Jessica Simpson vs. Scarlett Johansson: Whose Makeup-Free Mag Cover Is the Best?

Photo by Marie Claire 

Photo by Popaholic

As summer rolls around, all the mags start doing their traditional makeup-free or unretouched covers. We showed you Scarlett Johansson in last year's Elle and Jessica Simpson in this month's Marie Claire in the buff ... on their face, that is.

Whose makeup-free cover do you think looks the best?

I vote for Jessica Simpson! There's no doubt that both gals are gorg, but I totally admire JSim for going au natural, especially with all the criticism she gets on a daily basis. It was like a big "FU!" to those who bash her.

Plus, JSim's cover is a straight-on head shot. Brave gal.

I have to say that I love all these confident women bearing it all ... like Kim Kardashian's unphotoshopped nude shoot with Harper's Bazaar.

Could the media be coming around to natural "real" women? Esquire did just place ultra-curvy Christina Hendricks of Mad Men on the cover of the Women issue...

Poll Results

Question: Who's Makeup-free Cover is the Best?

Jessica's

44%

Scarlett's

28%

Both look awesome

28%

I think all cover models should wear makeup

0%

Total Votes: 18

Only CafeMom members can vote on polls.
Sign up for an account or Click here to log in.

Poll

Who's Makeup-free Cover is the Best?

Jessica's

Scarlett's

Both look awesome

I think all cover models should wear makeup

Only CafeMom members can vote on polls.
Sign up for an account or Click here to log in.

Total Votes: 18

View Results