Scarlett Johansson's '50 Shades of Grey' Movie News Isn't All That It Seems

GossipMonger 22

scarlett johanssonAll of this Fifty Shades of Grey buzz is starting to drive me mad. One second Sheridan Smith is tweeting to fans that she's snagged the role of Anastasia and the next rumors are buzzing that Stephen Amell had a REAL meeting about playing Christian Grey. It's like every second someone says those four words -- the world goes mad.

Naturally fans of the steamy trilogy nearly flipped their lids earlier this week when a major fan website announced that it wasn't Smith, but Scarlett Johansson who has been cast as Ana. After adequate freak out time, the website revealed that it was all just an April Fools' joke. And thank GOD. I mean come on, could you ever see Scarlett actually playing Ana?

She's 100 percent wrong for the part for this major reason.

Her age! I was actually surprised to find out that she was only 28 considering I think she looks a bit older than that. I would have guessed mid-30s. Even so, she just looks older than the Ana that we loved in the Fifty Shades trilogy. She doesn't look like she should be hanging out in college bars  or writing for a school newspaper, she looks like she could be teaching the lecture classes.

It's something that always bothers me, when older actors who play a role much younger than they are. Often it doesn't read well. I mean hello, Olivia Netown-John did NOT look like she was high school age in Grease -- the woman was 30 when the film finally came out! Mario Lopez as a high school boy in Saved by the Bell? Yeah, wasn't buying it.

Who knows, maybe Scarlett could be a better fit could be Mrs. Robinson, perhaps? I could totally see her rockin' some leather.

Who do you want to play Anastasia Steele?


Image via Paul Frasser Bird/ Flickr

fifty shades of grey, celebrity


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Natalia Avila

Eeeewwww, I wouldn't see the movie if it was starring Scarlett!!

My pick for Anna would be either Lucy Hale, or Ashley Greene.

Ian somerhalder is the only Christian ;)

Diana Salveson Heitmann

I total agree Lucy Hale and Ian Somerhalder would be perfect choice and if he's not Christian I really don't want to see it he is so perfect they would be really foolish.

Kim Conley

Not Lucy Hale. It would b weird. Ian and Alexis bledel.

nonmember avatar Lynn

Alexis Bledel is another actress too old to play the part of a fresh faced 22 yr old just out of college.

Emily Aldis

Micheal Fassbemder for Christen Grey. and perhaps someone like the main girl from sucker punch/sleeping beauty... shes around the early 20's region and she looks young.

nonmember avatar Julian

Jennifer Lawrence should be at the top of the list. She's the perfect fit.

Dorothy Oates

I agree that Emma Watson should be Ana and i also think Christian should be Ian Somerhalder.

1-10 of 22 comments 123 Last