Formula Is Deadly for Some Babies But This Isn't a Rant About Breastfeeding

Health Check 19

newborn feetWe all know breast is best when it comes to feeding our babies. This is just fact and not a statement to make anyone feel bad. Formula was created to feed babies when mom isn't going to breastfeed for whatever reason. We shouldn't rag on moms who go the formula route, either. It's also a fact that not every single mom can breastfeed. What we should all agree on is that formula needs to be better, safer for babies. Because what we have now isn't good enough and has been proven to be toxic to some infants. This is the saddest fact. A recent study revealed that the digestion of formula can be so toxic it can lead to cellular death, also known as cytotoxicity, and could cause a baby to die.

Instead of panicking, we need to do something. I have some ideas. Formula can be especially dangerous for premature babies because they aren't fully developed yet at birth. And what's so heartbreaking is that many times when a woman has a preemie, her body sometimes doesn't produce enough milk.

The stress of having a preterm baby isn't good for milk production, plus many moms have preemies because they get sick during pregnancy, which could also make breastfeeding challenging. So we need to figure out why some pregnant women are getting sick, coming down with preeclampsia and other ailments that put their pregnancy at risk. That could prevent many preterm babies and help more women carry to full-term.

This is also a good reason why no one should ever schedule an induction for an early delivery.

We've known that preemies who are fed formula are more likely to develop cellular damage in their intestines, what they call necrotizing enterocolitis. It's the leading cause of death in preterm babies, but they never knew why it happened to formula fed babies and not breastfed babies. Now they believe they do. It's the free fatty acids in formula that is toxic for some, and essentially damages the cell membranes of premature babies and infants with compromised health. The damage happens within five minutes of digestion, which is frightening. Right away, when a preemie has formula, there is cellular death, and that could lead to big problems and, in some babies, death. Healthy and full-term babies seem to have a barrier in their intestines that prevent this when digesting formula. Breast milk, when digested, has a component to it that appears to prevent cytotoxicity.

This should also make us realize how sensitive our babies' bodies are, particularly their intestines, and this is why we should wait to introduce solids until at least 6 months.

Now, knowing this, it will put even more pressure on moms to breastfeed. And that could be both good and bad. Good because some who didn't even want to try nursing their baby would give it a shot. Bad because of the stress. The mom guilt. The what if. Which is exactly why we have to fight for better formula or, better yet, more human milk banks so babies can get mama's milk from another mama. We need better and more accessible ways for moms who can and are willing to donate their breastmilk to be able to do so. And until our breastmilk donor banks are overflowing with breastmilk to feed all the babies that need it, we need to develop a formula that poses less risk and doesn't kill off cells, and harm our babies.

So what do we need to do? Keep pregnant women healthy, find cure for preeclampsia. Breastfeed if we can. Give support to moms who need it. Donate breastmilk if you can. Demand safer formula. This is a tough to-do list, but our lives and our babies' lives are worth it.

What do you think of these findings? Will you demand safer formula?


Image via Markus Reinhardt/Flickr

breastfeeding, formula, in the news, natural parenting


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

B1Bomber B1Bomber

This may be the least condescending pro-breastfeeding article I've ever seen. Bravo.

CPN322 CPN322

I like this article. I think it was well written and took every moms feelings into account. Well done.

randh... randhferedinos

I still would always prefer donor milk over formula. But yes, safer formula is a must.

GirlN... GirlNamedBillie

Robble, robble, robble, article says something bad about formula, robble, robble, robble, says moms are bad for using formula, robble, robble, robble.

These articles are always going to be mis-interpreted by people looking for an arguement, lol, very informative article.

corri... corrinacs

I really liked this article too, but I don't think it totally takes int oaccount everything.  I know that Similac has created a formula specifically made for premies that addresses just this sort of thing.  And what is a mother to do?

I would always have to say no to donor milk because of my children's history of food allergies.  Hopefully I am never in this situation.  Hopefully formula companies see this need and can make the protiens and fats easier to digest.

Albond86 Albond86

We do need better, safer formula, more encouragement to seek donor milk, AND better support, education, and services for moms who want to breast feed! 

miche... micheledo

I remember reading an article about a hospital that only gave preemies breastmilk. It is an enormous cost, buying the screened product, but the hospital actually discovered they were saving millions! The babies had less complications and were going home sooner. I would love to see more hospitals follow this model.

gem09... gem092011

Great article. The fairly recent introduction of synthetic DHA in formula (basically for marketing purposes to "compete" with breastmilk) is terrible. Google how it's made and what it does digestion wise to babies. Super scary. And it's hard to find formula without this fake DHA on the shelves! It's all about marketing/competition and not about the babies. :(

I plan on donating my breastmilk when my little guy is done breastfeeding. I would love to help a baby avoid formula if possible. :)

nonmember avatar MO Mom

"This is not a rant about breastfeeding." Bull.

1-10 of 19 comments 12 Last