Top 9 Restaurant Chains in America -- Is Your Favorite on the List?

Yum! 26

elmer'sWhat are the best chain restaurants in America? Consumer Reports sent 47,565 people out for dinner to find out. Diners rated 102 sit-down restaurants on taste, value, service, noise, menu, cleanliness, and mood. The top nine restaurants rated consistently high in all of these categories.

Here's what surprised me about the results: The top restaurants are mostly regional chains, not the mega national chains we all know about. Not what I expected to see! That's why you might see this list and think -- I've never even heard of half of these places! Keep reading to find out if your favorite restaurant is on this list.

Consumer Reports Top Chain Restaurants in America

  • Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano, 23 locations in 12 mostly Midwestern states
  • Black Angus Steakhouse, 45 locations in California, Washington, Arizona, Alaska, New Mexico, and Hawaii
  • Bob Evans, almost 600 locations in 18 states
  • Bravo Cucina Italiana, 47 restaurants in 20 states
  • First Watch, about 100 restaurants in 13 states
  • J. Alexander's, 33 locations in 13 states
  • Le Peep, 60 locations in 14 states
  • Elmer's, 25 locations in the Northwest
  • Fatz Eatz & Drinkz, 48 restaurants in the Southeast

And the worst chain restaurants? Friendly's and Waffle House. Sorry, guys. Looks like you need to clean up your act ... literally. Buffalo Wild Wings Grill & Bar is near the bottom of the list thanks to the service and the noise levels. Apparently diners don't really enjoy loud dining -- which makes me wonder why some places like Hard Rock Cafe crank the music so high. I know it's supposed to be all rock 'n' roll, but nobody likes screaming over their onion blossoms!

Anyway, it's great to see these smaller (or at least medium-sized) chains getting some recognition for keeping their customers happy. Maybe it's just easier to get it all right if you're a chain of 30 restaurants instead of trying to make the magic happen in dozens of restaurants all over the country. The big exception looks to be Bob Evans. Six hundred restaurants! Apparently they're doing something right.

I think I might keep this list handy for the next time I'm on a road trip somewhere. I've never been to any of these restaurants (I don't recall seeing any of the in New York City) and I'm starting to wonder if I'm missing out.

If you want to see ratings for all 102 restaurants, check out the August issue of Consumer Reports. The issue also has tips for saving when eating out.

Are any of your favorite restaurants on the top-nine list?


Image via goodiesfirst/Flickr


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

mustb... mustbeGRACE

Bob Evans here is an utter failure.

The wait staff are slow and lazy.

Won't go anymore. which is saying something as there aren't many places to eat out close by.

nonmember avatar Anowscara

I've lived in places with Black Angus Steakhouses and Fatz cafe's and I love both of them! Highly recommend them both if you ever get a chance to stop by :)

Kimbyann Kimbyann

Dennys should be on the worst list

Pinst... Pinstripes4

I loathe Denny's too. Are any of the best restaurant chains in the northeast? Possibly NY? I don't see any Bob Evans in my area.

kisse... kisses5050

 We support locally owned restaurants only.

nonmember avatar Carrie Ann

Who is "we" and why are they so smug?

DMart... DMartin21

There is a bob Evans in manhattan and southern nj.

Jenniy Jenniy

Love Bob Evans

kisse... kisses5050

carrie ann what is smug about saying "we"? My family and I feel it is important to support locally owned restaurants. By doing so you are keeping the money in the community not lining the pockets of a huge corporate greed machine. You are helping pay for a kids dance classes or the repairs on the roof of a neighbor not the vacation home of a CEO across the country or world. 95% of restaurants fail in the first five years because the little guy has a hard time competing with huge corporations who buy in bulk and sell crap and feed crap to the consumer. I owe it to my family and my community to do so.

jaxmadre jaxmadre

Ha! I worked at Friendly's. Yeahhh, they're pretty bad! lol
But I've never heard of any of these top restaurants.

1-10 of 26 comments 123 Last