The first season of Bachelor in Paradise may have ended on a happy note, but one couple did leave us with a burning question in our minds. Um, after Robert Graham refused to hook up with Sarah Herron in the fantasy suite, all we want to know is: WHY wouldn't he get physical with her?!?
No, seriously ... WHY? I know during the finale, he indicated that he simply wanted to take things slow with her, blah, blah, blah. But since he apparently never relayed that message to Sarah before their overnight date, she woke up the next morning feeling sad, rejected, and basically downright embarrassed about trying to get it on with a dude who didn't seem interested.