Taking My Kid Out of School for a Family Vacation Shouldn't Be 'Illegal'

Rant 30

empty school desksI knew the form was coming, but that didn't make it any easier when it arrived. Illegal Absence. I never knew a piece of paper could mom shame, but it did.

Technically, it's telling the truth. I am taking my kid out of school for what the state has deemed an "illegal absence." That I talked to her teacher on meet the teacher night and emailed her about our upcoming trip doesn't matter. Nor does the fact that said teacher is putting together a packet of homework to do on the trip.

It's still "illegal."

I don't do anything illegal.

OK. I speed. Sometimes. Not with the kid in the car!

But that's pretty much the extend of my bad-assery, folks. I'm a straight arrow who was voted class angel in high school (yes, really). 

So the word "illegal" bugs me. Big time.

Not just because I feel ashamed, although I do. Wait, actually, let me correct that. It IS because I feel ashamed.

I hate my kid's school and the state education department for making me feel ashamed of spending time with my daughter.

People! We're taking her out of school for five days for a family vacation, on which she'll see other parts of the country, eat different foods, and do a load of reading (yes, we're driving). We're not making her walk over hot coals while eating fried worms dipped in Tabasco.

Why is this "illegal"?

Because it's during the school year, and kids belong in school every day of the school year? Sorry, but even as a staunch supporter of public education, I disagree. I think there's something to be said for education outside of the classroom, and certainly something to be said for the value of family time.

These days, there isn't enough of the latter. About 60 percent of two-parent households with children under age 18 have two working parents, and 56 percent of mothers and 50 percent of fathers say juggling work and family life is difficult for them.

Family vacations offer valuable time for parents and kids to reconnect. Why not do that when school is out of session, you might ask? Did I mention all those two-parent-working families? Do you know how many of us are vying with one another for time off during the same exact school breaks? Statistically, it's impossible for all of us to do it, and this year, the only time my husband and I could both get off for a stretch of time was, you guessed it, during the school year.

I know we're not alone. I put out a Facebook query to friends to ask if anyone else had done a school-time vacation, asking how to broach it with our district, and I had a deluge of advice-givers.

These are all good parents, parents who value their kids' education. They're all parents who, like me, sought out their children's teachers and got their kids' assignments ahead of time so their kiddos wouldn't fall behind. Several chose -- as I did -- to make their vacation plans in the fall when classwork still tends to be focused on a review of the year before rather than a true representation of this year's curriculum.

The term "illegal absence" is unfair to parents like them, to parents like me, parents who are doing what we feel is best for our kids. It lumps us in with the truly bad parents -- you know the type, the ones who just can't be bothered to put down the crack pipe and get their kids out of bed in the morning to get on the bus.

It shames us for something that should be celebrated: giving kids a varied education that includes trips outside their hometown, for wanting to devote our time and energies to being WITH our kids.

Does your kids' school label vacations illegal? Do you do it anyway?


Image via DCJohn/Flickr

back to school, education, elementary school


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Katha... Katharine205

You know if you were homeschooling it wouldn't be an issue

nonmember avatar Anowscara

Our school actually does have a legal issue they enforce. If you miss more than five days of school in a single semester, you can be forced into some pretty serious consequences. They keep changing, so I'm not exactly sure what they are, but they have included forced grade repetition, and/or fines and charges against the parents. It's supposed to be reducing truancy, but it means parents can't utilize outside opportunities. Not all education happens in a classroom.

miche... micheledo

My parents took us out of school for a trip!  Well-worth it and I don't think my education was harmed.  :)  Be confident in your decision, have a blast, and just forget about it.

jrphelps jrphelps

When I was a kid, if we didn't take our family vacations in the summer, we didn't take them.  It's funny how poeple think the rules shouldn't apply to them.  Yes it should be illegal to take your kid out of school for a family vacation for an entire week!  The only time I missed school to go somewhere was when I was visiting my dad half way across the country.  BUT he always planned my visits around holidays so I only missed a day or 2 tops for travel time through the airports.

kelsusie kelsusie

Kids get enough time through the school year to take vacations if you want and there is also summer vacation. If you have a problem with the school's policies on abscense why don't you home school and there won't be an issue.

adamat34 adamat34

Im tired of schools interfering in parenting. There are bigger issues than a vacation. Ive taken my kids out to do things fun on a whim. As.long as its not consistent, who cares? Id love to see the school try and tell me what I can , where and where I cant.take my children!!

Kate Cooley

Our school system is like that, too. Be glad your teacher made up a packet. Ours WON'T do that at all. It's up to YOU and your kid to make up the work afterwards. Never mind that they're then overloaded with work and falling behind and the work COULD have been done on the long (in our case) train ride.

nonmember avatar blh

@Katharine don't be a douchebag. Just stop talking. You can't home school if you work full time. Plus I would say MANY parents wouldn't do a good job at teaching kids themselves plus a lot of children would prefer to be in school. And as for illegal well that's ridiculous. As long as she dies the work who cares? My parents did this. Schools ate getting way too invasive in my opinion.

miche... micheledo

jrphelps made me laugh out loud!!!! :D

Looks like the 'rules' didn't apply to you either since your dad couldn't manage to arrange your flight travel a day or two earlier and you still missed a couple days of school.  :D

Your own example shows that it shouldn't be such a big deal to miss some school.  Illegal - seems ridiculous.  

These 'no tolerance' policies allow no room for special cases, common sense, etc.  I missed months of my first period chemistry class when my brother was in a serious accident.  I was often at the hospital late at night and the school gave me permission to come to school at any time of the day.  I finished the class with an A+.  I still have the letter my teacher wrote for a scholarship application - about my hard work and dedication to keep my grades up in spite of missing so much school.  Nowadays, I probably would end up with a mandatory lower grade or an incomplete no matter how hard I worked.

1-10 of 30 comments 123 Last