It's hard to watch the video of middle school bus monitor Karen Klein being bullied by a crew of nasty kids and not get angry. Like many Americans, the imagery of a 68-year-old Klein brought to tears by their disgusting taunts sent me hurtling back in time to my own days in the torture chamber that is a bus ride when you're the bullies' favorite target. But folks, angry isn't going to fix this.
Death threats aren't going to fix this. Let me repeat that. Death threats are being hurled at a bunch of 11- and 12-year-old children. Because as cruel and vile as these kids were acting, every bully on that Athena Middle School bus is just that. A child. And the bullies who have taken over the conversation about what happened to Karen Klein do more to explain how this horrific incident happened in the first place than they do to fix it.
It doesn't take a whole lot of digging into kids' psyches to understand that kid bullies pick up their bad behavior from somewhere. And that somewhere is the adults who role model poor attitudes. So what happens when adults respond to a bunch of middle schoolers bullying their bus monitor with more bullying?
The bad behavior is multiplied tenfold. This hurts the kids in Greece, New York, but it goes much further. Thanks to the cruel people on the Internet, kids around the nation are getting the message that the best way to react to a bad situation is with anger, threats ... essentially with MORE bullying.
There are no lessons learned, no positives, at least not for society. Sure, some of the kids have apologized to the bus monitor, as they should. I'm glad to hear that their parents and the school district seem to be taking this whole incident seriously.
But let's remember, these are just kids. Even Klein herself said she wanted an apology but did not think they were bad kids, at least not deep down. She doesn't even want to press charges against the middle school bullies, despite the fact that they dredged up the pain of her child's suicide.
This doesn't excuse their actions. But it does put them in the proper light. Remember when you were a kid and you did something stupid? You learned more from some firm discipline from a calm, collected parent than from someone screaming in your face, didn't you? These middle schoolers need to see someone acting like the "bigger person," rather than sinking to their level if they're going to unlearn their bad habits.
We have a chance here to teach the kids on that bus, and kids around the world, that the kind of verbal abuse delivered on Karen Klein is not acceptable. We can't make what happened to her go away -- no matter how much money we throw at her -- but we can catch kids while they're still young, while their minds are still pliable, and teach them how to treat one another.
But as long as we approach these kids with anger and vitriol, they aren't getting that message. We are just creating more bullies.
Take a look at some of the aftermath of this story:
What is your response to the kids on that bus? What would you like to say to them?


Ashley Is a Widow Who Stays Strong...
This Hot Dad Wants to Vacuum Your Rug
This Hot Dad Wants to Do Your Ironing
KStew Refuses to Shower
















Comments 41
I'm sorry, but I STILL think that they should be made to walk to school for at least a full school year. Nothing like consequences to teach a kid an important lesson...babying them and making the excuse that they're just kids will teach them exactly NOTHING.
these kids should be removed from the school bus this is a privilege for these Bad kids..............
If any of my 3 children ever did anything so cruel, I would punish them, they would have to apologize in writing not only to the poor lady that they tortured, but to everyone on the bus and their parents, the bus driver, their principle, their teacher, their father, to myself, their priest, and to themselves. Then I would sentence them to hundreds of hours of community service, helping the elderly, or doing whatever the community needed. That behavior is not tolerated in my home. Where did these children learn this "hate" from?
I have no compassion for these children.. if more kids have to deal with what they dish out we wouldn't have all these problems with bullying. I don't believe in the bible but I strongly believe in doing unto others as you would have done unto you.
Another thing about this whole story that bothers me is that fact that this woman is obviously not an effective bus monitor, she couldn't even settle a situation directed at her and she is expected to be able to handle a whole bus of middle school children? I think it is sad that that role in this situation is not being scrutinized. If teachers, bus monitors, any person in a position of authority is letting children get away with this kind of behavior they shouldn't be doing the job.. anther problem with kids these days.
I think the idea of unusual punishment is what needs to happn. I agree with some posters that said they don't need to ride the school bus again. Their parents should have to bring them to and from school and if they want to go on a field trip they would have to come to and bring their child.....this should happen for a minimum of 6 months...after that if they even start to taunt ANYONE then they will never ride again. Thing is, if they are willing to do this to an adult then they are willing to do it to other students. That's what scares me more.
As much as it might sound like an eye for an eye, I think they should have some embarrassment placed on them in the form of unusual punishment. I'm thinking duct tape on their mouth with the words 'I couldn't say anything nice, so I'm not allowed to say anything at all' on the duct tape. They would have to wear this at school for a week and it can only be taken off for meals and they wouldn't be allowed to speak then either.
Death threats are obviously too much. But there is no excuse for this behavior and it's time to drop the "each child is a special little snowflake" crap and think that them saying sorry is enough. Give kids some credit. They are not as stupid or as incapable of knowing right and wrong as adults like to think. They know this was horrible and they probably thought they were safe from any real punishment. And they would have been right, too, had this made the internet.
I have no compassion for children like this. I hope they learn from this and I don't wish permanent harm to befall them, but I most definitely think anger is warrented.