Nicki Minaj Is ‘American Idol’ Judge? Oh Hell No

OMG 11

nicki minajNot happy about this. According to Us Weekly, Nicki Minaj is the new American Idol judge and I, for one, am already exhausted by the idea. Nicki will join Mariah Carey on the judges' panel this winter; the third seat at their table has yet to be filled, but rumor has it that Joe Jonas could replace AI stalwart Randy Jackson, who'll be moved to a mentoring role.

I feel bad for whomever signs up to sit next to Nicki and Mariah because frankly, I'd rather cut out each of my freckles with a rusty Swiss Army knife than have to endure their over-the-top personalities and the concoction of perfume, hairspray and adrenaline that whirls around them like a cloud of cloying toxicity. 

Nicki and Mariah together -- it's too much.

Too much makeup, too much attitude, too much glitter, too many distractions. We always enjoyed an AI focal point on the judges panel. In the beginning, we viewers focused our attention on Simon Cowell. Sure, Paula Abdul would occasionally catch our eye when she slurred like a drunk mom and clapped like a seal, but for the most part, Simon had our full attention.

And when he left, we looked to Randy. Then when J. Lo came on, it was all eyes on her. Now, with Nicki and Mariah, we won't know where to turn. Watching them talk to the contestants from their table will be like watching a tennis match, only the tennis ball is made of fire and we're doused in lighter fluid. We'll stare at our TVs wide-eyed and terrified, totally unable to look away. Not exactly what I call a pleasant viewing experience.

There's only room for one ginormous ego on the Idol judges' panel, and I'm afraid with two, the show might explode, leaving an ambrosial wake of hair extensions and nail art flowing down the aisles.

I miss drunk Paula now more than ever.

Do you think Nicki Minaj will make a good Idol judge?


Photo via Christopher Macsurac/Flickr

american idol


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Heath... HeatherMazzone

And with that, they just insured that this WILL be the last season of AI, ever.

CanCa... CanCan123

It needed to end 5 years ago, what the hell happend to the last 3 winners, where are they now?

ImaSo... ImaSoulMom

Don't you have to have talent to judge talent? Maybe not. Hope this makes room for a good show!

nonmember avatar ly

I really thought this was a joke.

Hottm... Hottmomma607

AI sucks anyways! How long are they going drag this show out? Judges come&go on there like changing of underwear! If that had ex Lakers Cheerleader/Ms. 1 hit wonder I guess Nikki M. is ok? Not that'll I be watching!

Kelly Cantley

You've got to be kidding??? They just lost me as a viewer

twili... twilightsbella

They need to end this show already. I watched the first season with kelly clarkson but after that they lost me. I dnt even think the winners become famous singers besides kelly.

fmjohn1 fmjohn1

I CANNOT believe this! I hope its wrong. I can't stand Nicki Minaj. I don't know that I could stomach an episode if she'll be on there.

nonmember avatar J

Really AI Nicki Minaj and Mariah Carey.....dont get me wrong I love love love Nicki Minaj and Mariah Carey but as AI judge I dont know it seem a little too much but I guess we shall see.

nonmember avatar Rebob

I would rather have a tooth pulled than have to listen to another word from Minaj (or whatever her frickin name is). OBNOXIOUS!

1-10 of 11 comments 12 Last