Do Jewish People Have Christmas Trees?

Big Kid 6

It's that glorious time of year when some families light up their menorah, sing their prayers, and eat latkes while others choose fir trees, cover them with ornaments, and bake cookies.

Of course there is a third kind of family -- my kind of family -- who does everything and spends most of the season pretty confused about how to handle competing and not-at-all compatible belief systems.

Welcome to my yearly nightmare. Most of the year, my husband I are the happiest couple on the block, but every December, he wants a tree and I want a menorah and it all becomes a weird gray area reserved for the Interfaith among us. Did I mention I'm interfaith twice? My mother converted to marry my father, making me technically Jewish, but my experience with and memories of midnight mass and Christmas cookies are probably about four times greater than the average Jewish adult's.

So what do we do with all this confusion?

  • Celebrate both equally: This is a key point because, really, if we're all Santa is AWESOME while we spark up the tree and give the kids major gifts on December 25, Hanukkah is going to look like the crap holiday. Since Hanukkah usually gets its bum kicked anyway (sorry, it's true), make sure you give the kids some of the bigger gifts during those eight nights, too.
  • Hang out with other mixed-up families: Make sure your kids are not the only ones rocking both the Hanukkah bush and the Jesus menorah (just kidding on the last one). This video gives a good explanation of what it's like to be a Jewish person buying a tree, but for interfaith families, it's even more confusing. Just make sure your kids aren't alone. Most reform synagogues or more liberal churches will have seminars and workshops for families who celebrate all the holidays. Attend. There is less confusion in numbers.
  • Start your own traditions: This one is key. The night you decorate the tree, also play dreidel. If you do an advent calendar, incorporate it into your Hanukkah nights. It seems crazy and mixed up, but when you own it and explain it to your kids, they will get it. It's unique, not weird!
  • REALLY celebrate each: This one is hard, but important. It works better if the family member whose religion is represented gets that holiday. However, both parents should be present. I have many painful memories of my Jewish father grimacing while my mom's family sang "Silent Night." No one is expecting Jewish people to get baptized, but a smile won't kill you. Do it for the kids.
  • Don't worry about the neighbors: You say you're Jewish and then hang Christmas lights. You light the menorah, but call yourself Catholic. We know. It's confusing. Your neighbors may look at you funny and some may ask questions, but there is no one right way to do things as an interfaith couple.
  • Choose one: Ultimately, it's important that the kids know they're one religion or the other (sorry, folks). This is not crucial, but it does make it easier all year round. Celebrate the holidays, but make sure only one gets the house of worship treatment. Do Hanukkah at home and attend mass on Christmas if you choose Christian. Or go to temple for Hanukkah, but do Christmas at home. Trying to give both religious messages just confuses kids.

Unless you have a better solution, in which case, I'm all ears. How do you do both?

Happy Hanukkah tonight!

 

Image via Facebook

activities, kid activities

6 Comments

To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

ChEMOM ChEMOM

So its my husband who is Jewish and he will not get into Hannukkah (apparently he and his parents believe that it is a minor holiday blown way out of proportion because of its proximity to christmas) which leaves me trying to get everyone in the spirit with no luck coz I don't know what I am doing..... We do do pretty big celebrations for the other major holidays like passover yom kippur and the other one that I forgot.....? (day of atonement unless that is yom kippur??) I am thinking that we will celebrate just christmas in December and celebrate the real Jewish holidays where they fall in the year.

poshkat poshkat

i dont agree with the last one. i believe that choosing one over the other is wrong. i am jewish, grew up in israel with every jewish holiday being celebrated as big as the last one. my husband is a catholic, he grew up with christmas being centered around santa and easter was of course the easter bunny. we celebrate both equally, christmas and hannuka have been mashed into christmaka and santa brings the presents on christmas, and hannuka harry (thank you SNL!!) bring the hannuka presents. its just the way it worked out for us. my son will know both and celebrate both. now we just need to find a joint name for easter and passover and we'll be good

Jennifer Riley

Hubby is catholic, and I'm Jewish, so here's our perspective: Christmas: Arguably one of the most important holidays to the Christian faith; Chanukah: not even a holiday, just a festival (see 1st commenter's husband's remarks, as he is mega-correct).  We celebrate both, but Christmas is a way bigger deal.  However, Yom Kippur is a bigger deal than either of them, as I'm more religious than he is.


The moral of the story is whatever works for you.  Every interfaith couple has the opportunity to share the best parts of their religions, and raise the most tolerant and culturally-relativistic kids.


PS: @ChEMOM: Yom Kippur is the day of atonement, you're probably thinking of Rosh Hashanah (new year).

ethan... ethans_momma06

We celebrate both as well. Hannukah is centered around the Religious holiday that it is. No presents for the kids during this holiday because that isn't what Hannukah is about (except for Gelt).


It's not a competition between the two holidays in our house. Each one is given importance, each is celebrated. But they are celebrated differently. That certainly doesn't make one better then the other. But I think you have some good tips.

frysh... fryshannon34

Never had to try both so far

Carey... Carey2006

I just try to ask my Jewish friends and honor their traditions as best I can.

1-6 of 6 comments