Disturbing Photos of Kids Will Make You Uncomfortable

42
jonathan hobin photo kids 9/11

"The Twins"

Does this photo of two little boys in their playroom reenacting one of the most horrible days in American history -- 9/11 -- make you uncomfortable? Us too. But I'm pretty sure that's the point Canadian photographer Jonathan Hobin is trying to make in his photography series In the Playroom, which includes kids playing Abu-Ghraib, Hurricane Katrina, and many other disturbing news-related stories too.

jonathan hobin photo kids Abu graib

"A Boo Grave"

jonathan hobin photo kids Hurricane Katrina

"The Saints"

 Here's how Hobin explains his work:

"In the Playroom" is a metaphor for the impossibility of a protective space safe from the reach of modern media. The quizzical disposition of youth and the pervasive nature of the media are symbolically represented in my images through tableau-vivant re-enactments of the very current events that adults might wish to keep out of their child’s world. Just as children make a game of pretending to be adults as a way to prepare and ultimately take on these roles in later life, so too do they explore things that they hear or see, whether or not they completely understand the magnitude of the event or the implications of their play.

While I'm pretty sure I wouldn't hang one of these photographs on my living room wall, I completely get where the artist is coming from -- and well, I agree and find his message to be a very important one for parents. Kids understand way more than we think they do, and what they don't understand, they figure through a variety of learning techniques, one being through play. Even when it's scary. Especially when it doesn't make any sense to them.

Hobin is making a very bold statement with these images, and it makes us uncomfortable because it's true. We know our kids are piecing together the ugly truths that we only begin to understand in adulthood, and that scares the crap out of us. When I was a kid, my friends and I explored many adult themes through play, including sex, abduction, rape, prostitution, poverty, child abuse, and more. And those are just the themes we explored with Barbies.

Kids are going play out life's scariest stories -- whether in their minds or in their playrooms -- and we as parents ought to be prepared for the day we walk in and see it in action. We cannot turn away from our kids if we find them figuring things out in a way that disturbs us or feels too mature, and for that reason, we should look long and hard at these photographs and think about what we will do, instead of turn away.

What's your reaction to these photos?


Images via jhobin.com; artwork available at the Dale Smith Gallery 

in the news, books & media, activities

42 Comments

To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

nonmember avatar WaltzingMtilda

Yea, while this is all deep and stuff, to me it basically comes across as anti-America propaganda.

butte... butterflyfreak

Well, the photos aren't showing up on here so I went through the link. The pictures are disturbing, as they are meant to be. Also, thought- provoking, again, as they are meant to be. I have always believed that children are smarter and have a better understanding of what's going on than we adults think or want to believe and these photos illustrate that, in a very dramatic way.

butte... butterflymkm

Very creepy. But profound. Anyone else think that in the first photo the plane kid has a really evil look to him? I think they are a great look into America from a child's eyes.

starglo starglo

I think, while disturbing to see kids like this, these photos are amazing!  They mean so many different things!  Kids see everything, kids understand more than we think, kids hear everything... etc.

Momo77 Momo77

Disturbing but amazing photography, Just shows what kind of world kids grow up in.

081109 081109

It makes me think of what I always tell my hubby about our son.  "He's young but he's not stupid."  

there... theresaphilly

A little disturbing, but I kind of like them. Kids eyes in photo one looks a little creepy!

Freela Freela

I don't think it's anti-American propaganda, especially since the 'Seal Heart' pic is obviously aimed at former Gov General Adrienne Clarkson and her support of the seal hunt.  I do think it's ironic that he posed children in these images to protest kids' exposure to media depicting these events!

tinyp... tinypossum

I'm not a fan of using children in this sort of manipulative manner just to make a point and shock people. I think it is disturbing and inappropriate and I wonder at the parents who let their kids appear in these photos. Stage mom, much?

Anast... Anastazia975

Amazing pictures!! That speak volumes!

1-10 of 42 comments 12345 Last