At virtually every kind of retail establishment imaginable, this manages to be my oldest son's monologue, "Mommy, can we buy that? Well, can we buy this? This? How cooome?."
Depending on my mood, how rushed I am, etc., I generally follow up his 'can we buy' questions with solid explanations of why not. "You have one just like that." "That's not healthy." "That's for grownups." "We already have a television, hon, mommy's looking for batteries." "A mousetrap is not a toy, Lorenzo. No." Only once do I recall saying "Mommy can't afford..." and it was in frustration about whatever I was dealing with at the moment--but the 'can we buy' questions just took me there. No sooner than the words slipped out, some kind of guilt followed them. The truth of the matter is, there are many times that mommy can't afford. In this economy, our family finances have been a constant source of concern for both my husband and I, yet we work so hard to conceal this from the kids. Why?
Finances
are not an easy subject for most families to tackle, especially when it comes to
older school-aged kids. We live in a consumer culture
that kids as young as age two are sucked into; an MTV "My Super-Sweet
16" world that has teens wearing $150 sneakers and carrying $300
iPhones--or feeling bad when they can't. An interesting blog about family finance and kids in the NY Times today helped me feel better about myself when it cited a Charles Schwab
survey that reported that of the nearly 4,000 respondents, most
said they'd only give themselves a C- when it comes to teaching their
kids to manage money wisely.
The major takeaway from the article though, are the simple yet wise tips about the things we can all do at every stage of 'financial parenting' offered by the founder and CEO of the National Youth Financial Advisors Council. And I quote...
Start a Savings Plan. Get your child, teen or young
adult in a habit of saving money. As long as you pay for their food and
housing bills, have them set aside 40 percent of all income they
receive, including gifts and earned allowance, into a savings account.
Build a Solid Financial Foundation. Make sure your children have their checking, savings, retirement account and brokerage accounts open as soon as possible (even if they do not have money to put into their brokerage or retirement accounts right now). This gives them a feeling of responsibility and status and starts them thinking about the value of money that is allowed more time to grow.
Teach About Compounding Interest. The younger you are the more you can harness the power of compounding interest. So the younger you truly understand what this can do for you the better. Play around with online calculators to show them how this works - not so much the theory but the “how to.”
Raise Free Thinkers. In today’s age, from the moment newborns are exposed to the real world, they are heavily influenced with advertiser’s messages to “buy, buy, buy.” Teach them to evaluate advertising by asking, “what are they trying to convince me of,” “whom are they targeting” and “what is this goal of this ad.”
On the day I told my 5-year-old that I couldn't afford what he (thought) he wanted, I cleaned it all up with something more. "Look, babe, that costs money. In order to get money you have to work really hard (although lots of us work really hard and are essentially poor, but he can discover that later). It's not enough to just want something really badly, you have to plan and save for it. So keep filling up your piggy bank." It was the best I could do in the moment.
Moms of big kids, do tell, how do you handle challenging money talks with your 'can we buy' children?


This Hot Dad Wants to Do Your Ironing
This Hot Dad Wants to Cook You Dinner
This Hot Dad Cooks AND Does the Dishes
Kanye West is Gay?!
















Comments 9
yes,i think so.
I have always been honest with my children. If I couldn't afford it, they knew it. I was a single mom in the military and at times we couldn't afford the luxuries of high priced items. My kids had nice clean clothes, good food, and roof over their head and they were thankful for that. Now 25 yrs later, they live on their own and budget their own money.
I have been honest with my 3 1/2-year-old about money. He says, "I want that, Mom!" I tell him, "We don't have the money for that, Baby." He says okay. But one day he said, "Lets go to the money store & buy some money so we can go get that, Mom!" That's when I knew I failed him. That was the first day he cleaned up all his toys for a dollar. I told him we have to earn money, that's why Mommy & Daddy have to go to work every day. I hope he's catching on.
We've always been frugal shoppers as a family. When I take the kids shopping at Goodwill, I tell them they can pick out five pairs of shorts there, or they can get just one pair at Target. They understand that sort of logic.
If they find some sort of big toy that they really want, but I think costs too much, I try to explain to them how much it costs in terms that they can comprehend. For instance, a $50 toy would cost as much as TEN My Little Ponies. Or as much as SEVEN Star Wars figures. When I make the kids stop and think how many other toys they might have to forego in order to get that one expensive toy, they almost always say that they don't REALLY want that big toy that much.
The money thing is hard, and we definitely don't want to raise greedy and materialistic kids... I think as parents we just have to stay on it and keep leading by example.
My kids rarely ask for stuff in stores and if they do they don't whine when they are told no. They know we don't have a lot of money. Heck, they see it every day when I have to tell them they can't have a sandwich because we have no bread left or they can't have cereal for breakfast because there is no milk left. It happens at least once a week.
My kids have a lot more needs that we can't pay for then wants...like gym pants that they are required to wear to school in the winter on gym days (2 of the 3 have them...the other is stuck wearing shorts on those days) and boots and winter coats. We can't afford any of it right now and we let them know that. We don't hide that we are poor. It's just a fact of life
Hopefully things will get better next month (we're having a money crunch right now) or at least after the holidays. We're doing okay now. There was a time we couldn't even afford food and heat. We froze all winter and my kids ate Saltines for dinner one night because it was all we had.
I'm usually pretty honest about things like that, I will just say "I don't know if we can afford it" or just simply "We'll have to see". Feel like I've been saying that a lot lately. lol
ya my daughter just told me i wish i was an adult ya wright know mommy and daddy pay bills give you everything i told her i wish i was you but she nose we are struggling financially and she wants to help buy getting a job i told her the money is yours but she has a cell phone that i pay for but once she works that's her bill we got to teach our kids that its hard on adults to get them Wat they need so ya we should teach them to save for college that doesn't come cheap
Well i think ,most of the kids had no idea about this and even i dont want them let know the situation i fell really improper to put some unessesary burden on there innocent brains and let them enjoy there own way,ofcourse its not very easy to do like easy to say but i am just going threw and article in <a href="http://www.dozenvideo.com/Video-News-TOP/cbs-news.html">cbsnewstv.com</a> in which most of the kids went to the trauma when they heard the situation from there parents,so i never want it to happen atleast with my kids.
I just recently found out about a child savings plan that is affordable for most anyone. The interest compounds and the money can be withdrawn for college, to purchase their first home, to pay for a wedding, start a business or they can continue to save for their retirement. There's a $50,000 life insurance policy to boot! The policy is transferable, non-cancelable and the premium stays the same. It is the best savings plan that I have seen! I sure wish my parents would have known about this when I was a child and given me a head start in my financial future.