Gross Diaperless Baby Trend Means City-Dwellers Should Watch Their Step

Ewww! 58

diaperless babiesWhen my sons were babies, I remember reading about elimination communication -- the practice, according to the Wikipedia definition, of using timing, signals, cues, and intuition to address an infant's need to eliminate waste -- and thinking to myself, those parents are fucking nuts. Not, well that's certainly a different path than what I choose but we're all special snowflakes! Just: They. Are. NUTS.

I'm not quite so prone to snap judgments about such things now that I'm not personally responsible for dealing with every substance that comes out of my children's rear ends, but when I read this recent article on how urban EC-loving parents are dealing with their babies' inevitable public messes, I'm right back to thinking that this is a truly crazy trend. Because if you're happy to let your child take a non-diapered dump AT A RESTAURANT TABLE ... well, I'm sorry, your lifestyle choices are infringing on my right to eat a non-feces-scented salad and THAT'S NOT OKAY.

For those who are unfamiliar with what elimination communication (or EC, as it's often called) is all about, it's basically about watching your baby for signs that he or she needs to eliminate, and attempting to "catch" the waste via potty chairs, bowls, sinks, or what have you. EC practicers communicate special sounds to their babies (usually an "ssss" or "shhh" sound) in order to create an association between the sounds and feeling relieved.

Advocates say this practice enhances interaction and communication between parents and babies, and can cut way back on diaper-related downsides like rashes, expense, and environmental concerns. They also point out that it's hardly a new trend, being as how about half of the world's children (mostly in Asia and Africa) never wear diapers.

The downside (well, in my mind, one of the MANY downsides) is that an infant's muscles aren't typically developed enough for independent toilet training before they turn 2. So that's a pretty good stretch of time where you have to personally project manage your kid's waste cycles.

As for how parents deal with the challenge of a diaperless baby in public, some city dwellers simply let their babies use the street as their own private restroom. As one mom put it,

Sometimes the thrill of being able to go outside and pee is just what [babies] need. In the suburbs people set up potties in the trunk of their cars. That made me jealous. But in New York no one cares what you are doing. You can hold your baby to pee pretty much anywhere. Especially since few people would have any idea what you are doing.

Another mom said she would try to use a bathroom first, but otherwise, a park or drainage area would suffice:

We would get off the subway, I would take him into the toilet. Sometimes there were times it was hard to find a public bathroom in New York. Asking to use bathrooms helped me get over shyness. (At parks and playgrounds) finding a little area of grass or some bushes was good. I’ve not owned a dog in the city, but I can relate. I would try not to have him pee on the sidewalk. I would try to find a drain pipe ... on the corner of streets.

Last but not least is this story from an EC mom who took her diaperless baby out to eat:

The other day we accidentally left the house without putting her in a diaper before going to a restaurant. We peed her on the sidewalk, but she wouldn’t go. Then we tucked a pre-fold [cloth diaper] under her [at the restaurant table]. We were in a place where we didn’t want her to go and we didn’t want people talking about it.

Okay. Okaaaayyyyyy. I'm ... yeah, I'm pretty grossed out by the idea of letting babies pee and poop all over city streets. Yes, dogs are doing this too, but ... what, are dogs the gold standard now? And just because no one cares what you're doing doesn't make it okay, for crying out loud. (I bet the person who accidentally steps in your child's puddle DOES care, actually.)

Plus, a non-diapered infant at a restaurant table? Dude, that's crossing a line. It's one thing if your baby is bare-bottomed in your own home and you're the one who gets to "sss" all day long and rush to and from the potty chair, it's something else entirely to "pee" your baby on a SIDEWALK then cross your fingers there isn't an uncovered blowout as you enjoy your meal.

In conclusion, ew. And also, I think you owe New York an apology, street-peeing EC moms.

What do you think about elimination communication? Are you okay with babies peeing and pooping outside?


Image via lkonstanski/Flickr

poop & diapers

58 Comments

To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Katy Khan

Doesn't bother me, just don't do it indoors.

Amanda Solita Shovlin

to each his own. I have no problem with it. both my kids have used diapers. son potty trained at 3.5 and my daughter is 26 months and showing signs that she is ready. Now we use cloth diapers so I'm sorta crunchy lol. I have no problem with the kids peeing outside. It's the pooing and the fact that they have thier babies private parts out for all to see. It's a horrible thing that in this day and age we have to be afraid of our infant daughters going topless or our babies of either gender being changed in public or even naked in our own yards and having some weird pervert trying to catch a peek. yes the poo in resteraunt is gross, but I would be more concerned with the naked in public part. Not for modesty sake but for all those perverted people out there.

Bryony A. Hughes

Gross! people get highly upset when a pet owner doesn't clean up after their pet. Not to mention most parks have designated areas where dogs can do their business. There is a reason why people don't pee and poo in the streets, it spreads disease and its unsanitary.  Just because animals do it, doesn't mean people should teach their children that they should as well. I don't like stepping in dog poo and I surely wouldn't want to step in baby poo!

Serab... Serabelle

I don't usually care how other people raise their kids, breastfeeding, formula feeding, cosleeping, ferber method, whatevs as far as I'm concerned, but this is gross. Do what you want in your home, but if you're in public, slap a freekin diaper on that kid! As someone that spent many years in food service, if someone's undiapered offspring shit on my table I would be pissed! That violates so many health codes, it boggles my mind. Just not ok.

Lisa Topper Baker

Hey lobus - relax and re-read what she wrote. ``It's one thing if your baby is bare-bottomed in your own home and you're the one who gets to "sss" all day long and rush to and from the potty chair, it's something else entirely to "pee" your baby on a SIDEWALK then cross your fingers there isn't an uncovered blowout as you enjoy your meal.`` So call her ``ignorant`` but you clearly state that you did exactly as she suggested (ec at home, diaper in public), so it sounds to me like you`re the ignorant one in this situation. Or maybe comprehending what you read is only for rocket scientists.

Lynette Lynette

The people that I know who EC have their babies wear cloth diapers when away from home.   I don't EC but I think it's fine that others do.

jec72579 jec72579

I think that it is just going wayyy too far in the " oh, it's not the norm, so I think I'll try it, so I can get attention" thing. My God people, can you even raise your children normally? People are crazy!

nonmember avatar Stephanie.r.e

This sounds disgusting. I'm with serabelle. I usually couldn't care less how others parent their kids but this kind of weird crap is the thing that makes me judge other parents. I can't imagine being in the house of a person that does this.

nonmember avatar kellie

I don't think some of these comments are very thought out or fair. jec72579 and Stephanie, mothers faced the same sort of criticism for breastfeeding in the 60s. "Why can't you use a bottle like a normal mom?" "Letting your baby suck on your breast is just weird." My MIL remembers being treated poorly by nurses in the hospital for breastfeeding. She was the only mother there who didn't use a bottle.

If parents want to EC who are we to point fingers and judge?

Eliminating waste in public areas is something that needs to be dealt with better and I share concern about that. I think poo especially needs to be contained. Pee in the grass doesn't really bother me. I think, to be fair, the babies should follow the same rules as other humans on where to eliminate waste.

Mama2... Mama2MonkeyBoys

I agree that if you want to do this in your own home, fine. But I'm absolutely appalled that anyone would think it's ok to, essentially, train their children to think it's fine to poop on the grass in a public park, or pee on the sidewalk.


Gross and stupid.

1-10 of 58 comments 12345 Last
F