Follow The Stir

We Tried It

8 Popular Diet Myths Exposed!

by Aunt Becky on August 22, 2012 at 2:20 PM

Seems like every time you turn on the TV, surf the web, or talk to friends, the world has a new-and-improved diet plan which assures you that you'll take off "10 pounds in 10 minutes!" (or some such nonsense).

As a nurse, I know that the answer to losing weight is a simple equation: eat less + exercise more = weight loss.

So let's go ahead and examine 8 popular diet myths -- then discover the truth.

Myth #1: Small, more frequent meals will improve your metabolism. Eat like you're an animal in the wild instead of doing the more substantial breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

Truth: Food doesn't affect metabolism very much; if you want to lose more weight, build up your muscles. This means at rest, you'll burn extra calories.

Myth #2: Alternating between meals of carbs and protein will help with weight loss, as each uses different enzymes for digestion, thereby furthering weight loss.

Truth: Our digestive tracts are smart -- they can handle digesting a number of food groups at once. Doing so will actually cause you to drop pounds.

Myth #3: Don't eat in the evening. Close your kitchens at 8 p.m. because the food you eat at night sits in your system while you sleep and turns into fat.

Truth: Calories don't have a clock -- the body uses its calories the same way all times of the day. The issue with night eaters is that they often OVER eat, which is why cutting out snacking at night can help lose the pounds.

Myth #4: Coffee helps you lose weight because it's a diuretic, so it will make you, you know, go to the bathroom. A lot. Kind of like a laxative.

Truth: I WISH! Coffee can help with suppression of appetite, but the amount of coffee you'd have to drink would be far greater than the couple of cups most people drink.

Myth #5: Milk helps you slim down -- the theory is that calcium helps the body break down fats more easily, leading to weight loss.

Truth: Milk doesn't have magical calorie-burning properties, though it IS good for you. When you're dieting, try low-fat versions of milk and milk products. The calcium DOES a body good.

Myth #6: Pasta packs on the pounds. All those carbs ... eesh.

Truth: It's not carbs that make you fat -- extra calories do, no matter what form they come in. Protein, veggies, and fruit can all pack on the pounds. Practice everything in moderation.

Myth #7: Diet programs are the best way to lose weight. You need professional help to really do it right!

Truth: Losing weight is about changing your eating habits and you can do that on your own. While prescriptive diets will help to lose weight in the short term, in the long run, someone who wants to lose weight and have it stay off needs to rethink their whole way of eating.

Myth #8: You have to DRASTICALLY cut your caloric intake. So stop eating any big meals and skip some meals entirely!

Truth: Most of us can't survive on extremely low-calorie diets indefinitely. Once again, they can help take off weight quickly, but this can lead to yo-yo dieting after a while, and those extra pounds you shed could come back!

What other diet myths can you think of?


Image via puuikibeach/Flickr

Filed Under: diets, eating habits, eating healthy

Comments

5
  • butte...
    --

    butterflyfreak

    August 22, 2012 at 2:41 PM

    The best thing you can do for your body is cut out all the processed foods. I have stopped buying pretty much all convenience foods, no more mac and cheese or Top Ramen in this house.


  • the4m...
    --

    the4mutts

    August 22, 2012 at 4:05 PM
    @butterflyfreak~ hey we just did that too, and I lost a whole pant size in 10 days :D
    Ain't we fart smellers? Er... smart fellers ;)
  • Amanda
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Amanda

    August 22, 2012 at 5:02 PM
    What I hate about "diets" is that they force people to believe that if you just focus on 'food', you will lose weight. I'm sorry, but the ONLY thing that has kept me at an ideal weight is strength training & cardio workouts. Exercise is the key, along with eating non-processed foods (kudos, butterflyfreak), and making a lifestyle out of it :) Feed your body NUTRIENTS, not calories.
  • Amanda
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Amanda

    August 22, 2012 at 5:02 PM
    What I hate about "diets" is that they force people to believe that if you just focus on 'food', you will lose weight. I'm sorry, but the ONLY thing that has kept me at an ideal weight is strength training & cardio workouts. Exercise is the key, along with eating non-processed foods (kudos, butterflyfreak), and making a lifestyle out of it :) Feed your body NUTRIENTS, not calories.
  • PonyC...
    --

    PonyChaser

    August 22, 2012 at 9:37 PM

    Honestly, I have to disagree with the carb one. There are *some* people out here (me) who are extremely sensitive to carbohydrates and sugars. So much so that I cannot drink, because my body reacts to it (no, I'm not drunk). Cutting out most carbs - those found in breads, for example - and increasing my lean protein intake has helped me immensely. Not only do I lose weight faster, my head is clearer, I have more energy, and I sleep better.

    I'm not saying that a "paleo-style" or low-carb diet is for everybody, I know others who have done just the opposite - lost weight just cutting calories, or cutting out proteins, fats, whatever.

    I think the biggest thing that people need to learn is that no "diet plan" is going to work for everybody. I trained for a race, ran a couple miles every day for six months, and never lost a pound. I did NOT increase my exercise, and did the low carb/high protein thing for a couple weeks and lost 15. You have to know your body and how it reacts to things, or nothing is going to work.


1-5 of 5 comments

To leave a comment, log in as a CafeMom member:

Log In

OR, use our non-member comment form: