Mom of Twins Confesses She Loves The 'Perfect' One More Than the Disfigured One

Rant 102

loveI don't know where to begin with this story, so I'm just going to dive in. Seven years ago, a mom gave birth to a set of twin boys. One was perfectly healthy. The other was born with a rare disfigurement that has essentially given him only half a face. And now Henry and Oliver Machin's mom is sharing their photo with the world so she can talk about something pretty dark and disturbing.

For years, Charlene Machin said she did not love one of her sons. In fact, when she talks about her child, her little boy born with a left eye, ear, and nostril that never developed, she uses words like "waves of terror" and "grief."

Powerful? Absolutely. Machin's confession is an important one for parents of kids with special needs who feel like something is wrong with them as they struggle to balance that dream of a perfect child with their reality.

But I can't help thinking of the awful cost for that confession. Machin's two sons' names and photographs are now being paired with articles across the web about this subject. I myself debated long and hard before deciding to include their names, reasoning, sadly, that the worst harm had already been done.

Charlotte Machin already told the world that at one point, she could not bring herself to love her son. She has already laid that burden on both of her sons' shoulders. One has to deal with the reality of being "unloved" at one point, the other with the sibling rivalry inherent in families with a favored child.

My heart breaks for those poor kids.

I need to make an important distinction here: I am not criticizing her natural feelings. This struggle is more common than parents like to admit and it's not just with parents of special needs kids. Moms dealing with post partum depression, moms who give birth to a child of a gender other than the one they thought they wanted ... the list goes on.

Typically when a mother comes out with one of these types of confessions, it serves as a touchstone for those who are struggling. There's a need for moms (and dads) to talk about this truth.

But there's a right way to do it and a wrong way.

Would it have been less impactful if Charlene Machin had remained anonymous? If she'd opted not to share personal photos? If she'd written a pseudonymous blog post, perhaps? Or done one of those TV interviews where the subject's face is blurred, the voice altered?

Maybe it wouldn't have hit home in quite the way it has, but I'd have taken that risk for the greater gain: to allow a child to grow up without the knowledge that his mother felt "waves of terror" when she looked at him, to give a child a sense that he has always had the unconditional love of the person who is supposed to love him first and foremost in this world.

Would you be willing to let your child know you didn't love them at one point in their life? What do you think of this mom's confession?


Image by Jeanne Sager

special needs, multiples


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

NatAndCo NatAndCo

It's only 7:30 in the morning and I'm already disgusted. Not so much because of how she feels, though i don't understand it, but the fact that she would put it out there. Tell it to a therapist, not the world and ultimately the poor little boys.

Caera Caera

I think every kid grows up and becomes an adult and realizes they were completely unloveable at some point during their lives. Sometimes it's their own fault because they turn into idiot, rude, obnoxious teenagers who cause their parents immense amounts of grief. Sometimes it's through no fault of their own, and their parent was the one who had some growing up to do.

Personally, as a grown-up child, I'd find the first one more disturbing. If I had caused my parents undo grief, I'd feel awful, and guilty, and like a wretch, especially if my parent had passed. I don't know I'd feel the same way if it was my parent's fault, as in this case.

nonmember avatar N

It's our job to protect our children even from ourselves. She has every right to feel whatever she'd like, but to publicly air something that will hurt her son is incredibly sad. He deserved to be protected from her feelings.

Truel... Truelove77

They are both beautiful If I were her I would have remained anon if she felt so strongly about not loving her son why didnt she give him to someone would look into his heart and not care what he looked like and loved him like he should be loved. Wow sad that this mother felt this way about such a precious child...

miche... micheledo

Wow.  I so appreciate moms who are honest about their struggles.  But usually these stories end with how they overcame those feelings (for the most part) and realized how very special and loved the child is.

Honestly, this makes me sick.  I can sympathize with the struggle, but to not overcome that??  How do you NOT love your child in the end?

miche... micheledo

Oops.  OK.  I just read the article that is linked to this blog.  The mom struggled for two years!  She has overcome it.   That is different.

And her boys are absolutely adorable!!!!

notab... notabosley

I don't know if I could put myself in her position to sympathize. I can't imagine ever loving my child any less. I can't criticize her though, I've never been in her place before.

nonmember avatar Anon

This kid is going to have enough struggles with people throughout his life and now there's an internet article forever burned into public opinion that it took his own mother two years to love him because he was too ugly for her. Wow, what a bitch. He was a poor helpless baby, no special needs. There's no struggle, he's just different looking. She should've kept her jerk mouth shut about this.

1-10 of 102 comments 12345 Last