A Dad Finds Out Why Men Shouldn't Go Bra Shopping for Their Daughters

bra shoppingWith the exception of career drag queens, men have no business in bra departments. Sometimes, though, we're required to venture into these forbidden zones, no matter how suicidal the mission. Due to my repeated failure, even when armed with a detailed text listing the exact size my 12-year-old daughter has instructed me to purchase, I seem incapable of returning home with a bra that "feels right." Which is why I privately refer to this sad vortex of breast retaining walls as The Island of Misfit Cups.

The open hostility with which I'm routinely greeted doesn't help. I thought we'd evolved as a culture, but the raw disdain my very presence seems to elicit in female bra shoppers has taught me otherwise.

Whenever I set foot in a bra department -- be it Nordstrom, Target, or KMart -- the same thing happens. The place empties faster than you can say Bra-Cha-Cha. (That's actually the name of a real bra, by the way, manufactured by a real company called -- get this -- "Spanx.")

You'd think I was Kevin Spacey at his skeeviest, lobbing rotten flounder heads into the strapless aisle.

These women don't seem to care that I can see them openly whispering about me from across the way, waiting for me to be done with my dirty business. But I'm there for my child, so I put up with the shunning.

Custom flex-fit, criss-cross, halter, strapless, underwire, quarter-cup, adhesive peel 'n' stick. I'm the first to admit these are terms no man should ever have to know. Most never will, because as far as bras go, most guys -- after figuring out how to get a woman out of one -- feel they've completed their formal education.

But my daughter's parents happen to be family men of the homosexual variety. Which in our case means at least one of us can be always relied on to find a relevant connection between any given topic and the American musical theatre.

More From The Stir: Good Dads Don't Need Sons

Like now. In the Broadway show Woman of the Year, Lauren Bacall famously sang that she was "one of the girls who's one of the boys." Since our children were born, due to the particular division of labor in our marriage (Kelly goes to the office, I shop for bras), I've had to become one of the dads who's one of the moms.

It was cute when the kids were babies. I'd often run into moms while out with the children to shop for things like diapers. The response of seeing a dad out trying to find just the right wipes for his baby's bottom was always the same. "Awwwwwuh." I figured they all knew I was one of them until one grandmotherly type winked as she said, "I see it's Mom's day off."

I quickly set her straight. "At our house, every day is mom's day off."

As you might imagine, this has meant, for two men raising a daughter, much Googling. Usually with a satisfactory result. I've learned to make mermaid costumes, bake birthday cakes from scratch, even how to navigate that ninth circle of hell, the American Girl Doll Store.

Still, when given the choice of picking out her first bra with her dads or one of the 19 kind women who'd lined up to volunteer for the task since her birth, Elizabeth chose ... not us.

"Are you nuts? What could you and Papa possibly know about shopping for a bra? I'm calling Miss Andrea."

Elizabeth and Andrea, the egg-donor who graciously provided the yolks for both our lovely children, had a wonderful, special, estrogen-bonding, female time that day, topped off I'm told by blue-raspberry Icees.

Which was nice for that first time, but that was a special occasion. As everyone knows, egg donors can't just clear their schedules at the drop of a hat every time your mutual issue needs underwear.

I was determined to Google myself into becoming what my daughter deserved: an educated, full-service, on-site cups and straps expert. But what I began to learn gave me pause. It turns out that terms like "push-up" and "deep plunge" are just the nipple on the iceberg. I soon found myself adrift in an alphabet soup of bizarre word combinations no male could have ever dreamed up: Smoothing Secrets Full Figure, Glamour Keyhold Balconette, Dream Angels Lace Racerback, and of course those twin Spanx creations, the Bra-lellujah and the Bra-Cha-Cha.

The Bra-Cha-Cha I tripped over while researching strapless bras.

Most women who've heard this story have immediately responded with, "Why on earth would you be looking for a strapless bra for a 12-year-old?"

