How Are You Explaining Miley to Your Kids? 'The Stir' Writers Discuss! (VIDEO)

Video 5

Moms Matter Google Hangout

Love it or hate it, we can't stop talking about Miley Cyrus's VMA performance.

Personally, I'm still cringing, and my eyes burn every time I even think about it. I have never been more embarrassed for someone than I was for Miley at that moment.

The problem I'm having now is that my 9-year-old daughter is currently obsessed with Hannah Montana -- and she doesn't understand why she's not allowed to download Miley's newest, erm, body of work.

Several writers for The Stir talked with me today about how to explain "the new Miley" to our kids in this week's Moms Matter Google Hangout. Check it out -- and give me your best advice in the comments!

One interesting point that emerged during this discussion was that it's really not realistic to simply try to keep our kids from seeing and hearing the new Miley, particularly once they're school-aged. Our kids are being exposed to this stuff whether we like it or not -- at school, at friends' houses, on smartphones and on iPad and on computers and televisions. I have a parent lock on our TV, I don't allow my kids to do searches or look at YouTube on the Internet, and we don't listen to pop music -- yet my daughter still heard Miley's "We Like to Party" after a neighbor played it for her on her iPad when she came over to our house. UGH.

I had the 'wonderful' experience of explaining to my daughter why she couldn't download that song, even though it was performed by her beloved "Hannah Montana." I explained to my daughter that Miley was making bad choices lately, and that by trying to convince people she was an adult, she was overdoing it and acting more like a child than ever. I didn't enjoy having to have that conversation, but in retrospect I'm glad we did. Now, my daughter understands why she can't watch or listen to the latest Miley music -- and she's more likely (at this point anyway) to make the decision not to watch or listen to her even at a friend's house, even when I'm not around. This made me realize that it's more important to explain why we believe what we believe to our kids than to simply ban things without context.

I realize she has the right to say and do whatever she wants ... but I have to admit, I'm irritated as a mother that the actress known best to our children as "Hannah Montana" has chosen this route.

Those are my thoughts on the matter -- what are yours? How are you explaining Miley's actions to your kids? How will you do it if the subject comes up? And are you as irritated as I am that she's become such a moral "don't" for our kids?

 

miley cyrus

5 Comments

To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

nonmember avatar meliss

I don't think tv is nessicary for kids at all.

nonmember avatar Ashley

I agree with a lot of this, especially with the fact that Robin Thicke has been getting no backlash on his performance. One thing though, Miley's song is called "We Can't Stop" not We Like To Party. But listen to her new single Wrecking Ball, its the old Miley music.

amber... amberdotsmom

Kids need to understand the character they see is not the person that plays them.  Miley Cyrus is NOT Hannah Montana, she never was and agree or disagree with her recent performances she can't stay a cute child character forever.  Think of it like Emma Watson - sure the kids want to be Hermione and run around the yard waving sticks like wands but that doesn't mean they're allowed to see The Bling Ring.  Hermione is fiction and Emma is grown, so is Miley, so is anybody whose picture we had posted all over our walls at 13.  I don't want to take away play and fantesy for the kids but I really feel that stressing the difference between the character they play and the real life person is how we help keep kids from idolizing the stars themselves too much.

chigi... chigirl1228

This is getting ridiculous. Why can't anyone understand that Miley is not trying to be an adult, she is an adult. Was the performance terrible bc of bad dancing and singing? Yes. Was it vulgar and in poor taste? No, not for VMA standards. She did nothing new in that performance that teens and young adults aren't doing now. Twerking and tongue wagging are in FB photos and you tube videos. It is fine and your decision to allow your daughter to watch/listen or not. Face it, Hannah Montana is over. It was huge about 5 or more years ago. If you want your daughter to watch the reruns... cool on you but meanwhile the tv show actors and its large fanbase have all grown up.

Todd Vrancic

Miley Cyrus, as chigirl so eloquently stated, is legally an adult.  And, as amberdotsmom said, also eloquently,  Hannah Montanna is a fictional character, as a matter of fact, she's a twice fictional character, since in the episode I watched (my grandson was nuts for the show, go figure) Hannah Montanna was the alter ego of the main character so she could have a pop star career and still do normal things like go to school, etc. without getting swarmed by paparazzi and fans.

1-5 of 5 comments