School Ban on Cartwheels & Handstands Takes Fun Out of Recess

Rant 13

cartwheelBumps and bruises. Cuts and scrapes. I've always thought they were like a road map of childhood, up and down our kids' legs and across their arms. But then I hear about schools like the one that's banned kids from doing any sort of somersault, handstand, or cartwheel during recess.

They're trying to keep kids from getting hurt. But who says "getting hurt" is the worst thing that is going to happen to our kids?

I remember a time when kids played at recess, I mean really played. We ran our little legs off during glorious games of chase. We slid down hot slides and hung high in the air on the monkey bars. I grew up in a poor rural school district where there wasn't enough money to put into playgrounds for every grade, and so I remember more years than not being forced to play on hard blacktop.

And despite a few sad memories of bullies and buttheads, the memories of childhood play are mostly good.

If you look long and hard at my legs, you'll notice the scars. There is where I tripped while getting off the school bus in kindergarten. That's where I ran into the bumper of a car in the school parking lot during recess. Mrs. B. had to use butterfly bandages to close it up. And that one? Well I'm not exactly sure, but I'll bet it was fun.

I'm sure I cried about the boo boos. I don't have the highest pain tolerance. And yet, they are part of who I am today. They're markers of my childhood. And they were lessons learned. I always looked ahead of me when getting off the bus after that tumble. I never ran near parked cars again. And when I do get a "boo boo," I avoid that dreaded pour of peroxide like the plague.

I still hate pain, but I don't flail and gnash my teeth. I've seen what's on the other side, and I wait.

That is the lesson of bumps and bruises, cuts and scrapes. You'll live, kid, you'll live.

Only our kids aren't allowed to get bumped or cut anymore. They're not learning what's on the other side.

I'm not sure when we stopped being able to differentiate between "extreme danger" and "slight risk" for our kids, but it's as though the two have been lumped in together. What might, possibly, in some situations, cause a child to break a nail is now side-by-side with activities that risk certain death.

This is how schools put out memos to their parents that kids will only be allowed to do cartwheels, somersaults, and handstands if there's a trained gymnastics instructor overseeing them. Because after centuries of kids tumbling ass over teakettle to no ill effects, we worry that one day one child may (or may not ... probably not) get a slight knock on the noggin. That's progress for you.

What do you think of these rules? Stupid or safe?


Image via Bitterjug/Flickr

back to school, activities, safety, sports


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Todd Vrancic

Somebody probably sued the school after their precious snowflake got a bump doing a somersault.

nonmember avatar Cee

It is probably just the school protecting itself from THAT mom.

jagam... jagamama0710

Unbelievably stupid. Overprotective, sue-happy parents suck.

nonmember avatar Mike M

This kind of attitude will become more common in the future. Rock Hudson's spirit was channeled by Elisa Medhus a while ago and he spoke of a future life of his (in 2079) where people typically spend little time outdoors aside from traveling from place to place. The details can be found online by searching for "channeling rock hudson part three" (first hit on Google and Bing).

nonmember avatar Another Guest

Smh. Why don't they just put the kids in bubble wrap before sending them outside?

qlarue qlarue

I'm a Girl Scout leader and do not allow the girls to do these when they are with us.  I'm not going to be the person held responsible for that bump or bruise or broken anything when the girl falls.  They can do whatever they want at home, but not on my watch.

work4... work4mickey

we restrict active play and then wonder why our kids are overweight.

SuzyB... SuzyBarno

So stupid! Let our kids play. I know parents who hover and have a super hard time letting their kids play at a park. They are anxiety ridden and you know what, those are the kids who fall and get terribly hurt because they have no confidence in themselves to do anything, so they end up falling because they give up half way thru. I actually had a mom ask me if I was scared my daughter would fall and break an arm. I said "no, and if she does we will handle it". I believe we have to let our kids discover their own limits, that's how they build confidence and self awareness. Stupid rule!

Nycti... Nyctimene

LOLLL and the government is still spending millions of dollars scratching their head and doing studies to figure out why American kids are so fat. They're not allowed to do ANYTHING!

No dodgeball, no Red Rover, no cartwheels, no sommersaults, no handstands, no jump rope, no hopscotch. A lot of the climbing apparatus are being removed.

But why are our kids so fat?!?!?!

1-10 of 13 comments 12 Last