Here's why. Elizabeth has always leaned toward what they call "casual sporty" attire. Which means that for years now, in warm weather, she prefers to wear tank tops and, more recently, those camisole things with the really thin straps.

This was fine when she was was 10. It's an athletic look that suits her. But things have kind of exploded recently in what her grandmother likes to call the "Up There Area." What to do? We could let the straps show -- a look every woman in my mother's bridge club would tell you is universal code for "cheap, tacky skank." I could staple the camisole straps to the top of the bra straps, but Elizabeth pointed out that this would constitute child abuse. Or we could invest in a suitable strapless bra.

A quick trip to the Island of Misfit Cups proved unsatisfactory. They didn't have anything strapless that didn't also promise to push things up. I'm not ready for a preteen with things pushed up.

I returned to my computer. Google "best strapless bra" and you'll quickly be led to the Bra-Cha-Cha. The Bra-Cha-Cha costs $68. I wouldn't pay that for a brassiere spun from gold.

So you can imagine my joy one day when, at Costco, I spotted a two-pack of strapless bras for $17.99! As if that weren't enough, a lady nearby was reading the packaging and chirping to a friend, "Este sujetador es tan versátil!" I quickly followed her lead and flipped the box over. It was true; photos on the back showed a "convertible" bra that was indeed amazingly versatile. Not only could it be worn strapless, there were actually optional straps included that could be configured into all kinds of styles I knew Elizabeth would love -- something called standard, halter style, even that zig-zaggy racerback thing.

More From The Stir: The Bra Celebrates 100 Years: 14 Most Memorable Moments (PHOTOS)

I praised the gods of Costco. I could purchase not one but two versátil strapless bras at a bargain price, without ever having to set foot in another retail mammary support center. I checked my iPhone Notes for Elizabeth's current size, snapped up the corresponding two-pack, threw it in my cart, and moved on to the tire department.

As I usually do when I buy clothes for Elizabeth, I left the package on her bed. Given her newfound modesty, she never mentioned my purchase, but the genius of it was self-evident. I felt certain she'd soon be nominating me for Bra-Daddy of the Year.

Cut to three weeks later. When I spotted in Elizabeth's clothes hamper what can only be called the most hoochie-mama stripper bra I've ever seen. Shiny satin ribbing running vertically up each pitch-black cup, like fingers. Sheer black lace all around the sides. There were bows.

"What is this?" I asked, fishing an undergarment Katy Perry would reject as too racy.

"A bra," she said.

"I can see that. I want to know where you got it."

"You bought it for me."

"I never bought you ... that."

I had to drop the thing back in the hamper. The satin stripes were leering at me.

"Yes you did. You left it on my bed. There were two of them, in a pack. The other one's nude."

I was sputtering now. "I did not buy that. There's black lace around the sides. There are stripes running up the ..."

"The cups. I know. I thought it was kind of grown-up, but you were so set on getting me a bra where my straps wouldn't show, I figured this was all you could find."

In my defense -- not that I have one -- the lace, the stripes, the bows, none of it was clearly visible from the packaging. Of course it is, if you look closely. Which I hadn't; I'd been too busy exalting in my bra bargain to realize I'd bought my daughter an undergarment fit for a pole dancer.

"It doesn't matter, it's strapless." Elizabeth went on. "Who's going to see it? Oh, except this girl at camp. She saw it on my bed last week and asked what I was doing with a bra from Victoria's Secret."

"What did you tell her?" I asked, my gut constricting.

"The truth. I said, 'My daddy bought it for me!'"

Once I was done figuring out what's appropriate attire when Child Protective Services shows up at your door, I finally had to face what every woman who's volunteered to bra shop with Elizabeth has been too polite ever to say: until the day we're able to grow a pair, men are doomed to remain tit-ignorant.

From that point on, I decided that, when Miss Andrea's not free, I'll be taking one of those 18 kind mom-wannabees up on their offers. From here on out, I'm leaving it to the professionals.

As for that Costco red-light special? I considered donating those hoochie-mamas to Christina Aguilera but ended up cremating them instead.

