Potato Salad Recipes -- With or Without Mayo?


potato salad

My brother's girlfriend and I got into a heated discussion this weekend about, of all things, potato salad -- no doubt in anticipation of warm weather and the approaching grilling season. She made the comment that she hates potato salad recipes that call for mayonnaise and hard boiled eggs, and I about fell off my chair. How could anyone say such a thing?

When it comes to potato salad, I'm a little biased. We have a recipe that's been in my family for years (it was my grandmother's), and we eat it at almost every family get-together. It's really plain, and really mayonnaisy, and probably really awful for you, but I don't care: It always makes me think of summer.

Nona's Potato Salad

6 Potatoes, peeled and cubed

1 Tablespoon grated onion

2 Hard boiled eggs, chopped

2 Celery stalks, diced

Mayonnaise to taste (about 1/2-3/4 cup)

1-2 teaspoons vinegar

Salt and Pepper

Boil potatoes, drain, and chill. Combine with onion, eggs, and celery. Add mayonnaise and vinegar until salad is desired consistency and has the perfect amount of tang. Season with salt and pepper.

Once I got over my potato salad elitism, I realized there are countless recipes with more of an oil-base dressing that still taste great. If you're anti-mayo (like my bro's GF), check out these recipes for Garlic and Herb Potato Salad or Bacon-Potato Salad. Either way, you won't be disappointed.

Do you prefer potato salad with or without mayo?


food, recipes


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

jeann... jeannesager

I'm a mayo kinda girl - but I do concede it's bad for you. I opt for light mayo, but I won't go to the non-fat kind because that's just too gross!

cafemama cafemama

Team mayo!

abels... abelsmama07

yes to mayo... no to eggs... blech

jeann... jeannesager

abels - I was hardcore anti egg in my potato salad for years, then I had my neighbor's with eggs and she made a convert outta me!

michi... michiganmom116

I can eat it with mayo and eggs or without. A favorite of ours WITHOUT mayo is German potato salad made with a sweet/sour vinegar dressing. We can eat it cold or hot.

writn... writnkitten

i don't do mayo (or eggs), but i've found that dijon mustard does the trick nicely.

MomIWant MomIWant

Yes to mayo! We only have potato salad a few times a year - mayo, eggs, bacon - so bad & yet taste so good!

Cafe... Cafe Jenn

Mayo of course, however, those recipes look good and I want to try them.

CherB... CherBearCM

To me that is the ONLY kind of potato salad! LOL I do like other ones but call them something else, potato salad to me must have lots of mayo ;)

1-9 of 9 comments