‘American Idol’ Producers May Fire All 4 Judges & These New Picks Would Be Awesome (PHOTOS)

american idol judgesEveryone is on the chopping block at American Idol -- even the judges! With the show seriously struggling with ratings, execs are considering cutting all four stars on the panel. That means Randy Jackson, along with newbies Mariah Carey, Nicki Minaj, and Keith Urban may all get a pink slip, according to The Wrap. For weeks there have been rumors that they want to bring Jennifer Lopez back, which would be great. During her tenure on the show, she was fantastic, connecting with the aspiring superstars and fans alike. But I say they need to think out of the box if they want to breath new life into the former hit. Take a look at our pick for a dream American Idol judges panel.

Who would you like to see on the show?

Image via American Idol

american idol start slideshow


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

LostS... LostSoul88

ugh American Idol will be over with if they had those judges. 

Dorothy Horton

American Idol is such a joke right now; first of all the Panel of so-called "Judges" are actually "critics" who are not qualified to do either. If they are going to have "Judges" then said judges should have a say in who stays and who goes; otherwise the final outcome becomes a "popularity" contest and being the "winner" has nothing to do with who is the most talented or who has the most potential, or who has the best "voice". The panel of Judges should be Music Industry Executives and Recording Company A&R People, if they really want to get it right. The average viewer just votes for who they like; and I don't watch the show regularly because their track record is lousy as far as I am concerned. The contestants should be the stars of the show and should not be upstaged by the people who have been sitting on the Panel for the last twelve seasons. Get it right American Idol; gimmicks don't work !!!!

nonmember avatar Elmer Velasquez

I would like to see all of them replaced with anyone else. This season I noticed favoritism towards African Americans, for some reason to hate on Angie Miller was not a problem, and they consistently worked at lowering her as a contestant. I feel that for some reason they made American viewers look at her as if she wasn't it, when indeed she was all. I hate to see two individuals get pity because of their race or things they have gone through in life. I feel that it was a dumb card to use, " Oh my parents died" or " Crying in every performance and putting a look like you will never make it" PATHETIC, MAYBE I SHOULD SHOUT MY STORY AND SOMEONE MAY GIVE ME A MILLION DOLLARS. American Idol doesn't make sense, most of the time weirdos win, and most of the time the good ones are kicked off. Also, Mariahs Video was very inappropriate for a family show.... WOW WHAT IS REALLY GOING ON?... ANGIE MILLER YOU ROCK!

1-3 of 3 comments