'Game of Thrones' Recap: 'Red Wedding' Death Scene Is as Heartbreaking as Season 1's -- Why Do We Watch This Show??

TV Addict 11

Walder FreyIt's finally here: Episode 9 of Game of Thrones, "The Rains of Castamere," featuring the highly anticipated Red Wedding! I'll give you a moment to geek out. Fans knew what was coming after reading A Storm of Swords or checking out spoilers on the Internet -- and everyone was wondering how the show was going to pull off such a big, violent, insane, climactic moment.

The Red Wedding, featuring Robb Stark's uncle Edmure Tully marrying a Frey daughter, may trump all the big moments we've already seen from these amazing characters. What a season it's been! Such a heart-pounding final 10 minutes, I can't even put it into words.

If you haven't yet seen "The Rains of Castamere," please don't ruin it for yourself by reading on. SPOILERS AHEAD. Seriously, watch first, then check back later!

Even though some of us knew it was coming, a collective "holy f***" was most likely heard by all Game of Thrones fans during that amazing Red Wedding finale. At the beginning of the episode, after Catelyn Stark demands of her son Robb, "Show them how it feels to lose what they love," she is thinking of her dead husband Eddard, but little does she know what's in store for her family.

Before the wedding, Walder Frey offers the Starks his hospitality while Robb begs for Frey's forgiveness after breaking an alliance and marrying another. "One of them was supposed to be queen; now none of them are," Frey quips. He has so many daughters and granddaughters he can barely keep them straight in an oddly disturbing yet hilarious introduction. What a sicko. He also grossly inspects Talisa, Robb's preggo wife.

Edmure is actually quite happy with how pretty his new wife Roslin is. After they are married, Walder announces that it's time for the bedding, when the guys carry up the bride and the women accompany the groom, stripping them, to the room where they get it on.

Catelyn watches skeptically as a door closes. The Hound and Arya (whose relationship is full of tension yet somewhat endearing) approach the gate but are turned away. "The Rains of Castamere" begins to play. And I'm about to pass out.

And it starts when Frey announces he has a "gift" for his new queen. Suddenly, Talisa's viciously stabbed in the stomach, Robb Stark is riddled with arrows, and Catelyn is hit with one as well. Robb's men outside, sufficiently drunk, are all killed as Arya watches on. She approaches Grey Wind, Robb's direwolf, but sees soldiers kill him as well -- the direwolf's eyes slowly close in such a sad, forlorn moment.

After the initial violence when almost everyone on the Stark side is dead, Catelyn stands and begs for Robb's life, pleading that he get up and walk out, while he is kneeling and mourning over Talisa and his unborn child. Roose Bolton comes up to Robb, says, "The Lannisters send their regards," and stabs him in the chest. Catelyn cuts Walder's wife's throat in anguish, then a soldier comes up from behind her and casually does the same to her.

No more Talisa, baby Robb, Robb, Grey Wind, and Catelyn -- all in one scene.

If you're wondering who Roose Bolton is, he married a Frey granddaughter. A few episodes ago, he was reassured by Jaime Lannister that he would not be held responsible for cutting off Jaime's hand, after first making a deal with the guy who actually did. Bolton thought Robb was fighting a lost cause, so he decided to plot with Tywin and Frey to take him down.

The silence at the end credits was enough to make the entire Internet explode. Holy crap. My mind is blown. How do I continue on with this.

I guess I have to inform you that some other things happened besides the Red Wedding:

The Wildings and Jon Snow spy on an old man who breeds horses for the Night's Watch. Jon gives the old man a head's up and stops Ygritte from shooting him with an arrow. But Orell suggests Jon kill the old man when they catch up to him. Jon hesitates while Ygritte kills him instead.

Tormund Giantsbane orders the Wildings to kill Jon, but Jon fights back and is able to take out Orell. Orell's eagle bites and claws the crap out of Jon's face, but he is able to get on a horse and escape while an extremely pissed off Ygritte looks on.

Direwolves Summer and Shaggydog watch the whole thing go down. Bran is able to see Jon through Summer's eyes. Beforehand, Hodor freaks out Hodoring over lightning the while Wildings ride outside and hear them. Warging Bran's able to take over Hodor's body to shut him up, much to the surprise of his tiny group. Warging Bran! Finally!

Rickon sobs when Bran breaks the group up to protect him and because Osha refuses to go over the Wall. Bye Osha, Shaggydog, and Rickon -- and after an episode when Rickon finally has more than one line. After everything that's happened, people ought to stop complaining that there are too many characters on this show ...

Anyway, Jorah Mormont is clearly suspicious and jealous of hot Daario and his dimples, Daenerys's new ally. Still, Daario, Grey Worm, and Jorah make a pretty good team in combat and are able to open the gates to take the city. Daario and Daenerys are so going to get it on.

But still, all of that pales in comparison to losing so many beloved characters all in one scene. I can't believe what I just saw. Someone please hold me. What an amazing, heart-wrenching episode.

What did you think of "The Rains of Castamere" and the Red Wedding?


Image via HBO

books, recaps, television


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Lindsay Renee Edwards

I was fine reading your spoilers since I read the books. I cant WAIT to see this episode! Im in California, so it wont be on for another hr or so. I cant wait for season 4 even more-so! 

Bmat Bmat

I didn't suspect what was coming, although Frey came across from the beginning of the episode as threatening.  I hated seeing the wolf get killed.  I'm still numb from the violence of the episode.

Ronald Coen

Well I think they lost 30% of their viewers today.. I think 2 Darrens 2 Ms Elly 1 Bobby in a shower is nuff for me

nonmember avatar K

For all you saying that there going to loose fans... Read this thing called the BOOK you twits

nonmember avatar alicia

i was doing my daughter's hair as i watched well kinda, i listened and glanced up every few min but wasn't so into it till i glanced up and saw someone locking the doors as catelyn watched and i said to my daughter uh-oh thats not a good sign, next thing i knew talisa was being stabbed so much i let out a loud yell "HOLY FUCK!!" then i was literally dumb founded and speechless as i watched the rest of the scene. as soon as it was over i apologized to my daughter for cussing and just sat there for a few min wrapping my brain around what i just saw... it was gruesome, sad, but so freakin awesome!!! loved it!! gonna watch it again!

nonmember avatar Halo

No one is safe at war !!! Great show and I will keep watching because the best is yet to come.. Don't get too attached to any character .. Loved Robb but I knew he was going down he had too many warnings! What was he thinking marrying for love that's crazy talk in the seven kingdoms!

Lasha... LashaTumbai

Just watched. That was rough.

hexxuss hexxuss

Never watched the show(s) or read the books... which is probably too - sounds too convoluted lol.

nonmember avatar Mademosielle

My husband and I sat speechless with our mouths hanging open as this incredible tragedy unfolded.It was like having the wind knocked out of us.And the silence at the end with the credits only exacerbated the horrifying scene before it. Still at a loss to describe it all I can only say--HUH? What just happened?

LadyM... LadyMinni

You guys think the show is violent, try reading the books! GRRM loves to kill people, which is part of where his fanbase comes from. We like that he portrays the gore of war in a more realistic way. In most series, the main characters come away just fine. Not with him.


1-10 of 11 comments 12 Last