I have to confess something Twilight fans might not like: I've never been able to get into the series, and it's mostly because of Bella. I just found her kind of mopey. All that mooning over her vampire boyfriend, and then her werewolf sort-of boyfriend. And what's with Edward trying to control her -- even though he can't? She came across as a pretty wimpy female to me, but her creator, Stephenie Meyer, says she's all about girl power. It's the humans against the supernatural creatures! I guess I can see that.
But then The Hunger Games came along and just blew Bella's girl power out of the water. Here's a real feminist heroine: Katniss, a warrior fighting for her survival! No time for moping over boys, she has a family to support. But the more I think about it, Katniss actually has more in common with the supernatural women of Twilight. Maybe the Twilight chicks should get some credit for being pro-girl power after all.
After all, the women in the Cullen coven are pretty tough. Alice may be small, but she's a fighter. Rosalie is a rape victim who got revenge against her rapists as a vampire. Don't mess with her! Then there's Victoria -- Bella's enemy, sure, but a formidable woman. And eventually Leah manages to crack the, er, wolf pack glass ceiling to become a female werewolf. There's plenty of kick-ass women in Twilight, if you think about it. And even Bella hangs in there and does her best as a human, using her wits instead of her strength.
I haven't read The Hunger Games -- or seen the movie yet. But I think I'd better, soon. I already love what I've heard about Katniss. When the story begins, she's supporting her family. When her younger sister is chosen as a tribute, she takes her place. She learns to fight and compete alongside the boys -- and she's amazing.
Still, I'm glad The Hunger Games is arriving at the tail end of Twilight-fever. It's not even really a Bella vs. Katniss thing -- but I kind of feel like Katniss takes the feminist hero up another level for fans. It's like Katniss was invented for fans who love Bella but wish she could have fought more against the vampires!
Which do you like better so far, Bella or Katniss?
Images via Breaking Dawn and Hunger Games
Ashley Is a Widow Who Stays Strong...
This Hot Dad Wants to Vacuum Your Rug
This Hot Dad Wants to Do Your Ironing
KStew Refuses to Shower
Comments 23
You know, you make a pretty good point. So much hullabaloo has been made over how Bella was a weak character, that very little attention was played to the other female characters.
In terms of physical strength, endurance, and pure ability to survive, I think Katniss wins of human-Bella. Despite her mother, Bella is very sheltered, whereas Katniss is not. Katniss is fully aware of "the real world"; she doesn't have a choice.
Think maybe you had to hang in there with Bella. She didn't know her strengths and was too "Edward is too good for me" in Twilight and New Moon. Then she figured some stuff out and stretched her feminist legs in Eclipse a little. But by the end, Bella is one bad ass Mother. Telling everyone how it's going to be.
Katniss kinda just went through everything as a pawn for one.thing or another.
She was physically tough, but emotionally.weak.
Katniss, no question.
But when you look at it, Katniss grew up dealing with various emotional stresses that may or may not have stunted her emotional growth. And I give Katniss a lot of props for volunteering as a tribute in place of her sister.
Bella, hands down. Human Bella "confounded" the Volturi and deflected all their powers saving Edward's "life" for the first time the second time in Eclipse. The third time will be in Breaking Dawn Pt. 2. She actually saves her entire family and the visiting covens during the last showdown with the Volturi as Vampire Bella.
100% Katniss.
There is no comparison between the two. I love both series, But of course Katniss will be stronger. She was fighting for survival in much darker times than Bella. But I take so much offense when people compare series that are so different! Twilight is a love story. It's focused so much on Bella and Edwards love. The Hunger Games is focused on Katniss surviving. It's apples and oranges.