist and mom of four, disagreed with some of the information in our posts. She runs AskDr.Amy.com, Open Salon, and The Skeptical OB, writing primarily about childbirth, home birth, and alternative health. I asked her to share her thoughts with us.

CafeMom: Will you and your children be getting the H1N1 vaccine?

At the moment, I am not eligible to get the vaccine because I am not in a high risk group. When it becomes widely available, I will get it. My children will be getting the vaccine.

Many moms are concerned about both the safety and efficacy of the H1N1 vaccine. Can you speak to this?

As far as efficacy and safety are concerned, it is important to keep in mind that the H1N1 vaccine is made exactly the same way as the seasonal flu vaccine.

There are many different influenza viruses and they are all capable of changing rapidly. That's why a new batch of seasonal flu vaccine is produced each year targeted to the strains that are expected to be common in the coming season. Typically preparation of the batch begins as one flu season ends since it takes so long to produce it.

Each batch is based on the flu strains common in the last season and flu trends around the world. Of course there is always a possibility that a new strain will arise between the time that the batch is started and the vaccine is ready, but typically new strains are similar to old ones and although the seasonal flu vaccine is not perfect, it is usually good enough to get the job done.

H1N1 flu was identified after this year's batch of seasonal flu vaccine was in production. Had it been found earlier it would have been added to this year's batch. H1N1 is not more lethal than the typical seasonal flu, but it is unusual in that it is particularly deadly in children and pregnant women. The CDC could have opted to ignore it, since it was too late to put it into the seasonal vaccine. However, because the virus was unusually harmful to children and pregnant women, the decision was made to begin another batch of flu vaccine targeted to H1N1.

So the H1N1 vaccine is just like the seasonal flu vaccine except that it is directed against a new strain of influenza. There is no reason to believe that the efficacy and side effects will be any different than the seasonal flu vaccine since it is prepared in exactly the same way. Indeed, to date there have been no reports of unusual reactions to it.

The bottom line is that H1N1 was identified too late to put it into the seasonal flu vaccine, otherwise it would have been put in. The new strain was so dangerous, however, that the CDC decided to begin a new, additional batch in order to offer protection against H1N1.

For more information on H1N1 vaccine recommendations, please check out AmyTuteurMD's piece, What Would You Do If You Were the CDC?.

Thank you to AmyTuteurMD for sharing this info with us!

Will you get the H1N1 vaccine?


Related Posts:

Swine Flu Vaccine: Another Mom's Take 

Why One CafeMom Will Not Get the Swine Flu Vaccine

28 Pregant Women Died From H1N1

cold & flu, illness, in the news, swine flu


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

auror... aurorabunny

Sooo glad that my family does not get vaccines, especially this one.

RanaA... RanaAurora

She should have read what Science Spot wrote. A lot of us opting out are doing so for reasons other than just being "afraid"of a vaccine.

auror... aurorabunny

I also would point anyone looking for an unbiased opinion toward Science Spot's article. 

This is coming from a doctor which makes it automatically biased.  Most pieces from adamant non-vaxxers (and I say that respectfully because I AM one) are going to be biased as well.

NeiceeP NeiceeP

Both of my teenagers, Hannah/Nicholas are now recovering from H1N1. Both are both feeling normal enough to shower (YEAHHHH), and normal enough to argue who gets the remote- fyi a silent, sick house is no good, I like them fiesty-ish again.

scien... science_spot

Thank you ladies for the raves!  And while I agree with almost this entire article.... there is one thing I need to point out:

and although the seasonal flu vaccine is not perfect, it is usually good enough to get the job done.

The efficacy data speaks for itself.  About 50% of vaccinees get immunity.  From here we still have to factor in the error rate of having a different strain in circulation than what is in the vaccine.  I disagree it "gets the job done".

shanl... shanlaree

I have 3 girls and all are fully vaccinated. We all get the flu shot every year and will definitely be getting the H1N1 vaccination. We have never had a problem with vaccinations and have never known anyone to have had problems. So for my family, this is why we do it:)

momav... momavanessa

I don't know if I will but my son gets his vaccines and so if the doctor says he should then I would consider it!

auror... aurorabunny

I don't know if I will but my son gets his vaccines and so if the doctor says he should then I would consider it!

momavanessa Oct. 11, 2009 at 5:54 PM

This is the type of thing that genuinely makes me sad.  PLEASE do some vaccine research.  PLEASE.  If you end up coming to the exact same conclusions as your doctor, fabulous.  But at least you will know what you're putting into your child and why.  Doctors are not gods and to take what they say blindly can be very dangerous.  I don't care if people vaccinate or not; but being educated is so so important.

damira damira

although i don't think we are getting it, i do trust me & my children's doctors with our lives. why would we go to them otherwise??  i am going into the healthcare field and have doctors in the family and i don't think their opinions are biased because they are doctors. i  trust them with medical issues considering they have studied it extensively and they are professionals.

auror... aurorabunny

But they are humans.  They make errors and incorrect judgements, just like all humans.  Lots of them also have agendas of their own, again, just like many other humans.

Not taking the time to educate yourself on something so important is just plain irresponsible.  Sorry but it's true.  As I said above, if you end up concurring with your doctor, wonderful.  But at least don't be too lazy to do some research when it comes to something as important as your childrens health. 

1-10 of 11 comments 12 Last