Who takes YOUR daughter bra shopping?


About the Author: William Lucas Walker is an Emmy Award-winning writer/producer whose television credits include Frasier, Will & Grace, and Roseanne. He was also a creator of the critically acclaimed Showtime comedy series The Chris Isaak Show. Bill and his husband Kelly are the parents of Elizabeth and James, born in 2001 and 2005 through surrogacy, and he writes monthly about fatherhood in Huffington Post's "Spilled Milk Column."


Image via Tracy Hunter/Flickr

puberty, tough topics

22 Comments

To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

nonmember avatar Hokis

Oh what memories this brought back, Mr. Walker. I was raised by my father from age 2 onward, and he is the bravest man I've ever known. He took me to get my first bra, and even at my young age I noticed the odd looks we received in the young women's lingerie department of the store. I commend you for your research into bras and the different fits and keeping up with your daughter's size; my poor papa had no clue but we somehow made it out of that store alive and with two pathetic scrunchy-looking bras, one donning a pink rose in the middle of the cups which looked like something that belonged on a small stuffed bear or baby outfit. Those were the days! ;)

You sound like a great father. It's so nice to know there's some still out there!!! Cheers.

nonmember avatar Natalie

Hilarious. So glad you have some women around to fall back on to help out in times like such. Glad Elizabeth has such supportive parents, and they have a great network. Fantastic story.

linzemae linzemae

This was absolutely hilarious. It also made me tear up because you seem to have such a great relationship with your kids and the egg donor! "Just the nipple of the iceberg" I died

Kaide... KaidensMama1107

Bravo! You sound like a great parent! Good luck when a thong creeps up in the washbin lol ;)

kisse... kisses5050

my poor husband... was sent from the hotel to get a black size 32 b black bra, white sunglasses , nude hose and 2inch silver hoops for my daughter who was competing in a pageant... he came back with with "You are the best pageant dad ever!!" written on the bag in sharpie

sooo to play it safe he stayed home with our other daughter the next year... She started her period for the first time...he called me and told me he went bought her "the stuff" but seeing as she was going to sea camp he thought she might want to try tampons so he used a coke bottel and showed her how to use them. Bless his heart.... When I talked to her on the phone she said "dont worry dad took care of everything"

Hang in there! Dads can do it all!

PRIMA487 PRIMA487

Oh kisses5050!! Too effin funny!

berit berit

1. Omg you were part of fraiser?!?!? Only my favorite show EVER!

2. Never judge a man in a bra aisle of a mall or other wide variety store. The kinky dudes get their's from stores like Fedrick's(it's a fact, ask them) any dude in a regular mall setting has a reason for being there. I've seen it a handful of times and offered a helping hand (in a non creepy, didn't like let him hold it up to me for size or anything kind of way) the last time after one of the employees all but ran from him. Turns out he was a single dad and his daughter wasn't comfortable trying on in a store and wanted different things brought home so she could see what worked without a sales lady or having to explain why her dad was around.

Saras... Sarasahmof3

Now I know how hubby feels. I shall never torture him again.


LOL


rolling on floor

nonmember avatar Heather

I am dead. I hope The Stir keeps you on all the time! I'm certainly going to start reading you on the Huff.

the4m... the4mutts

My husband IS incapable of bra shopping, but I am raising my sons not to be. My 10yr old recently helped pick out bras and panties for me, after I told him the size, shape, and level of padding (none) that I wanted for bras, and the size and butt coverage I wanted for panties. I don't want to raise a boy that is too embarrassed to buy tampons for his future wife, or too inept to buy bras for his future daughter.

I am HOPING my husband will learn right along my sons. He could use the pointers, since we have daughters as well.



While your blog is cute, and well written, it makes me sad to know that before your daughter needed bras, you both didn't make it a point to learn more about them, or take her with you every time, and get to know the needs of your daughter's body. Im not saying that you're bad parents, you're obviously not. I simply don't like the perpetuation of the "men are helpless with these things" stereotype.

1-10 of 22 comments 123 Last
F