Woman Gets Mastectomy After Mistakenly Being Told She Had Breast Cancer (VIDEO)

OMG 18

judy valenica nightlineThirty-seven million American women get routine mammograms every year, and quite frequently, doctors find an abnormality, which leads to a biopsy. We hope that the biopsy results will turn out benign, but what if it's actually cancer? What if we're told it's cancer ... but it's NOT? That's the nightmare Judy Valencia from Saginaw, Michigan shared with Nightline's Cynthia McFadden this week ...

When Judy's doctors saw an abnormality on one of her mammograms, they told her to get a biopsy of her breast tissue. And based on the results of that biopsy, she was told she had cancer. Then, she was told she had two choices: A lumpectomy to remove the cancerous portion or a mastectomy to remove her entire breast. Because she had a strong family history of breast cancer, she ended up having both breasts removed. But when she couldn't retrieve paperwork from the hospital for her insurance, she hired a lawyer ... who found out through a specialist in NYC that Valencia never had the disease.

Wow. Can you even fathom ...

"There is no one who questions a biopsy and gets it double checked," Judy told Nightline. Whether it's because of the emotions involved or the blind trust we have in our doctors and tests like a biopsy, getting a second opinion with matters like these is definitely more rare than common. And that's something Judy's obviously speaking up about and hoping her story leads women to question more and seek second opinions.

More from The Stir: Marine Shaves His Head & Races for Breast Cancer in a Heartwarming Act of Love

According to Dr. Elisa Port, one of the nation's leading breast surgeons who works at Mount Sinai's Dubin Breast Center, there are women out there like Judy who end up misdiagnosed just because they're being treated by someone with a lack of expertise to know what is in front of them. It's unnerving, to say the least.

While she's grateful to be cancer-free and be able to hug her grandchildren, Judy still believes, "Nothing is the same." She is suing the hospital and the doctors who initially diagnosed her with breast cancer for damages. There's no doubt in my mind she should win everything she's asking for. And if women hear her story and are more likely to get a second opinion, she'll have won even more.

You can check out the Nightline segment here ...


What do you make of Judy's story? Does this make you more likely to seek a second opinion for a diagnosis?


Image via ABC

cancer, breasts, doctors


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Wheep... Wheepingchree

I think with something as life-altering as getting a masectomy, I would have gotten a second opinion in the first place.  Not that this woman is in the wrong at all, it just seems to make sense to me to have more than one doctor working on me if I were to get a part of my body removed.

nonmember avatar Anon

If she has a "strong" family history of breast cancer sounds like she would've ended up needing it anyway. Some women get mastectomies early on for that exact reason without even waiting for it to develop.

Cynthia Parten

I think her comment that people never get second opinions is kind of ridiculuous. I understand why the woman made the choice she did, given her family history. But I would never just accept the first diagnosis I get, history or not.

Miche... MichelleK41

Always, always get a second opinion.

Bmat Bmat

Yes, it is a lesson for sure. 

elasmimi elasmimi

I am very strongly against frivolous lawsuits, but if anyone ever had reason to sue, this is that case!

lalab... lalaboosh

...really? It's uncommon to get a second opinion before a huge surgery?! It's official, I'm on a planet full of MORONS!

MamaB... MamaBear2cubs

Oh wow. I am always advocating 2nd opinions.Poor woman!

kellynh kellynh

OMG!! How awful!! Always get a second opinion!! 

1-10 of 18 comments 12 Last