Follow The Stir

TV Addict

Who Does Emily Maynard Pick? Latest Rumor Is Nothing Short of Heartbreaking

by Mary Fischer on July 17, 2012 at 10:56 AM

Emily Maynard

OMG. How are we supposed to wait until Sunday to see who Emily Maynard will pick on The Bachelorette finale? After seeing the previews of her final romantic dates with Jef Holm & Arie Luyendyk on The Bachelorette Men Tell All show last night, it looks like this finale truly is shaping up to be "the most dramatic rose ceremony ever." (For real!)

Emily really does seem to be falling in love with both Arie and Jef equally, which makes this season one of the toughest races to call in the history of the show. But a new rumor about what actually happens with Emily's final pick is nothing short of shocking -- and I honestly just don't know what to make of it. In fact, I'm already a bit heartbroken for her if this rumor is actually true.

*Warning: MAJOR Spoilers Ahead*

According to "an inside source," one of the remaining two men has a change of heart and actually breaks things off with Emily during their final date -- leaving her completely devastated and confused. Supposedly this particular guy gets "a bad case of cold feet" and says:

"I don’t think we know each other nearly enough to even be entertaining this; I don’t think we should get engaged." (Whaaaattt?)

More from The Stir: LIVE 'Bachelorette: After the Final Rose' Special Opens Door for Huge Shocker

Wait -- it gets worse. Supposedly after this dude cuts her loose, she begs him to change his mind and even tells him, "You're the one I want to pick!"

Talk about the worst heartbreak any Bachelorette has ever had to deal with! If this is true, then I seriously want to wring this guy's neck for leading her on all season while he never had any true intentions of actually proposing to her. (Who does that?)

This same source also indicates that Emily does wind up getting her happy ending after getting engaged to her other finalist, and apparently they are in love and planning to tie the knot this fall.

But for Emily's sake (and her rumored fiance), I hope this is nothing but another crazy story that was put out there to confuse fans about the final outcome of the show. Because if Emily's heart truly did lie with the man who allegedly left her, there will always be a huge "what if?" in the back of her mind -- and that's a very, very hard thing to escape.

Emily has such a good head on her shoulders and her judgement thus far has been absolutely perfect, so let's hope there is no truth to this story -- and that we will see her get her happy ending on Sunday. (But if this certain guy does wind up breaking her heart -- he'd better be ready to go from being a fan favorite to the ultimate Bachelorette villain overnight.)

Do you think this rumor is true?

 

Image via ABC

Filed Under: reality tv, the bachelorette

Comments

13
  • Cindy...
    -- Facebook comment from

    Cindy Hripak

    July 17, 2012 at 11:22 AM

    I do believe this rumor and It is most likely Jef. and then shawn wins her back!


  • Lisa...
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Lisa Richman

    July 17, 2012 at 2:06 PM
    I don't think her judgement has been perfect at all actually. For one thing SEAN was the best catch and she let the good one get away. I think she picks neither!
  • sue
    -- Nonmember comment from

    sue

    July 17, 2012 at 3:43 PM
    If she does end up with her 2nd choice, I kind of feel bad for the guy who is the 2nd choice. It would suck knowing that you weren't the first choice. But it is kind of nice that this season has a girl who isn't really stupid and falls for the worst person possible who appears to be a totally different person when they are not with the bachelorette/bachelor like some of the other past bachelorettes and bachelors.
  • shell...
    --

    shellyplatz

    July 17, 2012 at 5:57 PM

    She shoulda kept Sean!! I can't see her with Jef forever and her and Arie are all hormones! I was hoping Sean would still win in the end lol! My 2 picks if it were me woulda been Charlie and Doug. Sean woulda ranked up ther too


  • needa...
    --

    needadvice1983

    July 17, 2012 at 7:03 PM
    It's so funny but I did t like Sean! I felt like he was just "too perfect" to be genuine. I like Arie, but they seem to not click in other ways then sexual (constantly all over each other). And with Jef I think she would just get another kid, because he seems to still be growing up. Which is fine when it's just you, but when you have a child you need a man, not a teenager. But in the end we only see a small slice of what actually happened so all three of the guys (and her relationship with them) could be totally different then what we see. I hope she is happy because she does seem like a sweet girl.
  • Fred...
    -- Facebook comment from

    Fred Achierno

    July 17, 2012 at 8:46 PM
    I do think that Emily won't pick either Arie or Jef. I think it will be Arie who will tell her he has a change of heart. I just haven't liked him because he does seem like it's all about sex with him. If it is Arie who does that, she won't pick her second choice in Jef. I truly hope that if this is all to happen that her and Sean got together after the final episode and have developed their relationship so strong that the surprise will come to light during "After The Final Rose". I think Emily and Sean could have put on a great show during The Men Tell All last evening to not let it appear that they are together now. Maybe I am hoping and dreaming but I pray that this is how The Bachelorette ends for 2012!!
  • Kathleen
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Kathleen

    July 17, 2012 at 10:31 PM
    I don't see how anyone can truly fall in love with get to know someone well enough to consider marrying. The track record of these shows should tell the contestants how things will work out. I have trouble getting involved or feeling bad for people who seem so desperate for fame that they will do these shows. Last week Emily talked about going backwoods hood rat over a slam against her daughter. It seems to me that she could have shown her love for her daughter by not putting her through this circus.
  • mumma...
    --

    mummajenni

    July 18, 2012 at 12:00 AM
    I see one-F backing out. And honestly, smart move. It would be so foolish to get engaged after this "journey"...
  • Pat...
    -- Facebook comment from

    Pat McDermott

    July 18, 2012 at 10:07 AM
    Who would lead her on all season and then say no? Really? Uh, isn't that what she has done all season? It is part of the game and better for someone to say no now, then later.
  • 4real...
    --

    4realyall

    July 18, 2012 at 12:31 PM

    I was truly hoping she would pick Sean but since she left him go and now there are two left Arie and Jef I think she has gone with her second choice Jef. I too think Arie would be the one that says it's to soon and they don't know each other well enough. But just as I said she made the mistake early on letting Sean go!


1-10 of 13 comments

To leave a comment, log in as a CafeMom member:

Log In

OR, use our non-member comment form: