The Ultimate Shamrock Shake Recipe for St. Patrick's Day

shamrock shake

It's almost St. Paddy's Day, and you know what that means? Well, for me, it means shamrock shake season. Last year we did a taste test between the McDonald's classic and our homemade version. You'll have to read the post to find out which shake won. BUT -- in case you want to make your own, we found the ULTIMATE Shamrock Shake recipe. Top Secret Recipes reverse-engineers popular fast food and other favorite foods. Their recipe makes enough for two shakes, so if you're making this for kids you may want to double the recipe.

Notice that their recipe calls for mint extract, but not peppermint extract. Also, I'm not sure why they use "low fat milk" rather than whole. Maybe it's to get the right consistency? I figure you're already making this with ice cream so you might as well go all the way and use whole milk. But that's just me. I'm decadent like that.

Shamrock Shakes by Top Secret Recipes

Serves two


2 cups vanilla ice cream

1 1/4 cups low fat milk

1/4 teaspoon mint extract

8 drops food coloring


Combine all ingredients in a blender and blend on high speed until smooth. Stop blender to stir with a spoon if necessary to help blend ice cream.

Pour into two 2-ounce cups and serve each with a straw.

For grownups only: If you want yours spiked, I recommend an ounce of vodka or Irish whiskey per serving. Add in the blender when you're almost finished blending.

More from CafeMom: 10 Boozy (and Not-So-Boozy) Beverages for St. Patrick's Day

Read More >