That Prescription Refill Might Be Boosting Your Breast Cancer Risk

pink pills forming venus symbolFor years, we've heard that hormonal drugs (like in birth control pills and menopause treatments, like conjugated estrogens) can be hazardous to women's health and spike breast cancer risk. But now, a study done by researchers at the Breast Cancer Oncology Center at the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute in Boston shows that post-menopausal women who took estrogen alone -- thought to be safe and possibly even slightly beneficial in terms of cancer risk -- might have a problem if they're on the treatment for years.

The research tracked the health of about 60,000 nurses and found that use of any kind of hormones for 10 years or more slightly raised the chances of developing breast cancer. I hate to say it, but well, hello, YEAH.

This isn't that surprising. Taking something that your body is not producing naturally in a systemic way is probably going to have a negative effect in some form or another. I'm sure the women in this study weren't on bioidentical forms of estrogen or progesterone, which I could see making a big difference, being that your body actually identifies those drugs as closer to what it created pre-menopause.

But, that said, whether or not women choose to take hormonal drugs is a very delicate matter. It really drives me nuts when the medical industry gravitates to any singular formulation as the catch-all fix for all women. Because we're just not built that way. Similarly, there's not a one size fits all solution for menopausal symptoms. We each have very unique hormonal and genetic interplay -- even after menopause -- so it would stand to reason that we should all be treated as the complex beings that we are.

It's why I appreciate when doctors (usually naturopathic and holistic ones) make a point of checking where a woman stands hormonally before proceeding with any particular treatment or developing a preventative protocol. After all, too much of a certain type of natural estrogen in the body is known to elevate breast cancer risk. I actually found out just last year that my "good"-to-"bad" estrogen ratio was slightly skewed, so I'm actually on balancing herbs/vitamins (DIM and evening primrose oil) to rectify that.

It's no wonder that when women are being given a "one-size-fits-all" drug for years on end, disease rates rise. If we can take anything away from this research, it's that we need non-systemic, more individualized and holistic treatments to bolster our well-being -- during our reproductive years and well after.

How do you feel about hormonal drugs and the associated elevated risk of breast cancer?


cancer, breasts, hormonal imbalances, drugs

4 Comments

To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Katsa... Katsandkids

this is one of the reasons I will not use any hormonal birth control methods www.ditchthepill.org has a lot of info on the subject

Katie Trent

every woman is different. i use birth control and i dont have any medical issue or anything like that because of it.

nonmember avatar Cathy

Your facts are WRONG! Read the study both estrogen alone and estrogen combined with progesterone raises the risks for breast cancer.

Param Eswaran

IT IS TRUE THAT ALL FAST FOOD EATERS DO NOT GET DISEASES. ALL BABIES WHO DRINK COW MILK DO NOT HAVE LACTO ALLERGY.ALL WOMEN WHO TAKE HARMONAL DRUGS ARE NOT SUFFERING.
BUT IT IS A FACT THAT SOME ARE AFFECTED BY THESE AND WITH CANCER FOLLOWING.
THE REASONS FOR ALL THESE TRENDS ARE TO BE FOUND, IN FINDING OUT WHICH GENERATION DO THEY BELONG IN FAST FOOD, OILY FOOD, USAGE OF HARMNL DRUGS, ETC....FOR INSTANCE, THE DISEASE RATE IN THE USA IS HIGHER THAN ANYWHERE ELSE.BECAUSE THERE ONLY PEOPLE HAVE HAD CHANGE OF LIFESTYLE AND FOOD AND DRUG HABITS. THE USA LEAD IT. OTHERS WILL FOLLOW IT. IMMUNITY AND RESISTANCE ARE WEAKENING GENERATIONS AFTER GEN AND THAT IS THE REASON FOR THE DIFF.
THANKS.
D.PARAMESWARAN, naturopath
www.sunflowerdance.com

1-4 of 4 comments