It's been said that the mommy wars come down to one thing: jealousy. And I'm going to admit it. This working mom is hella jealous of the stay-at-home moms who are able to spend time in their kids' classrooms. I have to duck my head in shame on open house night when the teacher calls for volunteers, but I would love to be more involved in my kid's education.
Isn't that the best thing for kids? Involved parents? You'd think. And yet, a Virginia legislator is currently crafting a law to make it mandatory to let parents into their kids' classrooms because there are schools that are actually turning away moms like me. And a little surveying of some moms around the country reveals this isn't just a problem in the Old Dominion State.
For reasons that varied from "it's district policy" to "the teacher picked her favorites," parents haven't been allowed to get a look at how things work day-to-day in their kid's classroom. And I know just how they feel -- like they're missing a piece of the puzzle.
Although the horrifying story out of Los Angeles yesterday about the teacher who allegedly abused dozens of kids inside the classroom made most parents question just what's going on at school, this isn't about trust for me. I met my daughter's teacher at the open house, had a nice conversation with her on parent/teacher night, and we've chatted via email and phone. She's been nothing but helpful, and I'm confident in her abilities.
And yet, it's frustrating to depend on an intermediary to get a picture of the dynamics of a classroom.
I can (and do) ask my 6-year-old. But let's face it, she's 6! She leaves things out. She forgets. She tells things "her way." And she is just a wee bit dramatic.
The only real way to get a sense of her day-to-day, how she interacts with her peers (and they with her), and what is truth vs. a 6-year-old's version of it is to actually enter a classroom and see it with my own eyes. Last year I was able to use a vacation day from work to volunteer during a classroom party, and just that hour or two changed my perspective entirely. I can't wait to do the same thing later this month in first grade.
It's a hard thing for parents to send their kids off in the morning and then try to piece together the story of their day from the dribs and drabs of information we collect after they get off the bus. Even one day of observation in a classroom can help make us more informed parents, and thus more involved. That's exactly what kids need, but even more to the point, it's what teachers need to actually get their jobs done.
In fact Patrick Hope's proposal in Virginia sounds like it would help a lot of parents and teachers both. It would help educators control the visits -- teachers have to get "reasonable notice" and there can only be "minimized disruption" for parents -- and help the parents in one fell swoop. I can't imagine any district saying no to something like this.
Do you visit your child's classroom? How has it benefited your family?
Image via sambo854/Flickr
A Dad's Perspective on Playdates
Bagged Salad Recall Sparks New Fears
Help Dying 4-Year-Old Fulfill His Bucket List (VIDEO)
Melissa McCarthy & Sandra Bullock's Buddy Cop Movie
Do Working Moms Have It Easy?
Your Morning Coffee Could Save Your Life
Join the Fight Against Toxic Kids' Products
8 Summery Sweet Popsicles You Can Make at Home
Guy Gets Chest Waxed on National TV (VIDEO)
14 Ways to Be a Happier Mom
How Tarot Cards Cured My Nightmares
Robin Gibbs Dies: 5 Greatest Bee Gees Songs (VIDEOS)
A User's Manual for My Daughter to Remember Me By
Stupid Reason #768 Kids Get Suspended From School (VIDEO)
Mom Confession: I Never Wanted to Be a Mother
Backstage at Mamma Mia! with Irene Bunis
Vampire Sex and Vajazzling (it's...
Raising Digital Kids
Best Father-Daughter Dance Ever!

Comments (16)
if you want to see how your child really interacts, you need to visit without her knowing you are there.
How about a camera for all schools? That way we can protect the children and keep teachers safe from false accusations.
When I was a kid there were no classroom volunteers, I think my mother saw my K teacher all of three times (orientation, first day drop off, and parents evening) and after that it was pretty much just parents night. Maybe if they'd had volunteers my K teacher couldn't have been so abusive (screaming, refusing to allow bathroom visits, taunting kids) and she might have not even been tempted. One rookie teacher controlling 30 five year old kids, not a good situation for anyone.
I absolutely plan to volunteer at my kids' schools (which is still a long way off; my son is 16 months old, and my second is still five months from being born...). I currently work five days a week and my fiance recently asked if I was planning on returning to full time when the kids are in school. If we can still afford for me to work three days a week, I plan to continue just so I can have time to volunteer. I can't imagine having to sending my young kids off to school every day and having to clue what's going on. That would be so hard!
I have mixed feelings about parental involvement in the classroom. I think it should be kept to a minimum. here are my reasonings from my own personal observations -some parents are 'too' involved and they end up causing disruption, teachers need to be allowed to teach and not worry about 'hosting' parents, kids and parents need to learn how to be without each other for hours a day. I know many moms who live vicariously through their children - experiencing elementary school all over again, however, I have been there done this. My child needs her own life, aside from the family unit. To have parents come in for special events or when extra help is required is great, but for the moms who just need a place to go everyday in order to feel better, then they need a hobby.
parental involvement is great. it is the unwarranted help that is the problem. There are too many hellicopter parents out there and not enough parents that just want to honestly help in the classroom. Volunteer parents have to remember that they can not give their own child special attention when helping in the classroom it is not fair to the teacher, the other students, or their own child.
Trust the judgement of your childs teacher, if you have questions ask her/him. If there is a problem let her know and if she doesn't do anything than talk to the principal.
The law in your state sounds silly but teachers need to be protected from crazed parents jus as students need to be protected from bad teachers.
I volunteer at school for both my boys, and plan to do so also for my 2 daughters when they are school-age. Teachers at the school usually ask for parent volunteers and I think it's important for the kids to see that I am involved, even if just for a couple of hours a week, in their school community. That being said, all adults need to understand where they are and act accordingly. I am there to help the teacher, so I do as she asks and we don't engage in random conversation. I would be wary of teachers who don't allow parents in the classroom as a blanket policy. What are they hiding? It doesn't make you a "helicopter parent" to offer your skills to a teacher. I have a PhD in Chemistry, but I've chosen to quit work to raise my kids and their teachers so far have been very happy to have my help. I understand some parents are annoying and intrusive, but some teachers really are awful. Both should find something else to do.
I go about once a month. Yesterday it was to drop off cupcake for my son's birthday. Tomorrow it will be a Parent, Teacher, Admin conference over adding work to our vacation (I want them to send me stufff).
teachers don't deserve privacy with my child... I am not a busy body stay at home mom. Dont tell me what is too much. I dont interfere with the teacher, and absolutely expect my child to respect and listen to her teachers and to the help they get, but by no means better BAN ME from my child! i will absolutely HOMESCHOOL. fuck that! i will not comment back and i am about done with all these people thinking ALL teachers are blessed- My oldest daughter has had a wonderful school experience, her teachers have let me knw wht she has done and what she is capable of. I respect teachers, especially the good ones. A good teacher KNOWS to have parents back up and volunteer is a god send, but there are those parents who do over hover their kids. And im pretty sure a good teacher knws when to have them back up. I am proud of my oldest daughter, she has excellent teachers. But the minute one tells me i cant see them, they are in for a fight.